Themes: Justice

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

Aside from being a piece of classic literature, a religious and mythological text, and a piece of Greek theater, Antigone is also a deeply political work concerned with the nature of justice, specifically within the Greek city-state. A topic concerning much of ancient Greek philosophy is the ways in which an ideal state ought to be organized in order to best ensure human flourishing and divine blessing. Many Greek philosophers posited an ideal city-state that is organized in a way that mirrors the cosmos themselves, with human interaction as the medium between the heavens and the crude matter of the world. In this regard, Sophocles was no different. Antigone was written, at least in part, to serve as an example of Zeus’s divine justice for the city-state; specifically, it offers an answer to the question of how the state may best achieve political authority within the confines of divine piety.

In order to engage with this question, Sophocles creates a conflict between Antigone, who represents the will of the gods, and Creon, who represents the state of Thebes. By virtue of being a traitor and a blood family member simultaneously, Polynices serves as a means of conflict between these two archetypes. Antigone adopts the unyielding perspective that Polynices must be buried as if he were one of their own, and Creon remains similarly unyielding in his position that Polynices is an enemy to the state and must be treated as such. Sophocles attempts to provide an answer for how Thebes ought to ensure justice in such a scenario by showing the self-destructive results of any immovable conflict between two perspectives upheld by Zeus.

Through the ensuing tragedy, the audience comes to understand that what both Antigone and Creon lack all along is respect for each other’s perspectives. Antigone, despite being pious, nonetheless defies a king, whose power is upheld by Zeus. Creon, conversely, is the justified ruler of Thebes, but he nonetheless defies the demands of the gods. Zeus’s true justice, therefore, must exist somewhere in the middle of these two perspectives. In this way, Thebes can become a place that upholds political law only insofar as the demands of piety allows, and is only as pious as due respect for the laws of the city-state allow. This is the nature of the justice that Sophocles hopes to show his audience.

Expert Q&A

What is the meaning of Sentry's words in Antigone: "How dreadful it is when the right judge judges wrong!"?

Sentry's words highlight the tragedy of a leader making poor decisions despite holding a position of authority. In "Antigone," this reflects Creon's failure to balance power with justice, leading to destructive outcomes. The phrase emphasizes the dual role of "judge" as both a noun (authority) and a verb (decision-making), suggesting that even rightful rulers can err if they don't apply wisdom and fairness in their judgments. This theme parallels Teiresias' warning in "Oedipus."

Why does Haemon believe Antigone shouldn't be punished?

Haemon argues against punishing Antigone because her actions, driven by compassion and adherence to divine law, should be seen as noble rather than criminal. He contends that the people support Antigone's decision to bury her brother, and as a ruler, Creon should heed public opinion. Haemon also emphasizes the importance of flexibility in leadership, suggesting that Creon should be open to changing his mind and showing mercy.

Discuss the moral positions of Antigone and Creon in Antigone, validating Hegel's assessment of a tragic collision of right against right.

I think that Hegel's assessment of the drama is true to the form, and resonates with the intended effects of Sophocles' play. Creon: " I have said it before. / The law must be obeyed. And I will see to it / That everyone obeys it. No one is above / The law, not even those who guard it." I think that this short quote captures Creon's idealistic conception of what politics and government ought to be like. For Creon, a leader serves to uphold the law, and any attempt to circumvent or change that law in some way undermines society as a whole.

In Antigone, what conduct was Zeus punishing?

Zeus punishes Creon for his arrogance and failure to adhere to divine laws, specifically the denial of proper burial rites for Polyneices. Tiresias, the prophet, warns Creon that the gods are displeased with his actions and refusal to bury Polyneices, which defies the gods' laws. The gods, especially Zeus, despise hubris and the breaking of divine commandments, prompting them to threaten Creon with the loss of his son unless he rectifies his mistakes.

Can someone explain this quote from Antigone?

You cannot learn of any man the soul, the mind, and the intent until he shows his practice of government and law. For I believe that who controls the state and does not hold to the best plans of all, but locks his tongue up through some kind of fear, that he is the worst of all who are or were.

This quote from "Antigone" suggests that one cannot truly understand a person's character—soul, mind, and intentions—until they demonstrate their ability to govern and uphold laws. It critiques those in power who do not pursue the best interests of the state due to fear, labeling them as the worst individuals. It emphasizes that true character is revealed through leadership and protection of others, not merely through words.

How does "doing the right thing" not necessarily lead to happiness in the play, Antigone?

Antigone must die for doing the right thing and she is happy to do so. The chorus describes her death as a just one, because of her courage and nobility.

Get Ahead with eNotes

Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Previous

Themes: Gender Roles

Next

Themes: Tragic Hero

Loading...