Last Reviewed on February 25, 2020, by eNotes Editorial. Word Count: 1753
All That Fall is a one-act radio play, written in 1956, by Samuel Beckett. Beckett wrote the play after being commissioned by the BBC, and the first production was broadcast in 1957.
During his lifetime, Beckett was insistent that this “is a text written to come out of the dark,” and he refused to allow any theatrical stage productions of it. He even turned down Laurence Olivier and Joan Plowright when they asked him if they could produce it as a play. Later, however, he finally agreed to allow it to be performed live, but only if the radio play was performed as a radio play that the audience happened to be watching. He put this stricture in his will, and it has been honored (more or less) to this day.
At the time, as he wrote it, Beckett confided in a friend:
Never thought about Radio play technique but in the dead of t’other night got a nice gruesome idea full of cart wheels and dragging of feet and puffing and panting which may or may not lead to something.
As the radio play begins, we first hear a succession of barnyard animals, the sort you might hear in the countryside. We hear a sheep, a chicken, a cow, a horse, and a dog. The voices of the animals, per Beckett's script, are all performed by actors. They create a barnyard cacophony; then their cries slowly fall away, and we hear the dragging foot and rhythmic pants and grunts of Maddie Rooney.
The music of "Death and the Maiden," by Franz Schubert, rises as Maddie draws near the home where it is playing. She passes by and sings the sad music to herself. She stops when she hears the clappety-clap (again, from an actor) of a horse and cart drawing near. It is Christy, a neighbor. The two chat for a bit, and he tries to sell her some nice dung from his cart.
We are in Boghill, Ireland, a fictitious suburban commuter village based on Foxrock, a town outside of Dublin, where Beckett grew up. Though Beckett had lived in France and written several works in French before this radio play, here he decided to write in English again and created a thoroughly Irish story and set of characters. When All That Fall was performed in his lifetime, Beckett approached various lead actresses (such as Billie Whitelaw, who did a later production) and asked them to be sure to use a very thick Irish brogue while playing Maddie Rooney.
There is an air of intense theatricality and exaggeration about Maddie as she walks to the train station to meet her husband, Dan. She is grotesquely overdramatic about the emotional and existential pain she feels. She stops mid-road and exclaims,
MRS. ROONEY: What will become of me? Oh I am just a hysterical old hag . . . destroyed with sorrow and pining and gentility and church-going and fat and rheumatism and childlessness.
Maddie is obese, which is why we hear her foot dragging as she struggles along the road. In the script of All That Fall, Beckett mentions that Maddie is “dragging her feet” several times, and over and again we hear the rhythmic pace of her unsteady gait. She stops and tussles with her corset, then shouts at a fellow she has met along the road:
MRS. ROONEY: Come back and unlace me behind the hedge! (laughter) Oh what’s wrong with me. To be in atoms, atoms. Jesus, Jesus.
Everything today is reminding Maddie of her daughter, Minnie. She and Dan’s little girl died forty years before, but Maddie’s suffering remains fresh and keen. In fact, this is the anniversary of the day Minnie died. It is also her the birthday of her husband, Dan. Wisely or not, Maddie has decided to walk to the train station to meet her husband and give him a birthday surprise. But her mood swings wildly from moment to moment. She drags to a halt and says,
MRS. ROONEY: It is all flooding over her again. She simply went back home. Straight back home.
Speaking of herself in the third person, it is as though Maddie is verbally telling the story about herself as she lives it. This air of heightened theatricality continues throughout the play. Maddie is so distraught that she becomes confused with reality. She meets several people en route to the station, and she accidentally calls at least two different men “Rooney,” the name of her husband. She corrects herself quickly both times. Age is catching up with Maddie Rooney. She stops and moans,
MRS. ROONEY: How can I go on, I cannot. Oh let me just plop down at on the road like a big fat jelly out of a bowl and never move again! A great big slop thick with grit and dust and flies, they would have to scoop me up with a shovel.
We have not met her husband yet, but she stops and tells him, and us,
MRS. ROONEY: Love, that is all I asked, a little love, daily, twice daily, fifty years of twice daily love . . . A peck on the jaw at morning, near the ear, and another at the evening, peck, peck, till you grow whiskers on you.
Beckett’s drama uses these grotesque audio devices, episodes, and characters to indicate the irrationality and absurdity of life. Maddie is lonely and sad; she seeks love; she is uncomfortable with her body; she misses her daughter. Her exclamation of “Christ, what a planet!” encapsulates Beckett’s vision of a frightening, alienating world.
When Maddie arrives at the train station, the train is late. She has to wait. But finally the train arrives, fifteen minutes late, and she greets her husband, Dan. When she asks him why the train was so late, he brusquely tells her he has no idea why.
Dan is blind and walks with a cane, which we hear clacking on the ground as he moves forward. Now, as Dan and Maddie walk together, we hear her dragging foot and his clacking cane, and in between their dialogue all we hear are the sounds of the two of them, walking down staircases and along the road. As their scene together progresses, Beckett adds something else to the soundscape: the light added tom of a drum, like an echo, that accompanies his cane clack and her foot thud, creating a steady, droning beat that feels funereal and inexorable, as they walk home.
Dan is a coarse, off-putting man. He pushes the world away, including Maddie. He is often sick and he meanly reminds Maddie:
MR. ROONEY: Did you ever know me to be well? The day you met me I should have been in bed. The day you proposed to me the doctors gave me up.
When Maddie tries to give him a birthday kiss, Dan shouts,
MR. ROONEY: Kiss you? In public? On the platform? Before the boy? Have you taken leave of your senses?
Dan would like nothing more than to spend the rest of his life sitting at home and doing nothing, “counting the hours till the next meal.” He doesn’t want to talk about Minnie, or his birthday, or anything. All he wants to do is walk home. So Maddie escorts him home, and they make the return journey. They struggle along, Dan almost falling down a staircase, Maddie fussing as she helps him. Maddie muses, “Why don’t we sit down somewhere? Are we afraid we may not rise again?”
The wind is blowing. Blind Dan forgets what direction he is facing, and Maddie blandly tells him he is staring into a ditch containing dead leaves.
“Dead leaves? In June?” Dan is surprised. Maddie bemoans a laburnum that is losing all its tassels. It seems their world is failing and falling. The first drops of rain come down, “cold and drizzle.” Nature is out of joint. “Put your arm around me, be nice to me,” Maddie asks. There is a pause, and then Maddie exclaims happily, “Oh, Dan!” Then they drag and cane and drum onward in the wind and rain.
As they near their home, the couple passes the house where the music "Death and the Maiden" is playing again. They stop and listen. Maddie notices that Dan is crying.
“Why are you crying?” Maddie asks.
“YES!” Dan shouts angrily at her. They do not speak of it again.
Jerry, a boy from the train station, runs up, to give Dan something he left on the train. It is, as Maddie describes, “like a ball, and yet it is not a ball.” Dan becomes angry again and tells her it is just something he carries around with him. Maddie has never seen it before. What it is is unclear. Maddie asks Jerry why the train was so late.
JERRY: It was a little child, Ma’am.
(Mr. Rooney groans)
MRS ROONEY: What do you mean, it was a little child?
JERRY: It was a little child fell out of the carriage, Ma’am. (Pause) Under the wheels, Ma’am.
The wind blows loudly. We hear Maddie’s foot and Dan’s cane for awhile. The wind blows more loudly still. The play is over, and nothing more is said.
Maddie has had plenty to say today, but she says nothing after she finds out about the accident on the train. We are left to wonder, uneasily, what happened on the train. Why does Dan have that ball that is not a ball? Why does he groan when he hears about the accident? Is it all because a child has died, and this is the anniversary of the death of their own child, or is there a darker reason for his anger today—did he toss the child off the train, as a monstrous vengeance upon the world for the death of his own child?
When Becket was asked about this much later, he said,
And the answer is we don’t know, at least I don’t . . . I know creatures are supposed to have no secrets for their authors, but I’m afraid mine for me have little else.
All That Fall, a “text written to come out of the dark,” is a haunting and at times wildly (and darkly) funny radio drama, eccentrically florid and Irish, full of despair and hope. Beckett’s brilliant use of sound, rhythm, music, and dialogue creates a richly imagined world that leaves a lasting impression even when the story is done.
Last Updated on May 5, 2015, by eNotes Editorial. Word Count: 666
All That Fall, a radio play, opens with a chorus of farm animals heard against Franz Schubert’s String Quartet, “Death and the Maiden,” and the shuffle of trudging feet. It is a Saturday morning in June, in the village of Boghill, Ireland, sometime during the 1950’s. Mrs. Rooney (nee Dunne) is on her painful way—she is overweight and in her seventies—to meet her blind husband at the local railway station, on this, his birthday. Since it is also a day for the Leopardstown horse races, everyone hopes that the weather will hold.
As she makes her slow way, she is pursued by memories of her daughter Minnie, dead for some forty years, and by nostalgia for sexual attention. A succession of acquaintances interrupt these ruminations, and Mrs. Rooney exchanges small talk with each about the weather and the day’s races, with recurring references to language, sterility, and impending dissolution. First comes Christy, a carter, riding a hinny-drawn cart, who offers her manure for her garden. Next, she is overtaken by a retired bill broker, Mr. Tyler, riding a bicycle. As they converse, they are covered by the dust thrown up by a grocer’s delivery van, which almost runs them over. Mr. Tyler’s commiserations with Mrs. Rooney are cut short by his anxiety about possibly missing the train, so he pedals ahead. Meanwhile, Mrs. Rooney persists in a series of grim reflections on sexual longings, aging, and death. Then Mr. Slocum, the clerk of the racecourse, draws up in his motor car and, after much travail, succeeds in squeezing Mrs. Rooney inside and restarting his vehicle. They roar off, only to run over a hen. At the station, Tommy the attendant helps to pry her from the vehicle.
While awaiting the 12:30 train, Mrs. Rooney encounters two more characters: Mr. Barrell, the stationmaster, and Miss Fitt, an eccentric spinster. Mr. Barrell politely inquires about her health and, hearing more details than he has patience for, goes about his business. At this point, Mrs. Rooney sees the self-absorbed and religious Miss Fitt, who is on her way to meet her mother at the train. Miss Fitt’s Christianity is a peculiar mixture of mysticism, bigotry, and meanness, but she is prevailed upon to help Mrs. Rooney up the station steps.
The train is now overdue: Mr. Barrell dismisses the rumor of an accident as a “hitch.” After further anxious delay for Mr. Tyler, Miss Fitt, and Mrs. Rooney, the train finally arrives, and Dan Rooney alights. He is led by Jerry, a boy hired to help him home. Mr. Rooney pays Jerry, and the two Rooneys commence their walk home. Carefully they descend the steps and, supporting each other, plod homeward. They pause several times to consider several subjects: Mr. Rooney’s ill-health, Mrs. Rooney’s fatness, their reading of Theodor Fontane’s Effi Briest (1895; English translation, 1914, 1962) and a sermon they have recently heard. This seemingly aimless conversation encounters several significant issues: Mrs. Rooney’s scarcely controlled eroticism, Mr. Rooney’s cruel obsessiveness, their affection for and dependence upon each other, their sardonically humorous view of their own debilities, and their religious skepticism. Mrs. Rooney tries to find out what delayed the train, and her husband by degrees confesses to a deadly enmity toward children. As Mr. Rooney recounts his daily routine, each detail reveals the yawning emptiness of life, its horror and boredom. Thus when they recall the text of the sermon (from Psalm 145: “The Lord upholdeth all that fall and raiseth up all that be bowed down”), they are consumed with derisive laughter at the absurd gap between the biblical promise and their own painful experience and bleak expectations.
Their laughter is interrupted by the boy Jerry, who lets it be known that the train’s delay was caused by the death of a child. The action ends with the implication that Mr. Rooney was somehow involved. The sound effects indicate that it has become a wet Saturday afternoon after all.
Last Updated on May 5, 2015, by eNotes Editorial. Word Count: 421
All That Fall was written at the suggestion of the BBC during the summer months of 1956 and, under the direction of Donald McWhinnie, was first broadcast January 13, 1957, on the Third Programme. It was immediately praised as a radio classic, although some critics were disconcerted by the “whodunit” ending.
Beckett’s drama in general has several distinctive features: limited action, sparse dialogue, reduction of interest in individual human character, the absence of conventional problem and resolution, a strong sense of the ritual origins of drama, and an awareness of the nature and conventions of drama itself. A meticulous craftsman, Beckett has taken a direct hand in the production of many of his plays.
In En attendant Godot (pb. 1952; Waiting for Godot, 1954), the most influential play since World War II, every detail of the action, every word and gesture, is existentially weighted and has a place in its grand symmetry. All That Fall is similarly designed, so that the more limited resources of sound, voice, and silence bear the same dismal freight; Beckett conceived All That Fall specifically for radio, so that it has no bodies, faces, or gestures, but only a set of interwoven voices emerging out of, and receding back into, the silence of the airwaves. Thus, the answer to the whodunit is designedly beyond reach, and listeners who expect an answer are taunted.
Mrs. Rooney’s journey to Boghill railway station to meet and accompany home her blind husband is dramatized after a pattern in which each element countermands its opposite. On her journey out, for example, she encounters a progression of vehicles (cart, bicycle, car, and train) as she moves up the social ladder (from Christy the carter, Mr. Tyler the retired bill broker, Mr. Slocum the clerk of the racecourse, to Mr. Barrell the stationmaster). As each of these means of transportation is breaking down, so are all of Mrs. Rooney’s experiences accompanied by a litany of death: Christy’s wife, Minnie, the hen, Slocum’s mother, the child in the train, the Gaelic language, and so on. Interwoven with these themes are the motifs of promise and frustration, rising and falling, desire and sterility, Christian hope and despair, in a state of permanent mutual antagonism. This June Saturday is at once a day of conception (it becomes a wet afternoon), of birth (Mr. Rooney’s), and of death (the child’s). All these themes are handled in characteristic Beckettian style: the horror and boredom of experience is alleviated by Mrs. Rooney’s scathing, self-lacerating, grim humor.
Last Updated on May 5, 2015, by eNotes Editorial. Word Count: 272
Village. Unnamed rural community in Ireland that serves as the peripheral setting of the play and establishes the foundation of its humor and tragedy. While Samuel Beckett’s dramatic themes are universal in scope, they are also rooted in his native Ireland.
Country road. Road to the village that is a dangerous and toilsome place—one on which a person might be run over by a passing motor van at any moment and whose dust and filth cling to people. In a broader sense, the country road mirrors the human condition as Beckett presents it—a place where every action is merely a hesitation before death. Parents rear children only to be struck down by disease or by the wheels of a train. Mrs. Rooney shuffles along the country road, suffering under the weight of her own body and the memory of her dead daughter, toward a meeting at the train station with her blind and embittered husband.
Boghill train station
Boghill train station. The station is initially a source of hope. Mrs. Rooney plans to surprise her husband on his birthday by meeting him there. It becomes, however, another source of death when she discovers that a child has fallen beneath a train’s wheels and has died—a tragedy that might have been caused by Mr. Rooney. Mrs. Rooney’s trip to the station also compels her to leave home, where she would prefer to stay, waiting for death to come, as she describes it, by a “drifting gently down in the higher life, and remembering, remembering . . . all the silly unhappiness . . . as though . . . it had never happened. . . .”
Last Updated on May 5, 2015, by eNotes Editorial. Word Count: 313
Alspaugh, David J. “The Symbolic Structure of Samuel Beckett’s All That Fall.” Modern Drama 9 (December, 1966): 324-332. An overview of the play’s features. Discussion focuses on the work’s plot, and on such themes as paternity and Christianity. The idea of movement in the play is also examined.
Bair, Deirdre. Samuel Beckett: A Biography, 1978.
Cohn, Ruby. Samuel Beckett: The Comic Gamut, 1962.
Federman, Raymond, and John Fletcher. Samuel Beckett, His Works and His Critics, 1970.
Fletcher, John. Samuel Beckett’s Art, 1967.
Fletcher, John, and John Spurling. Beckett the Playwright. Rev. ed. New York: Hill and Wang, 1985. A helpful introductory study of all of Beckett’s dramatic works, with a chapter on All That Fall. Discussion focuses on the work’s motifs of love and loss and on the wit of its complicated verbal play.
Kenner, Hugh. A Reader’s Guide to Samuel Beckett, 1973.
McWhinnie, Donald. The Art of Radio. London: Faber, 1969. The author produced the first broadcast of All That Fall. As well as general thoughts about radio as an artistic medium, detailed information regarding the play’s production is included. Of particular interest are the insights regarding the challenges of Beckett’s script.
Van Laan, Thomas F. “All That Fall as ‘a Play for Radio.’” Modern Drama 28 (March, 1985): 38-47. An analysis of how the play uses radio as an artistic idea. The ways in which language and action in All That Fall are significantly reshaped by the medium are discussed. The relationship of the play to the overall preoccupations of Beckett’s work is also explored.
Zilliacus, Clas. Beckett and Broadcasting. Abo, Finland: Abo Akademi, 1976. The definitive account of Beckett’s artistic and professional involvement with radio and television. Beckett’s thoughts about the various productions of his broadcast works are included. Detailed accounts of the productions are provided, including some illuminating commentary on the use of sound effects in All That Fall.