Editor's Choice
How does All My Sons depict the relationship between men and women?
Quick answer:
The play depicts male-female relationships as complex and often dominated by patriarchal norms. Women, like Kate Keller, are portrayed in conventional roles, primarily as supportive wives and mothers, often subservient to their husbands. Despite knowing her husband's guilt, Kate supports Joe, highlighting her internalized obedience. However, she eventually becomes the voice of truth, urging Joe to confront his moral failures. The generational differences are evident in Chris and Ann's relationship, which contrasts with Joe and Kate's insincere dynamic.
On the surface, the role of women in All My Sons is fairly conventional. Women such as Kate Keller are confined to supportive roles as wives and mothers. To a large extent, they only live their lives through their children and their husbands; there's no sense that Kate has any real existence of her own. As a conventionally loyal and faithful wife, she willingly supports her husband despite knowing the full story about the faulty cylinder heads. In doing so, she refuses to confront the possibility that her beloved son Larry may have been killed as a result of her husband's greed.
Yet in the end, Kate becomes the voice of truth, getting Joe to face up to the moral consequences of his actions. It seems that Kate has finally realized that the patriarchal system to which she's given such outward obedience, and whose values she's internalized, is responsible for...
Unlock This Answer Now
Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.
Already a member? Log in here.
the immense suffering that has descended upon her family.
It seems there are two topics within your question: relations between men and women, and the main theme of the play.
While male-female relations are important in this play, there are other, possible main themes. The marriage of Joe and Kate provides much of the interpersonal conflict. Joe's actions, however, were so deeply dishonest on every level and had such devastating consequences that one main theme is the necessity to take personal responsibility. That theme is one that Miller treats in many of his works.
Although Miller created some strong female characters, male dominance characterizes gender relations in All My Sons. The difference between the generations is also evident in comparing Joe's relations with his wife, Kate, to his son Chris's interactions with Ann, whom he loves.
Kate is pining for her missing son. She needs to think of herself as a devoted mother first because that is the most highly valued social role. Instead, she is mainly subservient to her husband, to the extent that she pretends she doesn't know of his guilt. Pretending that Larry will return, while understanding he died because of Joe's crime, consumes her so much that she tries to block her other son's happiness. Joe puts her down constantly and promotes his own innocence, demanding her complicity.
Chris thinks they are all stuck in time and wants to move forward. Ann also understands the need to grow past the war and Larry's death, and she and Chris are generally able to communicate honestly. They try to face his parents together, realizing they need each other's strength to counter the toxic environment in which Joe and Kate are trapped.
In All My Sons, the relationship between Joe and Kate Keller is one based on lies, unquestioned support, blind faith. Kate has known all along about Joe's dishonesty, and even though she has witnessed the horrible injustices that have resulted from Joe's actions, she has kept his secret for many years. She has tried to have faith that her husband has made the right decision, and Joe has expected her as his wife to keep his confidence. Likewise, Kate is the only person who truly believes that Larry will some day come home, and although Chris and Joe are ready to accept the likelihood that Larry is dead, they maintain the facade of belief to spare Kate's feelings. So the relationship between the two is one based on insincerity.