Analysis

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

Last Updated April 19, 2024.

At first glance, Margaret Atwood's "All Bread" might seem like a simple ode to a staple food. Yet, beneath the crust, the poem offers a surprisingly deep exploration of the journey bread takes from field to table, prompting readers to consider the complex relationship between humanity, nature, and sustenance.

"All Bread" is brimming with symbolism, deepening the poem's meaning beyond a straightforward description of harvesting, baking, and eating. The unexpected ingredients—like "wood, cow dung"—symbolize the often unseen foundation for life, forcing readers to confront the complex web that sustains living beings. Baking, in this view, becomes a ritual. The "moist cloth" hints at a burial; the "silver dish" suggests something sacred. The rising dough's comparison to "white famine bellies" emphasizes bread's life-giving power.

Finally, the taste of bread represents human connection and the cycle of life and death. Eating the bread becomes a symbolic act characterized as consuming "ashes"; the act reminds readers of their place in the natural world and in the cycle of renewal. Through these symbols, Atwood invites her audience to appreciate the profound connection between humanity and the earth.

Unlike traditional sonnets or ballads, "All Bread" does not adhere to a strict rhyme scheme or meter. The poem utilizes a free verse structure to allow for a more natural flow of language that reflects the organic processes it describes.

The rhythm also varies throughout the poem, with short, choppy lines like "nine strokes of the axe" (which somewhat mimic the physical effort they describe) and longer, flowing lines like "Live burial under a moist cloth." Such flexibility in rhyme and rhythm allows Atwood to tailor the language to the specific image or feeling she wants to convey.

The tone of "All Bread" shifts subtly throughout the poem to create a complex exploration of emotions. The opening stanza takes a blunt, almost confrontational approach. Atwood throws the readers unexpected ingredients like "cow dung" to deconstruct the conventional view of bread. From that unexpected introduction to a familiar object, the second stanza becomes more descriptive, using vivid imagery to paint the baking process, with a hint of reverence suggested by the "silver dish."

Then, the third stanza adopts a more personal tone as the taste of bread becomes linked to human effort through the "salt taste of your hands." Finally, the poem concludes with a contemplative tone, using the act of "eating this earth" to remind the reader of their place in the cycle of life and death. Despite these shifts, an underlying seriousness and respect for the natural world and the processes that sustain life permeate the poem.

The poet utilizes a straightforward vocabulary and avoids overly complex words or obscure references. However, this simplicity is deceptive. Atwood uses common words in unexpected ways, which creates powerful imagery. "The bodies of dead animals" is a blunt but effective way to challenge the sanitized view of food's origins. This interplay between common words and surprising imagery allows Atwood to explore complex themes in a way that is accessible yet impactful.

The title, "All Bread," carries significant weight in itself. On the surface, it simply identifies the subject matter. However, by using "All Bread" instead of "A Loaf of Bread" or "Breadmaking," Atwood broadens the scope. "All Bread" becomes a symbol, encompassing not just the final product but the entire journey—from the raw ingredients to the act of sharing. It suggests a universality. It reminds readers that all bread, regardless of its shape or origin, shares a similar story of transformation, human connection, and dependence on the earth.

While Margaret Atwood was not necessarily a farmer, she spent much of her childhood in rural Canada, a natural backdrop that likely informs the imagery in...

(This entire section contains 797 words.)

See This Study Guide Now

Start your 48-hour free trial to unlock this study guide. You'll also get access to more than 30,000 additional guides and more than 350,000 Homework Help questions answered by our experts.

Get 48 Hours Free Access

"All Bread." Spending time between Toronto and the forested areas of northern Quebec and Ontario (where her entomologist father conducted research) could have exposed her firsthand to the natural world and the processes of resource gathering. Such a connection to nature might have fueled her desire to explore the often unseen journey of food from its natural origins to the dinner table.

The poem's focus on transformation and human connection to the earth could also be influenced by her environmental concerns, a theme she frequently explores in her writing.

Like Atwood's novels—in which nature often plays a powerful role—the poem highlights the human connection to the earth. The death present in the cycle that feeds humanity resonates with the mortality themes in her works like Surfacing and The Handmaid's Tale. In these and many of her other works, Atwood explores everyday objects or experiences and imbues them with deeper symbolic meaning.

Previous

Summary