In Antigone, what are examples of human vs. human and human vs. society conflicts?
In the opening scene of Sophocles's drama, the discussion between Antigone and Ismene reveals different examples of conflict.
As the drama opens, both sisters are struggling with the law that Creon has passed. The edict forbids a proper burial for their brother, Polynices. A restriction against his receiving proper rites has become the law of the land. Antigone's insistence on challenging this law demonstrates a human vs. society conflict. Antigone represents this conflict in her willingness to break the law to honor what she feels is right and just:
Be whatever you want, and I will bury him.
It seems fair to me to die doing it.
I will lie dear to him, with one dear to me,
a holy outlaw, since I must please those
below a longer time than people here,
for I shall lie there forever. You, though,
dishonor the gods' commands, if you wish.
Antigone's declaration to her sister about her purpose in burying her brother represents her conflict with society's expectation. It is for this reason that she calls herself a "holy outlaw." She refers to herself this way because she knows that her actions will break society's laws, with which she is in conflict. Antigone is further fomenting a conflict with society because she is challenging the social expectation for women. When Antigone initially tells Ismene of her plans to honor their brother, Ismene says that she does not feel comfortable supporting Antigone because "we should not fight with men" and "that we are ruled by more powerful people / and must obey them." Antigone dismisses this social expectation. Antigone believes that carrying out the will of the gods and her duty as a sister are more important than conforming to what society expects out of her as a woman. In both ways, Antigone brings about the conflict of human versus society.
In the collision between Antigone's and Ismene's beliefs, a human vs. human conflict emerges. As both sisters talk, this gulf becomes more pronounced:
If you say this, you will be hateful to me,
and the dead will hate you always–justly.
But let me and my foolish plans suffer(95)
this terrible thing, for I shall succumb
to nothing so awful as a shameful death.
Antigone's stance causes her to break from her sister. This conflict is seen in language such as "you'll be hateful to me." There is little room for negotiation, as Antigone has clearly picked a divergent path from her sister's path. This conflict is further seen in how she curses Ismene with her line "the dead will hate you always--justly." Antigone is in profound conflict with her sister and accordingly carves out her position. The difference between the thoughts and actions of these sisters is an example of a human versus human conflict.
Where is the 'human vs. self' conflict found in Antigone?
In the Greek tragedy Antigone by Sophocles, Creon's primary conflict is with himself, although he doesn't see it that way until the end of the play. He believes he is struggling with Antigone, Haemon, and Tiresias, but his own ego and stubbornness are what cause the play's conflict. Throughout the play, Creon decides again and again to follow his own counsel rather than listen to others. He continues to lose the human vs. self conflict every time he has an opportunity to rise above his selfish conviction of his own supremacy. After Haemon and Eurydice have both committed suicide, Creon understands the source of all the conflict, and upon the news of Eurydice's death he wails:
Ah me, this guilt can never be fixed on any other of mortal kind, for my acquittal! I, even I, was thy slayer, wretched that I am-I own the truth. Lead me away, O my servants, lead me hence with all speed, whose life is but as death!
At this point, he has no one to blame, and although he previously repented of his obstinacy and provided Polynices with a proper burial and sought to free Antigone from the tomb, his enlightenment came too late. Now he is burdened with guilt for the deaths of the two people he loved most, and that is a human vs. self conflict that will presumably continue for the rest of his life.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.