Summary
In the heart of New York's high society, Newland Archer, a charming and sought-after attorney, becomes engaged to the beautiful and virtuous May Welland. Their engagement announcement coincides with a reception held for May’s cousin, Countess Ellen Olenska, whose scandalous past stirs the waters of their rigid community. Ellen's return from Europe, amidst whispers of divorce from a wayward Polish count, challenges the social norms that Archer feels bound to follow.
Initial Attraction
While their engagement is celebrated, Archer finds himself drawn to Ellen's enigmatic charm. Despite societal disapproval, he visits her under the guise of helping his future cousin-in-law acclimate. Ellen's allure presents a stark contrast to the predictable life Archer anticipates with May, highlighting Ellen's sensitivity and unconventional beauty. As Archer stands by Ellen amidst the storm of her divorce proceedings, he grapples with the allure of an alternate life she embodies. Though he doesn't consider ending his engagement, Archer's admiration for Ellen begins to eclipse his feelings for May.
Societal Pressures
Despite her family's protective facade, Ellen is treated as an outsider, her every move scrutinized. Her desire to live in a less respectable part of town raises eyebrows, and her free-spirited nature is viewed with suspicion. Meanwhile, Ellen draws the attention of Julius Beaufort, a notorious figure in their circle, further complicating her position. Archer’s disdain for Beaufort only deepens his fascination with Ellen.
Retreat and Realization
Determined to distance himself from Ellen, Archer visits May in St. Augustine. May's chilly reception and rebuffs initially dampen Archer's spirits, but he soon finds himself reawakened by her beauty and pleads for an earlier wedding date. The Welland family, entrenched in their elaborate wedding plans, declines to alter the schedule. Returning to New York, Archer manages to hasten the wedding with the help of Mrs. Manson Mingott. The news reaches him via a telegram meant for Ellen, just as he contemplates deepening their connection, marking a turning point in his inner conflict.
Marriage and Disillusionment
Archer’s wedding and subsequent honeymoon fail to quell his growing dissatisfaction. Life with May follows a predictable path, one dictated by societal conventions, leaving Archer feeling trapped in a life he never passionately chose. His work offers little fulfillment, and May’s passive sweetness only heightens his longing for something more. Back in New York, he resumes clandestine meetings with Ellen, seeking the vitality missing from his stagnant existence.
A Proposal and Its Consequences
In a bold proposal, Archer suggests they elope, but Ellen, with her mature wisdom, declines. She insists their love remains pure only without physical consummation. Archer reluctantly agrees and advises Ellen against divorce, blaming his own lack of courage for this advice. The implosion of Beaufort’s firm triggers a family crisis, leading Ellen back to New York to support Mrs. Mingott, thus reigniting Archer's hopes.
The Affair Ends
Archer’s renewed meetings with Ellen raise suspicions among friends and family. His intimacy with her becomes known, exacerbating the tension in his marriage to May. Yet Ellen's departure to Paris, prompted by the news of May's pregnancy, marks the end of their affair. May's subtle victory reinforces Archer's place within his conservative society, where he ultimately yields and makes peace with his circumstances.
Time and Reflection
As the years roll by, Archer dabbles in progressive politics and social reform, watching as society slowly evolves. He raises his children, Mary and Dallas, within the bounds of propriety. Following May's death, Archer reflects on her passing with genuine sorrow, contemplating the changing tides of societal norms. He acknowledges a shift toward a more open-minded generation that embraces change.
A Final Decision
In his later years, Archer plans a European trip with his son Dallas, who reveals his awareness of Archer's past with Ellen. In Paris, Dallas arranges a visit to Ellen's apartment, yet Archer chooses to remain outside, contemplatively seated on a park bench. He watches as the lights flicker in Ellen’s window, then dim when a servant closes the shutters, signaling the end of an era. Archer walks back to his hotel, accepting that some stories are best left in the past, while finding solace in the present's stability.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.