Themes and Meanings

(Critical Guide to Poetry for Students)

Among Moore’s concerns in “An Octopus” is the view that writing is a phenomenon or an otherness analogous to the mountain. The reader’s approach to the poem would entail similar dilemmas to that of viewing the mountain. Moore explores to what extent one can avoid objectifying an object—that is, turning away from its complexities and changing it into something identifiable. The demand for identity must be resisted, Moore implies through the poem’s use of paradox, shifting perspectives, citations, and other devices. To resist identity, however, is not to give up “Relentless accuracy.” The unresolved and incomplete quality of the poem suggests that neither the mountain nor the poem can be seen fully. Moore does not consider this as failure, but rather a sign of the necessity for a relentless pursuit of accuracy as well as a demand for active curiosity.

“An Octopus” exemplifies Moore’s genius as an observer and a collector of observations. The naturalist’s desire for details is demonstrated with her use of citations about the environment of the mountain. Yet, importantly, Moore does not settle for simply a descriptive poem. Like her protégé, the poet Elizabeth Bishop, Moore was concerned with such metaphysical and aesthetic issues as uncertainty, provisionality, voice, the definition of self, and the processes of seeing. “An Octopus” explores each of these concerns while offering a meditation on writing. Moore offers a...

(The entire section is 475 words.)