To an Athlete Dying Young

by A. E. Housman

Start Free Trial

Discussion Topic

Tone and setting of "To an Athlete Dying Young"

Summary:

The tone of "To an Athlete Dying Young" is both melancholic and celebratory, reflecting on the premature death of a young athlete. The setting alternates between the public space of the town, where the athlete was celebrated, and the private space of the grave, symbolizing the transition from life to death and the fleeting nature of fame.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What is the tone of "To an Athlete Dying Young"?

At first, it seems that the tone of "To an Athlete Dying Young" is straightforwardly elegiac, the kind of tone one would expect from a poem written to commemorate the life of someone recently departed. As the early stanzas make clear, the young man was a local hero whose winning of a race brought immense joy to the people of his hometown.

But it isn't very long before a subtle change in tone can be observed. The day of the young man's funeral is described as celebratory, in much the same way as the town celebrated his remarkable feats of athleticism. The reason for this is that, because the athlete died young, his glory was never able to fade, and so can be preserved and celebrated by the local townsfolk.

Further irony can be observed in the third stanza, where the speaker strongly implies that the young man made a smart move in dying, by removing himself from the earth, a place where glory is fleeting. The further implication here is that the young man committed suicide before his glory, his looks, and his athleticism all started to fade.

In an ironic twist on the traditional elegy, Houseman appears to be celebrating the young man's premature death—as it will spare him immense pain, suffering, and decline later on—rather that commemorating his short, glorious life. In dying, the young man has been further spared having to live in a society which places too much importance on the attainment of ephemeral worldly achievements.

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What is the tone of "To an Athlete Dying Young"?

The tone of “To an Athlete Dying Young” is Housman’s characteristic combination of nostalgia, melancholy, and bitterness. The self-reflective quality of the verse is accentuated by the poet addressing one who cannot reply or even hear him. He is essentially talking to himself as he reflects on the futile and fleeting nature of glory. The triumphant shoulder-high progress of the athlete in the first stanza is followed immediately by his coffin, held at similar height along “the road all runners come.” There is barely even a moment for him to enjoy the glory of victory.

The nature of the poet’s bitterness, however, is made explicit in the third stanza, when the poet does not even mourn the athlete but commends him for abandoning life so early. Laurels whither quickly, Housman tells him. Glorious youth turns to obscure old age, a fate the athlete has avoided. The classical image that ends the poem returns the tone to melancholy again, but the overall tone is one of embittered age, envying rather than lamenting a young man’s death.

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What is the tone of "To an Athlete Dying Young"?

This poem is basically an address to a young athlete who once received the praise and glory of his town because of his victory. However, now he is being remembered in a different way, because he is being held high in his own funeral procession. The speaker however argues that the athlete was lucky to have died, as he went out at his best moment in life and will not live to see his name forgotten with time. Because he died at his strongest, he will be able to amaze the dead with his beauty that will never fade.

The tone, therefore, of this great poem is one of sadness and sombre reflection as the speaker remembers the life of this athlete who was snatched away in his prime. Arguably, the poem ends on a hopeful note, as the speaker contemplates how he will be able to receive eternal glory and adulation through his death.

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What words describe the setting of "To an Athlete Dying Young"?

Housman's poem offers only the slightest description of the setting, which has the effect of universalizing it: the action takes place in a small town, but it could be almost any town at anytime.

Description uses the five senses of sight, sound, taste, touch, and smell to allow us to imagine a scene. Words that describe setting in this poem include "chaired," "man and boy stood cheering by," and "marketplace." We can picture the crowds as the triumphant young athlete is paraded through the town lifted up high. It would be a glorious feeling for the young man. "Cheering" describes the sound following the athlete on his victory walk.

The same setting is described in the second stanza, but this time the sound is much "stiller" because the athlete is being brought through town in a coffin held high on people's shoulders. We can imagine the hush.

After the first two stanzas, the poem moves to become a meditation on dying young, but another important description of the new setting is "low lintel." A lintel is a horizontal support beam at the top of a structure. In this case, the low lintel refers to the headstone at the top of the grave in which the athlete is buried.

See eNotes Ad-Free

Start your 48-hour free trial to get access to more than 30,000 additional guides and more than 350,000 Homework Help questions answered by our experts.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Last Updated on