Student Question

What is the overall meaning of All the King's Men and why?

Quick answer:

As with any complex novel, All the King's Men is open to many interpretations, but a significant grouping of themes involves the ambiguity inherent in people's actions. As many commentators have noted, Jack Burden's story parallels that of his boss, Willie Stark. The actions of both men in some sense backfire, and although they both may be said to have had good intentions at the start, they have been corrupted by ambition and ego.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Perhaps even more than the assassination of Willie Stark, the suicide of Judge Irwin is the key event and the climax of All the King's Men.

When Jack Burden's mother screams, "You killed your father!," it becomes clear that the whole business of blackmailing the old judge is emblematic of Jack's fall and of the fact that Jack's life has been a lie in some sense.

Like Stark, Jack starts out with apparently good intentions. But as the adage states, power corrupts. Stark intends initially to serve and to help the people, but power goes to his head in a self-perpetuating process. As his aide, Jack goes along with him and does what he has to do, including blackmail.

Both Stark and Jack are protagonists, heroes if we will, but are morally ambiguous. Both know that they have done wrong. But throughout the story, Jack has cynically acted as if unaware that his actions will come back to haunt him. Even the fact that the woman he loves, Anne, has become Stark's mistress does not stop him from serving as Stark's chief operative.

Other characters as well, including Anne, Sadie, Jack's mother, and even the Judge, inhabit a moral borderland, a gray area where good and evil both are indulged in. That people—not only political leaders, but "ordinary" souls—more often than not are subject to this ambiguity is illustrated on a massive scale in the book.

The shock of the Judge's death, that he was the cause of it, and that the Judge was his father are the facts that reveal to Jack his own failure. Similarly, the final look the dying Willie gives Jack indicates that Willie, too, understands that all of it could have, and should have, been different.

In the novel, this contrasts with the scene in the 1949 film, where Willie Stark's last words are merely, "I could have had the world," as if even in his final moment, all Willie cares about is that his quest for power was cut short. The novel's theme, more realistically, is that powerful men are both good and bad and that their successes and failures are equally the result of compromised motives and actions.

See eNotes Ad-Free

Start your 48-hour free trial to get access to more than 30,000 additional guides and more than 350,000 Homework Help questions answered by our experts.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Approved by eNotes Editorial