Themes: False Ideals of Warfare

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

Arms and the Man is most obviously an attack on the false ideals of warfare and the soldier’s profession. Late nineteenth century British society, especially the aristocratic element, tended to see war as noble and soldiers as brave, courageous, fearing nothing—resolved to conquer or die. Many military melodramas of the period upheld these virtues, but they were performed for a civilian audience; soldiers themselves did not think this way, as Shaw has Bluntschli make clear. Not a pacifist, Shaw is not opposed to war when necessary, but he does demand that it be seen for what it is—war makes men tired and hungry, afraid and nervous. In the person of Bluntschli and in his comments about battle, Shaw establishes the opposition with Raina and Sergius, the arch romantics of the play. The satire of the play is aimed at the poetic view of war and the soldier and at the commonplace conjunction between the soldier, aristocracy, and love. These were the staples of the standard military melodrama of the period; here, Raina breaks the pattern in which only the brave deserve the fair and chooses for her mate the practical, professional, middle-class Bluntschli.

Expert Q&A

What does the chocolate-cream soldier in Arms and the Man call 'unprofessional' and why?

The chocolate-cream soldier in Arms and the Man calls Sergius' leading a cavalry charge into a machine gun nest 'unprofessional' because it is tactically foolish and dangerous. Although the charge succeeded by accident due to the enemy's lack of proper ammunition, such actions are generally considered impractical and laughable in professional military strategy.

In Arms and the Man by George Bernard Shaw, what does 'they make cannons out of cherry trees' mean?

In George Bernard Shaw's play, "they make cannons out of cherry trees" refers to the resourcefulness of Bulgarian soldiers during the April Uprising against the Ottoman Empire, using available materials like cherry trees for weaponry. This line, spoken by Captain Bluntschli, highlights his surprise at Bulgarian customs and symbolizes his frustration with unconventional military practices and the prominent role of women, reflecting broader themes of gender and societal norms in the play.

Get Ahead with eNotes

Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Previous

Themes: Idealism versus Realism

Next

Themes: Anti-Romantic View of Life

Loading...