Critical Context

(Critical Edition of Young Adult Fiction)

Judson was an established author whose works included approximately seventeen juvenile biographies of famous Americans when she wrote Andrew Carnegie. The awards and honors bestowed on Judson’s work included the naming of three of her juvenile biographies as Newbery Honor Books, and she was given the Laura Ingalls Wilder Award for her lasting contribution to children’s literature in 1960. Writing fictionalized biographies for juveniles after careful research of diaries, letters, records, localities, and personalities, Judson produced books that were popular at publication, reprinted several times, and cited as outstanding examples of the genre.

Judson’s purpose in writing these books was to show young readers American leaders of dedication and vision. Early in her career, Judson became interested in the contributions of American immigrants. Carnegie, an exemplary businessman and Scottish immigrant, easily fit her writing goals and won her admiration. His interesting and eventful life embodied virtues such as fairness and generosity that made Carnegie’s story an appealing choice for a juvenile biography. Other books had already been written about Carnegie, notably Katherine B. Shippen’s Andrew Carnegie and the Age of Steel (1958), but Judson believed that she could write about his life from a fresh perspective.

Biographies that employ fictionalized dialogue based on facts, such as Judson’s Andrew Carnegie, can enliven history for young readers. Reading such biographies for pleasure can lead to a discovery of the past and prepare young readers for more factual historical accounts.