Themes: Guilt and Blame
Joe Keller’s culpability for his corrupt action in letting the defective parts ship is a driving force in this play. It is under the surface in the characters’ social interactions to the extent that the audience knows nothing about it until late in act 1. Yet it shapes everything that happens between the major characters. Kate does not want Annie around not only because she suspects her feelings for Chris, but also because she worries that Annie is a spy for her father, whom the courts blamed for what happened at the factory. Though George initially accepted Joe’s account of the story and the court’s decision that his father was to blame, he comes to question this when he speaks to his father. This is where the characters’ relationships began to explicitly destabilize. George forces Chris into a position of questioning whether his father is guilty. After that, the realization that the deaths of the twenty-one pilots were indeed Joe’s fault becomes the breaking point for Joe and Chris’s relationship and the ultimate cause of Joe’s suicide.
Expert Q&A
Why does Joe feel guilty in All My Sons?
In Arthur Miller’s All My Sons, Joe Keller feels guilty because he knows that he was responsible for the deaths of twenty-one pilots during World War II, was possibly responsible for the death of his son Larry, and his former business partner remains in prison, convicted for those deaths. Joe has tried desperately to rationalize his actions, and his family has heretofore stood by him, but he cannot, ultimately, escape responsibility.
How does survivor's guilt affect Chris, Joe, and Annie in All My Sons?
Survivor's guilt affects Chris and Annie in that feel guilty for moving on with their lives with each other when Chris's parents are still waiting for Larry to come home from the war. Joe has avoided survivor's guilt for years by telling himself he did what he had to do to protect his family, but the knowledge that he caused his son's death overwhelms him with guilt and results in his suicide.
What is Sue's opinion on Joe Keller's guilt, according to public opinion?
Sue believes the entire town is aware of Joe Keller's guilt regarding his wartime actions and letting another man take the blame. Her anger is directed towards Joe's son, Chris, whom she accuses of being complicit in his father's wrongdoing and benefiting from it. She considers Chris a phony and resents his relationship with her husband.
Is there a suitable punishment for Keller's crime?
Joe Keller's suicide can be seen as a suitable punishment for his crimes, as it is driven by overwhelming guilt for the deaths he caused and the betrayal of his family. His suicide serves as both an escape from living with his guilt and a form of justice, aligning with the "eye for an eye" principle. Ultimately, his death might facilitate healing and forgiveness for the surviving characters, allowing them to move forward.
In All My Sons, what is Kate Keller's and Jim Bayliss' culpability, knowing Joe's deceit and not acting?
In All My Sons, a view of the level of culpability shared by such characters as Kate Keller and Jim Bayliss for Joe's crime will depend on whether one thinks private loyalty is more important than public duty. A reasonable centrist position might be to say that, while they should not go to the authorities behind his back, they ought to confront Joe himself and demand that he face up to the consequences of his actions, which Kate eventually does.
Joe's justification of his actions and its connection to the themes of All My Sons
Joe justifies his actions by prioritizing his family's financial security, which he believes excuses his unethical decisions. This ties into the themes of moral responsibility and the consequences of placing personal gain over social duty, as depicted in All My Sons.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.
