Alexandre Dumas Dumas, Alexandre (père) - Essay


(Nineteenth-Century Literary Criticism)

Alexandre Dumas (père) 1802–1870

(Full name Alexandre Dumas Davy de la Pailleterie) French novelist, dramatist, memoirist, historian, essayist, and short story and travel sketch writer.

Popular in his own time, Dumas père has remained a favorite storyteller among generations of readers throughout the world. His best-known works are the novels Les trois mousquetaires (1844; The Three Musketeers; or, The Feats and Fortunes of a Gascon Adventurer) and Le comte de Monte-Cristo (1845; The Count of Monte Cristo), adventure stories that abound with swordfights, lavish costumes, beautiful women, and narrow escapes. But these represent a minute portion of writings produced by this enormously prolific author, whose published novels, plays, stories, essays, and other works number in the hundreds. Due to his prolific output and the high entertainment value of his fiction—not to mention questions concerning his collaboration with other writers—critics have often judged Dumas harshly. Nonetheless, his work as a dramatist, which include the plays Henri III et sa cour (1829; Henry III and His Court) and Antony (1831), helped to usher in the Romantic era on the French stage.

Biographical Information

Dumas's father, Thomas-Alexandre Dumas, was the son of a marquis and a Haitian slave, and he took his family name from his African mother. After Thomas's death in 1806, Dumas was raised by his mother, an innkeeper's daughter named Marie-Louise-Elisabeth Labouret, in the town of Villers-Cotterêts, near Paris. He attended the local parochial school, and when he was older worked as a clerk but moved to Paris at the age of twenty, lured by the theater. Influenced by the dramatic works of Shakespeare, the poetry of Lord Byron, and the historical romances of Sir Walter Scott, Dumas collaborated with two others in writing a one-act play, La chasse et l'amour (1825). The young playwright used the pseudonym Davy, taken from the name of his paternal grandfather; but soon he was writing under his own name and began producing a series of important dramas that included Henri III and His Court, Antony, and Christine; ou Stockholm, Fountainebleau, et Rome (1830). During the Revolution of 1830, Dumas became interested in republican politics, and with the return of monarchy under King Louise Philippe, he decided to leave France in 1832. There followed several years of travel in Switzerland, Russia, Italy, and other parts of Europe, adventures Dumas began recording in Impressions de voyage (1833-37; The Glacier Land) and numerous other books of travel essays. In the 1840s, having returned to France, he embarked on the most fruitful decade of his life, years which saw the serial publication of The Three Musketeers, The Count of Monte Cristo, and dozens of other novels. He was so prolific, in fact, that critics began to raise questions concerning his use of collaborators such as Auguste Maquet. In 1845, French journalist Eugène de Mirecourt charged publicly that Dumas ran a "literary factory" in which he exploited the efforts of slave-like scribes. The slander case against Mirecourt, which Dumas won, was not the only harbinger of bad tidings as the 1840s came to a close. During those years of prosperity, Dumas spent money lavishly, and built a mansion dubbed the "Château de Monte-Cristo," which housed his many lovers, pets, and hangers-on. By 1850 he was bankrupt, and was forced to sell his home. Also in that year the Thèâtre Historique, which he had founded in 1847 to stage his own dramas, went bankrupt. Dumas fled to Brussels to avoid his creditors, and continued to write at a feverish pace, this time without the help of Maquet or other collaborators.

By 1853 his finances were back in order, and he returned to Paris, where his memoirs had been published to great success. He also founded and began writing for several journals with titles based on his most acclaimed novels, including Le mousquetaire and Le Monte-Cristo. As passionate in his personal life as he was in his work, Dumas had enjoyed a number of lovers and fathered several illegitimate children, including the future writer Alexandre Dumas fils in 1824. He was married briefly in the 1840s to actress Ida Ferrier and engaged in a celebrated affair with the American actress Adah Isaacs Menken in the late 1860s. His voluminous literary output continued, though slackened somewhat from its zenith in the 1840s, and he continued to travel widely. But his fortunes steadily declined, and when he died in his son's home at the age of sixty-eight, little remained of the riches Dumas had accumulated in his highly successful career.

Major Works

Like his contemporary and rival Honoré de Balzac, Dumas set out to produce a vast body of fiction that would depict the width and breadth of a society, specifically France from the Middle Ages to his own time. In so doing, he produced his two best-known works, The Three Musketeers and The Count of Monte Cristo, as well as dozens—even scores—of other novels. (English-speaking readers may be disappointed to scan his list of published writings in vain for The Man in the Iron Mask: the book is actually a compilation taken from several of his works and did not exist as such during Dumas's lifetime.) In writing these "historical romances," as they were called, Dumas pioneered the genre of historical fiction, bringing together actual events and people with characters and incidents of his own creation. The Three Musketeers, for instance, is drawn from the quasi-historical memoirs of a figure called M. d'Artagnan; Dumas, for his part, drew the characters of D'Artagnan, as well as Athos, Porthos, and Aramis, out of those memoirs. He built their adventures around events involving King Louis XIII, Cardinal Richelieu, and other prominent personages of seventeenth-century France. Likewise The Count of Monte Cristo, a tale of unjust imprisonment and revenge, has its roots in an account from the Napoleonic era. Less well-known at the time, but more significant to modern critics because it offers insights into Dumas's views on his African heritage is Georges (1843; George; or the Planter of the Isle of France). Like Monte Cristo, it is a tale of revenge, with the important difference that it is Dumas's only story—and one of the few works of Western literature prior to the twentieth century—in which the hero is a mulatto. Another work little-known in his time, but more noted in the twentieth century, is his examination of a courtesan's career in "respectable" society, Fernande (1844; Fernande; or, The Fallen Angel). But such topical novels are the exception rather than the rule in an oeuvre that includes far more works depicting the French past of Medieval times and the Renaissance.

In his later years, Dumas produced an obscure novel destined to attract more attention after his lifetime: La terreur prussiene (1866; The Prussian Terror) sounded an alarmist warning regarding a militaristic Germany, which by the time of his death had invaded France. Interestingly, the work was first translated into English in 1915, when Britain was engaged in war with Germany on the battlegrounds of Dumas's homeland. Principal among Dumas's dramatic works is Antony, a tale of seduction, intrigue, and murder that shocked Paris audiences because it was set not in the classical past, but in contemporary France. Similarly, La tour de Nesle (1832; The Tower of Nesle) presents a scandalous plot involving sex and betrayal, this time set in medieval France. Also notable are several plays depicting lives and events surrounding monarchs, including Henry III and His Court, which vies with Hugo's Cromwell for the title of first play of the Romantic era; Christine, about Queen Christina of Sweden; and Charles VII chez ses grands vassaux (1831; Charles VII at the Homes of His Great Vassals). Dorothy Trench-Bonett, who produced the first English translation of the latter 160 years after its writing, referred to it as one of the first pieces of Western literature that offered a protest against the slave trade. Other than his novels and plays, the third significant component of Dumas's oeuvre is comprised of his travel writings and other essays, including his celebrated autobiography Mes mémoires (1852-54; My Memoirs), which did not appear in English until 1907.

Critical Reception

Of all his works, Dumas's historical romances are best known in the English-speaking world, where he has enjoyed at least as great a following as he has among French readers. In France, he is most noted for his dramatic writings, which critics have long recognized as groundbreaking works. Not only was Antony innovative in its use of a contemporary setting for a classic tale of erotic intrigue, the staging of Henry III and His Court in February of 1829 made it the first Romantic play, although Hugo's Cromwell was actually written earlier. In spite of his contributions to French and world literature, however, in his own day Dumas often found himself the butt of harsh criticism. His work was routinely dismissed as mere entertainment of the lightest sort—hardly more substantial than The Wandering Jew and other works of his largely forgotten contemporary, Eugène Sue. Certainly Dumas ranked low in comparison to the more critically celebrated (though sometimes almost equally prolific) writers of his time such as George Sand, Balzac, and even Victor Hugo. In addition, the sheer volume of his works—not to mention his habit of padding his writing with excessive quotations and dialogue—made him appear more like a human writing machine than an artist. His astounding output, in fact, left him open to questions regarding the authorship of works produced under the name "Alexandre Dumas." But he proved in his later work that collaboration was not an absolute requirement for production on his part, and observers have pointed out that no joint authorship has ever been claimed for My Memoirs and any number of his widely praised non-fiction works.

The sheer endurance of his historical romances, which have seen countless film interpretations, seems in itself a sign of Dumas's singular power as a creative talent, and his reputation has steadily increased over time. Though his work has enjoyed scant critical attention in proportion to its sheer bulk, he remains a figure of interest. In the late twentieth century, critics have continued to investigate his lesser-known writings for their contemporary relevance. Of greatest interest, perhaps, has been the fact of his African ancestry and its influence on George and other works. This racial theme, along with various sexual aspects of Dumas's work, including androgyny (Christine), promises to provide decades' worth of fruitful critical inquiry.

Principal Works

(Nineteenth-Century Literary Criticism)

La chasse et l'amour [As Davy] (drama) 1825

Henri III et sa cour [translated as Catherine of Cleves; also published as Henry III and His Court] (drama) 1829

Christine; ou Stockholm, Fountainebleau, et Rome (drama) 1830

Antony [Anton)] (drama) 1831

Charles VII chez ses grands vassaux [Charles VII at the Homes of His Great Vassals] (drama) 1831

Napoléon Bonaparte; ou, Trente ans de l'histoire de France (drama) 1831

Richard Darlington (drama) 1831

Térésa (drama) 1832

La tour de Nesle [The Tower of...

(The entire section is 732 words.)

Gamaliel Bradford (essay date 1926)

(Nineteenth-Century Literary Criticism)

SOURCE: "Alexandre Dumas," in A Naturalist of Souls: Studies in Psychography, Houghton Mifflin Company, 1926, pp. 179-205.

[In the following essay, Bradford provides an overview of Dumas's career and works and defends him against critics who appraise his writing as mere entertainment.]

Mr. Davidson, whose excellent volume on Dumas must be the foundation of any careful study of the subject, dismisses his author with the remark: 'Except for increasing the already ample means of relaxation, he did nothing to benefit humanity at large.' Is not this a rather grudging epitaph for the creator of 'Monte Cristo'? Are the means of relaxation so ample that we can afford to treat...

(The entire section is 5833 words.)

Jared Wenger (essay date 1940)

(Nineteenth-Century Literary Criticism)

SOURCE: "Violence as a Technique in the Dramas and Dramatizations of Dumas père," in The Romanic Review, Vol. XXXI, No. 3, October, 1940, pp. 265-79.

[In the following essay, Wenger analyzes the violent scenes in Dumas's dramatic works according to a tripartite model involving "Play," "Show," and "Struggle."]

Alexandre Dumas the elder has an appeal for popular and scholarly reader alike. The present study of his dramas springs from this appeal, is undertaken because of his fame as a novelist, and is inspired by an interest in the problems of fiction. This is no paradox. Dumas is remembered today largely for his romances; yet he began his career with a drama,...

(The entire section is 6917 words.)

Richard Parker (essay date 1944)

(Nineteenth-Century Literary Criticism)

SOURCE: "Some Additional Sources of Dumas's Les trois mousquetaires," in Modern Philology, Vol. XLII, No. 1, August, 1944, pp. 34-40.

[In the following essay, Parker discusses a number of works that influenced Les trois mousquetaires, most notably the memoirs of the Comte de Brienne.]

From the time of the publication of Les trois mousquetaires in 1844, when the author in his preface tried to throw his readers off the trail by his reference to the nonexistent folio manuscript No. 4772 or 4773 (he was uncertain which!), there has been a merry chase in tracking down the sources of Dumas's masterpiece. With the feigned naïveté of the ingenious...

(The entire section is 4036 words.)

A. Craig Bell (essay date 1952)

(Nineteenth-Century Literary Criticism)

SOURCE: "The Neglected Side of Dumas," in The National and English Review, July, 1952, pp. 32-60

[In the following essay, Bell briefly examines more than a dozen of Dumas's lesser-known novels and other works.]

On July 24 this year the Mayor of Villers-Cotterets is unveiling a new statue1 to mark the 150th anniversary of the birth of the little town's most illustrious citizen—Alexandre Dumas. The ceremony will be attended by admirers from all over the world; for despite austere critics and academic historians of literature, Dumas continues to hold the attention of posterity.

Anniversaries of the births and deaths of great writers have in...

(The entire section is 2439 words.)

Marcel Girard (essay date 1968)

(Nineteenth-Century Literary Criticism)

SOURCE: Introduction to The Forty-Five, by Alexandre Dumas, J. M. Dent and Sons Ltd., 1968, pp. v-xiii.

[In the following essay, Girard outlines the historical setting of The Forty-Five.]

The Forty-five is a sequel to Marguerite de Valois and Chicot the Jester, especially to the latter, and it is difficult to follow the plot or to understand the characters without bearing in mind the earlier episodes. The three novels together form a huge chronicle of the reigns of Charles IX and Henri III, from 1572 to 1585, that is to say from the Massacre of St Bartholomew to the death of the Duc d'Anjou; a terrible epoch, well suited to inspire a novelist....

(The entire section is 3573 words.)

Barnett Shaw (essay date 1969)

(Nineteenth-Century Literary Criticism)

SOURCE: Introduction to Alexandre Dumas, Père: The Great Lover and Other Plays, adapted by Barnett Shaw, Frederick Ungar Publishing Co., 1969, pp. 1-4.

[In the following essay, Shaw offers a condensed overview of Dumas's life and works.]

Alexandre Dumas was the son of a mulatto general, Thomas-Alexandre Dumas, who served under Napoleon. His grandfather was the Marquis Davy de la Pailleterie, who had married a native named Marie-Cessette Dumas while running a plantation on the island of Haiti. Both Dumas and his father ignored the title to which they had a right, preferring to use the name Dumas.

Dumas was born in Villers-Cotterets, forty miles...

(The entire section is 1617 words.)

A. Owen Aldridge (essay date 1972)

(Nineteenth-Century Literary Criticism)

SOURCE: "The Vampire Theme: Dumas Pere and the English Stage," in Revue des Langues Vivantes, Vol. XXXIX, No. 4, 1973, pp. 312-24.

[In the following essay, originally presented as a paper in 1972, Aldridge discusses the sources of Dumas's little-known drama Le Vampire (1851).]

One of the least known of all the works of Alexandre Dumas, père, is his drama Le Vampire, 1851. It is so obscure that it has not even been honored by a separate printing, but is merely available in the collected edition of the author's dramatic works.1 The play is important, however, in the biography of Dumas and in the history of comparative literature in the...

(The entire section is 6070 words.)

Douglas Munro (essay date 1983)

(Nineteenth-Century Literary Criticism)

SOURCE: "Two 'Missing' Works of Alexandre Dumas, Père," in Bulletin of the John Rylands University Library of Manchester, Vol. 66, No. 1, Autumn, 1983, pp. 198-212.

[In the following essay, Munro examines the publishing histories of two little-known works by Dumas, the historical romance Le comte de Moret and the drama Pietro Tasca.]

This article is primarily concerned with the "missing" manuscripts of two works by Alexandre Dumas, père, Le comte de Moret and Pietro Tasca. But these, it should be noted, are not alone among his works in being "missing", for various other manuscripts of his, all plays, may also, for a variety of reasons, be counted...

(The entire section is 3882 words.)

II. Pietro Tasca

(Nineteenth-Century Literary Criticism)

That apparently lost holograph manuscripts of Dumas do in fact reappear entirely unexpectedly may be further exemplified by one such that was offered to me at the beginning of the war through a Jewish émigré from Vienna.

It was no less than the complete manuscript of a play in five acts in prose, wholly written on some ninety loose sheets in Dumas' familiar, beautifully-flowing hand and on his famous blue paper.

The manuscript bore no title or list of characters. The lack of title was possibly due to the loss of the first sheet, on which it was Dumas' invariable custom to write his titles in a large, even script, together with an indication of the acts and tableaux. But there may...

(The entire section is 1795 words.)

Don MacLennan (essay date 1988)

(Nineteenth-Century Literary Criticism)

SOURCE: "Metastasis; or Dumas, Joyce and the Dark Avenger," in English Studies in Africa: A Journal of the Humanities 31, No. 2, 1988, pp. 119-27.

[In the following essay, MacLennan identifies evidence of The Count of Monte Cristo 's influence on A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man by James Joyce.]

The count bowed, and stepped back. "Do you refuse?" said Mercédès, in a tremulous voice. "Pray, excuse me, madame," replied Monte Cristo, "but I never eat Muscatel grapes."1

It is obvious that Joyce read and digested Dumas's novel The Count of Monte Cristo, and that he selected Monte...

(The entire section is 4019 words.)

A. Craig Bell (essay date 1988)

(Nineteenth-Century Literary Criticism)

SOURCE: Foreword to Fernande: The Story of a Courtesan, by Alexandre Dumas, translated by A. Craig Bell, Robert Hale, 1988, pp. 5-8.

[In the following essay, Bell provides a brief examination of the influences behind Femande, Dumas's story of an upper-class prostitute.]

To the reader who knows only the Dumas of the historical romances this naturalistic novel of contemporary Parisian society with a courtesan as its 'heroine' will come as a surprise, and he will almost certainly wonder as to the reasons for his writing it. A brief explanation, then.

In 1842 Dumas wrote his second1, and one of his best, historical romances, namely Le...

(The entire section is 1025 words.)

Renee Winegarten (essay date 1991)

(Nineteenth-Century Literary Criticism)

SOURCE: "Alexandre Dumas: Fact and Fiction," in New Criterion, Vol. 9, No. 9, May, 1991, pp. 32-9.

[In the following essay, Winegarten assesses Dumas's career and writings from a late-twentieth-century perspective, taking into account the changing standards in the evaluation of the author's work.]

If reading is a vice that goes unpunished, as the poet has it, then Alexandre Dumas père (1802-1870) offers one of the principal means of access to that form of depravity for devotees too numerous to mention. Throughout the world, how many have tasted for the first time the refined pleasures, the ecstasies and thrills of reading, in The Three Musketeers and its...

(The entire section is 5090 words.)

Adrian Kiernander (essay date 1996)

(Nineteenth-Century Literary Criticism)

SOURCE: "Paris Was Always Burning: (Drag) Queens and Kings in Two Early Plays by Alexandre Dumas pére, " in Essays in Theatre, Vol. 14, No. 2, May, 1996, pp. 158-73.

[In the following essay, Kiernander explores aspects of androgyny and sexual ambiguity in the plays Christine and Henri III et sa cour.]

It is apt that the writings of Alexandre Dumas père, which deal so frequently with overwhelming obsession, should have provoked similar extraordinary obsessions in his readers. The result of one such obsession is a vast repository of Dumas material, the book collection alone consisting of over 2,500 titles (many of them multi-volume works), in the Auckland...

(The entire section is 6599 words.)

Further Reading

(Nineteenth-Century Literary Criticism)


Davidson, Arthur F. "The Great Novels." In Alexandre Dumas (pére): His Life and Works, pp. 216-56. Philadelphia: J. B. Lippincott, 1902.

Covers the period 1843-53, when Dumas produced his most significant works of fiction.

Hemmings, F. W. J. "The Novelist." In The King of Romance. A Portrait of Alexandre Dumas, pp. 114-30. London: Hamish Hamilton, 1979.

Examines Dumas's career as a novelist, from his beginnings in the years of "roman-feuilleton mania" during the 1840s through his collaboration with Auguste Maquet and the writing of his most celebrated...

(The entire section is 738 words.)