"After Twenty Years" Themes
The main themes in “After Twenty Years” are friendship versus duty, how time changes people, and crime does not pay.
- Friendship versus duty: In having Bob arrested, Jimmy Wells chooses his public duty as a police officer over private loyalty to his old friend.
How time changes people: Bob’s failure to recognize Jimmy raises the question of how much time has, or has not, changed the two men.
Crime does not pay: While Bob has achieved greater success as a criminal than Jimmy has as a patrolman, his life of crime ultimately leads to his arrest.
Last Updated on November 6, 2020, by eNotes Editorial. Word Count: 869
Friendship versus Duty
“After Twenty Years” was first published in 1906 and is set, like most of O. Henry’s stories, in the present or recent past. The action takes place, therefore, during Theodore Roosevelt’s presidency or earlier, at a time when the United States had a strong ethos of public duty, based on the values of the Roman Republic on which it was modeled. There is no sign of any struggle in Jimmy Wells’s mind between the claims of friendship and duty. If he ever considers letting his friend go for old time’s sake, the author does not mention it. The only concession he makes is to avoid arresting Bob himself. Even then, as he leaves Bob to wait, he ensures that he will stay where he is long enough for the plainclothes detective to arrest him.
Given Jimmy’s apparent single-mindedness in pursuit of his duty, it may seem that the question of friendship versus duty is too easily decided for it to be a major theme. However, the author, who sometimes goes so far as to break the fourth wall and tell the reader what he thinks in other stories, does not align himself with either character or perspective here. Bob never considers the possibility that Jimmy will betray him to the authorities. He does not know that Jimmy is a police officer, but he might still have considered whether such an upright citizen would call the police on discovering that his friend was a well-known criminal. It may be that he thinks Jimmy will never discover this, and does not propose to tell him, but his praise of Jimmy is, nonetheless, consistently directed toward his private character as a friend. Jimmy is his “best chum,” his brother, true and stanch, the type of man who will never forget a promise. This suggests that Jimmy might at least feel a pang of remorse on reflecting that Bob’s personal loyalty is to be his undoing. Whether his decision to leave Bob’s arrest to another man is due to such remorse, to sentimentality, or to moral cowardice is for the reader to decide, as is the larger question of whether he is right to place public duty above friendship.
How Time Changes People
“After Twenty Years” concludes with three surprises in quick succession. First, Bob realizes that the man who claims to be Jimmy is not Jimmy. Second, it is revealed that Bob is a well-known criminal. Third, Jimmy confesses in his note that he was the police officer to whom Bob spoke at the beginning of the story. All these surprises show different aspects of the changes wrought by time.
Either Jimmy or Bob or both of them have changed so much that Bob does not recognize Jimmy, despite the fact that he is expecting him. He then fails to realize that the second man he meets, who claims to be Jimmy, is not his old friend. It is only when they pass the brightly lit window of a drugstore that he notices a physical feature that does not change with age, the shape of a man’s...
(The entire section contains 869 words.)
Unlock This Study Guide Now
Start your 48-hour free trial to unlock this After Twenty Years study guide. You'll get access to all of the After Twenty Years content, as well as access to more than 30,000 additional guides and more than 350,000 Homework Help questions answered by our experts.