Themes: Romanticism of War

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

In line after line, Shaw satirizes the romantic notions about war that glorify a grisly business. If not for the comic dialogue, the audience would more easily recognize that they are being presented with a soldier who has escaped from a horrific battle after three days of being under fire. He is exhausted, starving, and being pursued. Such is the experience of a real soldier. Late in the play, Shaw throws in a gruesome report on the death of the man who told Bluntschli’s secret about staying in Raina’s bedroom; there is nothing comic or heroic about being shot in the hip and then burned to death. When Raina expresses horror at such a death, Sergius adds, “And how ridiculous! Oh, war! War! The dream of patriots and heroes! A fraud, Bluntschli, a hollow sham.” This kind of description caused Shaw’s critics to accuse him of baseness, of trying to destroy the heroic concept. That a soldier would prefer food to cartridges in his belt was considered ludicrous by critics, but in the introduction to Plays: Pleasant and Unpleasant, Shaw was reported to have said that all he had to do was introduce any doubters to the first six real soldiers they came across, and his stage soldier would prove authentic.

It is also noteworthy that Catherine is dissatisfied with a peace treaty because, in her unrealistic vision of glorious war, there is supposed to be a crushing rout of the enemy followed by celebrations of a heroic victory. Shaw’s message here is that there can be peaceful alternatives to perpetual fighting. He was dedicated throughout his life to curbing violence, especially that of wars, and Arms and the Man was one of the vehicles he used to plead his case.

Expert Q&A

What does the quote "nine soldiers out of ten were born fools" mean in Arms and the Man?

In George Bernard Shaw's "Arms and the Man," the quote "nine soldiers out of ten were born fools" signifies Bluntschli's philosophy of war and soldiering. Bluntschli, who carries chocolate instead of bullets, believes that most soldiers are fools for considering war as glorious and heroic. He views war as a terrible waste and battles as won not by talent but by lesser incompetence. This sentiment echoes Shaw's own views, who wrote the play to refute the romanticized perception of war and to argue against its utility.

Discuss the themes of "Romanticism of war" and "Romanticism of love" in Arms and the Man.

In "Arms and the Man," the themes of "Romanticism of war" and "Romanticism of love" are explored through Raina's idealized views. She sees her fiancé, Sergius, as a heroic figure, embodying the romantic notions of war. Initially, she dismisses Bluntschli for his pragmatic approach to battle, but later falls for him, challenging her romantic ideals. The play critiques these romanticized views, especially as World War I highlighted the harsh realities of war.

The portrayal and satire of love and war in "Arms and the Man."

In "Arms and the Man," George Bernard Shaw satirizes romanticized notions of love and war. Through characters like Raina and Bluntschli, Shaw exposes the absurdity of idealized heroism and romantic love, highlighting the discrepancy between reality and perception. The play critiques the glorification of war and the unrealistic expectations of love, emphasizing practicality and honesty over illusion.

Why does the speaker in "Arms and the Man" reject cartridges in battle and what alternative does he carry?

The speaker in "Arms and the Man" rejects cartridges in battle because he believes experienced soldiers know they are more likely to starve than be shot. Instead, he carries food, understanding that survival often depends on having sustenance rather than ammunition. This perspective highlights the ironic and harsh realities of war.

How does Shaw reconsider romance and heroism in "Arms and the Man" through realism?

Shaw uses realism in "Arms and the Man" to challenge romanticized notions of love and heroism. Characters like Raina and Sergius initially hold idealized views of war and romance, influenced by literature. The arrival of Bluntschli, a pragmatic mercenary, exposes the harsh realities, showing war's unglamorous nature and the superficiality of romantic ideals. Bluntschli, embodying realism, becomes the true hero, revealing the emptiness of conventional heroism and romance.

Shaw's "Arms and the Man" as an Anti-Romantic Comedy

Shaw's "Arms and the Man" is an anti-romantic comedy because it satirizes romanticized notions of love and war. The play critiques the unrealistic ideals held by its characters, showcasing the absurdities of their romantic fantasies and heroic perceptions. Through humor and irony, Shaw exposes the impracticality and folly of romantic idealism, contrasting it with the more pragmatic and human aspects of life.

How does Shaw criticize war in Arms and the Man?

Shaw criticizes war in "Arms and the Man" by satirizing its romanticization, using humor to expose the absurdity of glorifying war's horrors. Through witty dialogue, he challenges societal values and prejudices, portraying characters with realistic, cynical views of war. Some audiences deemed these portrayals unrealistic, but Shaw countered by suggesting they meet real soldiers to understand the true nature of war. His critique targets the glamorization of death and suffering in war.

Themes in Arms and the Man and their optimistic or pessimistic nature

Arms and the Man explores themes such as the futility of war, the illusion of heroism, and the contrast between romanticism and realism. These themes are presented with a generally optimistic nature, as the play ultimately promotes the idea that love and common sense prevail over romanticized notions of war and heroism.

Get Ahead with eNotes

Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Previous

Themes: All Themes

Next

Themes: Romanticism of Love

Loading...