Discussion Topic

The depiction of family and its centrality to the tragedy in All My Sons

Summary:

In All My Sons, family is depicted as both a source of strength and a cause of tragedy. The Keller family's loyalty and secrecy lead to moral compromises and ultimately, Joe Keller's downfall. The centrality of family to the tragedy is highlighted by the devastating consequences of Joe's actions on his loved ones and the shattering of familial bonds.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Can you briefly describe the characters in All My Sons?

Joe Keller is the patriarch of the family, he is a self-made man, who worked his way up from worker to boss/owner.  He owns a factory that made airplane parts for the military during World War II.  He is a decent man, a family man, a hard worker.  Mostly Joe would be considered a real example of the average American, but he made a tragic mistake and then blamed it on someone else. 

Joe's behavior regarding the shipment of the faulty airplane parts and then fingering his employee, Steve Deever as the  culprit responsible for the criminal act which resulted in the deaths of several pilots flying planes withe the  faulty parts.  Joe got out of jail by lying about his role in the shipping of the airplane parts. 

Joe is a contradition, on the one hand he is honest, patriotic, loves his family, on the other hand, he is dishonest, manipulative and selfish, unwilling to risk losing his business to behave in a moral way.  If he had not shipped the airplane parts, his business would have gone under, but he would have been a honorable family man.  He puts his business, which he claims is all for his family, ahead of his own integrity, dignity and honesty.

Kate Keller, Joe's wife, the mother of Larry and Chris.  Kate suffers from a delusion a belief that Larry, who has been missing in action, is still alive.  His room is kept as a shrine, his clothes are ready to be worn, his shoes are shined.  Kate won't accept that Larry is dead.  She is abrasive towards her husband, during the early part of the play, she does not reveal that she knows that Joe is guilty.  Kate has more sense than Joe, she accepts the end result of Joe's decision.  Kate turns out to be more realistic than first thought.

Larry is missing in action and is never heard or seen in the play.  He is the son of Joe and Kate and brother to Chris.  Larry was engaged to Anne Deever, the daughter of Steve, the man that Joe blamed for the shipping of the faulty airplane parts to the military.  Larry is regarded as a hero, a tree is planted in the yard as a memorial to him.  Actually, Larry has committed suicide, and only Ann knows why.  She reveals all to the family, when Joe finds out that Larry killed himself because of what he did with the faulty airplane parts, he goes in the house and shoots himself dead.

Chris Keller is an idealist, a veteran of WWII who came home alive, Chris is guilty that his brother is missing and he is alive.  He believes that his father is an honest man, never doubting that Steve was the one who shipped the faulty parts.  Chris has summoned Anne Deever, Larry's girl, as Kate calls her, because he is in love with her, he has proposed marriage to her.  But Chris is unable to accept the truth about his father, and cannot bear to face Anne, he sends her away.

Jim is a neighbor who is a doctor, he is married to Sue, who despises Chris Keller for intruding on her life trying to get Jim to give up his medical practice and go into research.  Sue resents Chris for suggesting this because research pays a lot less than the medical practice.

Frank is another neighbor who prepares Larry's horoscope to support Kate Keller's belief that her son is still alive.

Bert is the little boy in the neighborhood that Joe Keller plays policeman and jail with, which irritates Kate Keller so much, she feels that he should not play such a game since he was in jail.  Bert really looks up to Joe as a hero.    

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

How is family life depicted in All My Sons?

Family life in All My Sons is presented as something difficult, treacherous, and full of emotional stress. The relations between almost everyone in the family are strained and revolve around failures and problems. While there are some deep bonds between family members, even those can be broken by the realization of wrong doing.

The play is a tragedy, and the central issue is one family's inability to cope with the death of a son, and the guilt and/or anger they feel over what happened.

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

How is family central to the tragedy in All My Sons?

On a more abstract note, the concepts of family and the father/son bond is challenged by the final scene of the play in which Joe realizes that Larry must have considered all the soldiers in the war the sons of Joe (and other fathers).  This idea broadens the definition of family to a realm in which we as a people are a collective family and thus have responsibilities to ensure the safety and well-being of all the members in that family.  From this perspective, Joe neglected his responsibilities to his collective family by ordering Herbert to mend and ship the faulty cylinders.

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

How is family central to the tragedy in All My Sons?

In All My Sons, the central conflict revolves around the Keller family.  First in the decision that Joe Keller made to ship the faulty cylinder heads to the military to preserve his business, he says he did it for his family.  And second, because the family, Joe, Kate and the unseen Larry dominate Chris Keller's life, suffocating any possibility of happiness he might have with Ann Deever. And, the family is at the heart of the American Dream, pursuit of a nice home, financial security, a car, all is done for the family. 

Joe Keller violates this creed by sacrificing everything, including his family to save his beloved factory from closing.  His surrenders his integrity, his morality and breaks the law to keep the factory open during the war, he says to support his family, to be able to pass the business on to his sons.

As far as Joe is concerned, Kate's belief that Larry is coming back and is alive is enough of a reason for Chris and Ann not to get married.  It is more important for Kate not to get upset about the reality that Larry is dead, three years missing in action, than for Chris, their other son, to get married, and be happy with Ann.

The family demands that Chris sacrifice his happiness at the altar in honor of his missing brother, who might someday return home.  But it is more than that, Chris and Joe know that Larry is not coming back, but they make Kate believe that they support her faith in the idea of Larry returning alive.

They are dishonest with her just to keep her from falling apart, but the sham comes at a high price for Chris who wants to break away from his parents and move on into his own life, make his own family.

 The family is also part of one of the main themes in the play, the American dream.  The pursuit of the American dream is motivated by the desire to provide for ones family.  Having a nice home, good job, financial security, all are for the sake of the family.  But Joe Keller's decision to ship faulty airplane parts to the military which results in the deaths of several pilots sacrifices the family's security in the name of keeping the business from failing.

In the play there is a debate as to whether Joe Keller loves his family or his factory more, it appears that he sacrificed everything for the factory.  When he finds out that his own son, Larry, could not bear the shame of his father's guilt at having committed a crime, causing the deaths of all those innocent soldiers, the pilots, Joe commits suicide. He is unable to bear the price that he paid to keep his factory running, to save his business, he lost his two sons, and then surrendered his own life to guilt and regret.    

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

How is family central to the tragedy in All My Sons?

It is clear from the very start of this play that family is crucial to this play, and more particularly to the character of Joe. It is clear that Joe takes deep enjoyment in his role as father and husband - these are roles that are centrally important to him. However, the tragedy of this play is linked to Joe's idea of duty and responsibility. In Joe's mind, duty and responsibility are inextricably intertwined with the material comfort of his family and the success of his business. For him to be a good father, he has to make his business work. And of course, we know that in a moment of weakness he puts these values above wider values such as his responsibility towards his fellow human beings.

Joe's decision to commit suicide at the end of the novel comes as a direct response of his realisation that the pilots that died as a consequence of the decisions he made were "all his sons", pushing the boundaries of the traditional family much further. It is also ironic that his decision to act for his family is what estranges his relationship with his son, Chris. Joe's act of suicide at the end of the novel is tragic in a number of senses: Joe is unable to cope with the estrangement between him and his son, but at the same time his death is desgined to spare Chris any further embarrassment at what his father has done.

See eNotes Ad-Free

Start your 48-hour free trial to get access to more than 30,000 additional guides and more than 350,000 Homework Help questions answered by our experts.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Last Updated on