Illustration of Paul Baumer in a German army uniform with a red background

All Quiet on the Western Front

by Erich Maria Remarque

Start Free Trial

Chapter 3 Summary

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

Paul’s regiment gets reinforcements. The new group of soldiers is settling in after receiving their gas masks and coffee. Many of them are young; Paul and his group are practically veterans compared to them. The new soldiers have been eating poorly and are hungry. They are overjoyed at the prospect of the beef and beans Katczinsky has bartered from Ginger (for three pieces of parachute silk) and stashed away for his own bartering. Next time the recruits will trade him something for a portion of the food.

Katczinsky (Kat) is an intuitive man who is invaluable to the men around him. When they find themselves in a warehouse with wire netting attached to wood beams as their beds, Kat finds them straw. When they are hungry and there is no food to be found, Kat finds bread and horsemeat. As he cooks it, he adds salt and fat, two other mysterious acquisitions. Kat also knows how to cook what he scrounges. Whatever the need is, Kat finds it. It is his gift and the men appreciate it.

The men are relaxing away from the fighting after having to do a saluting drill for an hour because one of them did not salute an officer well enough. They can see an air fight raging above them and place bets on who will win. Kat is of the opinion that if all men in the military were paid the same—if there were no officers—the war would be over in a day. Kropp believes the war should end with the war ministers and generals fighting to the death; the winning group would claim victory. They reminisce about their days of training, the sounds and the smells and the drills. A German plane is shot down in a blaze of fire, and Kropp loses the bet.

Himmelstoss is a power-hungry man, and the men discuss how it happens that an officer’s uniform turns a mere postman into a man obsessed with power. Kat reflects that the organization of the military demands there must always be a command structure in which one man has more power than the next. When a man uses that power in the military, even if other men are demeaned or humiliated, he is praised. In the civilian world, such things are not tolerated. And “the more insignificant a man has been in civil life the worse it takes him.” The men are amazed that soldiers keep fighting knowing there will certainly be more abuse. During battle, however, there is no drilling; as soon as the fighting is over, there is more drilling and more mistreatment, for a soldier must never be idle.

Himmelstoss is coming to the front, and Tjaden is particularly unhappy about it. He holds a “special grudge” because Himmelstoss tortured him and another soldier who wet their beds at night. He put them in wire bunks so that each night the one below would get wet from the other. His plan assumed they were simply lazy (which they were not), but ultimately it did not work. One of them simply slept on the floor, and they often caught colds. Paul and Haie recall an incident in which they humiliated Himmelstoss and never got caught. They found him alone and wrapped him in his own bed cover so he could neither see nor move. They pressed his head into a pillow but allowed him occasional breaths. They then pulled down his trousers and proceeded to whip him as he knelt on the ground in his striped drawers. They then boxed his ears and he left running. Himmelstoss never discovered who delivered his humiliation, but one of the old-timers described them as “young heroes.”

Expert Q&A

What does the quote "Give 'em all the same grub...done in a day" from chapter 3 mean?

The quote "Give 'em all the same grub...done in a day" from chapter 3 means that if politicians and leaders who start wars had to endure the same hardships as soldiers, wars would end quickly. Kat's ironic statement highlights the disparity between those who declare wars and those who fight them, suggesting that equal treatment would make leaders reconsider initiating conflicts.

What is the significance of this quote from Chapter 3 of All Quiet on the Western Front?

"Give 'em all the same grub and all the same pay/And the war would be over and done in a day"

The quote from Chapter 3 highlights the inequality between officers and enlisted men during World War I. Katczinsky believes that if all soldiers received equal pay and food, the war would quickly end, as those in power would lose their motivation. This sentiment underscores the novel's critique of war, portraying it as serving the interests of the powerful while common soldiers endure hardship. It reflects Remarque's broader theme of exposing the grim realities and futility of war.

In chapter 3 of All Quiet on the Western Front, what is Katczinsky's sixth sense?

Katczinsky's "sixth sense" refers to his uncanny ability to find essential supplies like food and bedding when others cannot. In Chapter 3, his resourcefulness is highlighted as he provides food for the starving recruits, seemingly guided by an instinctual compass. Although Paul exaggerates Kat's abilities, he emphasizes Kat's instinct for survival and his experience as a soldier, making him invaluable to his comrades.

What are Kropp and Kat's philosophies on war in Chapter Three of All Quiet on the Western Front?

In Chapter Three, Kat believes that equalizing conditions for soldiers, regardless of rank, would end wars quickly, reflecting his view of war's inequities. Kropp suggests that wars should be settled by the leaders who start them, fighting like a bullfight, rather than ordinary soldiers. Both philosophies criticize the senselessness of war, highlighting how soldiers are merely pawns in conflicts driven by those in power.

How is Katczinsky characterized in chapter three of All Quiet on the Western Front?

In chapter three, Katczinsky is characterized as resourceful and philosophical. He demonstrates his resourcefulness by acquiring beef and beans for his friends through bartering parachute silk. His philosophical side emerges through his belief that the war could end if commanding officers experienced the same conditions as enlisted men, suggesting equal treatment would hasten peace. Katczinsky also provides some levity in the otherwise grim narrative.

Get Ahead with eNotes

Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Previous

Chapter 2 Summary

Next

Chapter 4 Summary

Loading...