Themes: Family
Family is the central theme of All My Sons. Every decision that Joe makes centers on the attempt to protect and support his family. The irony of the play is that, in the end, going too far to support his family becomes the cause of the Keller family’s destruction. When the choice of whether to let the defective parts ship out arises, Joe chooses what he perceives to be advantageous for his family: he tries to preserve his business’s reputation so that he can continue to make money for them in the short term and also pass the business on to Chris in good shape. But choosing family over honesty backfires in a devastating way for him.
First, Joe loses Larry. Although most of the characters thought that Larry had died in battle, when Chris reads Larry’s letter to Annie, they discover that his death had been a suicide. Larry killed himself because he could not bear the knowledge of his father’s corruption, particularly knowing that it had caused the deaths of fellow pilots. He could not live in the understanding that his father had chosen their family over honesty and compassion for others.
After Larry’s death, Kate becomes distant from both Joe and reality. She remains unable to accept that her son is dead because, as she reveals late in the play, that would also mean accepting that Joe was responsible for it. She believes that if Larry is dead, he must have died due to his father letting the defective parts ship.
Finally, Joe loses Chris as soon as Chris realizes the truth of what his father has done, that he really did knowingly let the defective parts ship. Chris initially decides not to turn him in. Yet he also makes it clear that they are no longer family when he announces he is moving away.
The horror and grief of having destroyed his family in an attempt to care for them is too much for Joe, leading to his suicide at the end of the play. The play’s title comes from his final realization that he should have treated the whole world like family. He should have viewed the pilots who flew in the crafts he helped build as “all my sons,” rather than exclusively protecting his biological family at the cost of everything else.
Expert Q&A
What's your interpretation of the "All My Sons" quote: "That's what a war does. I had two sons, now I got one."
The quote from "All My Sons" reflects Joe Keller's grief over losing his son Larry in the war, though the real tragedy lies in the cause of Larry's death. Unbeknownst to Joe, Larry committed suicide, unable to bear the guilt and shame of his father's provision of faulty parts to the military, which resulted in several deaths. Joe's immoral actions indirectly led to Larry's death, a fact he tries to deny by attributing the loss to war.
In "All My Sons", what does Mrs. Keller mean by telling Keller, "Be smart now, Joe. The boy is coming, be smart."
When Mrs. Keller tells Joe to "be smart," she is warning him about the impending visit from George Deever, who may want to reopen the case that implicated Steve Deever. Kate is anxious because George has visited his father in prison and may bring incriminating information. She fears Joe's relaxed demeanor and casual jokes about sensitive topics could lead to trouble under George's scrutiny, potentially exposing Joe's involvement in the crime.
In All My Sons, what are the effects of Kate's denial of Larry's death on the family?
In All My Sons, the effect of Kate's denial of Larry's death is to hold the family in stasis. Nobody can move forward and heal until they acknowledge Larry's death and why he killed himself. Kate's denial is harming everyone and making it difficult for Ann and Chris to marry.
What does Chris mean by the statement, "I know you're no worse than other men but I thought you were better. I never saw you as a man; I saw you as my father?"
"I know you're no worse than other men but I thought you were better. I never saw you as a man; I saw you as my father."
Chris's statement reflects his deep disappointment upon discovering his father's moral failings. He always saw his father, Joe, as an idealized figure rather than as a flawed human being. This realization shatters his perception and forces him to confront Joe's unethical actions. Chris's unrealistic expectations contributed to his disillusionment, ultimately leading to a strained relationship and Joe's tragic end.
What does Chris mean when he says he has been "a good son too long, a good sucker" in "All My Sons"?
When Chris says he has been "a good son too long, a good sucker" in "All My Sons," he is expressing his frustration at living under his father's influence and guilt. He feels he has been too obedient and complicit in Joe's cover-up of his crime, which led to the deaths of pilots, including possibly his brother Larry. Chris wants to assert his independence, live his own life, and no longer bear the weight of Joe's sins.
What is more important to Chris Keller than family in All My Sons?
In "All My Sons," Chris Keller values moral integrity, particularly honesty, over family. His deep commitment to these values becomes evident when confronted with the truth about his father's illegal actions during the war, which involved shipping defective parts that led to pilots' deaths. Chris's struggle with this revelation highlights his prioritization of moral principles over familial loyalty, ultimately leading him to consider leaving the family business and breaking off his engagement to protect his integrity.
Justification of the title All My Sons
The title All My Sons is justified as it reflects Joe Keller's realization that his responsibility extends beyond his own family to all the young men who died due to his actions. The title underscores the play's theme of social responsibility, emphasizing that Keller's moral obligations encompass all the soldiers, whom he metaphorically sees as his sons.
In All My Sons, how does Arthur Miller portray family relationships in crisis?
Arthur Miller portrays family relationships in crisis by highlighting the impact of Larry's disappearance on the Keller family. Kate Keller's refusal to accept Larry's death creates tension, especially as it hinders Chris and Ann's relationship. Her belief in Larry's return is tied to her denial of her husband's guilt in sending faulty parts to the war, which would implicate him in pilots' deaths, including potentially Larry's. This denial underscores the family's deep-seated issues and crisis.
In All My Sons, how does the unseen character, Larry, affect others?
In "All My Sons," the unseen character Larry profoundly impacts the other characters. His presumed death keeps his mother, Kate, in denial, preventing her from accepting Chris's proposal to Ann, whom she views as Larry's girl. Joe's guilt over his role in Larry's death ultimately leads to his suicide. Chris and Ann struggle with their feelings and loyalties due to Larry's memory, which serves as a barrier to their future. Larry's presence influences the family's inability to move forward.
What evidence from All My Sons suggests Joe's qualities as a father, neighbour, and husband?
Joe Keller in All My Sons is portrayed as a devoted father, striving to make his business successful to pass it on to his sons, suggesting his commitment to family legacy. As a neighbor, Joe is sociable and hospitable, inviting neighbors over, although they secretly doubt his innocence and view him as boastful. As a husband, Joe is flawed, requiring Kate to keep his dark secret, thus compromising her integrity and their marital trust.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.
