Illustration of a man on a dock facing the water

The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn

by Mark Twain

Start Free Trial

Discussion Topic

Huck Finn's propensity for lying and its impact on the reader

Summary:

Huck Finn's propensity for lying adds complexity to his character and serves to critique societal norms. For readers, his lies highlight his survival instincts and moral dilemmas, creating empathy and understanding of his circumstances. This aspect of his character also underscores the theme of deception versus truth in the narrative.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Why does Huck Finn frequently lie in Twain's novel, and what effect do these lies have on the reader?

Discuss Huck Finn's propensity for lying. Give plenty of examples.

Much of the time Huck lies to protect himself against his father, or to protect other people, especially Jim, the runaway slave. In this manner, Twain satirizes the convoluted values of a society that allows an abusive father and justifies slavery, or protects only the wealthy.

---In Chapter XIII, for instance, Huck lies to a watchman on a steamship about a Miss Hooker's being on a horse-ferry, but the oar was lost so the ferry floated downstream until she grabbed onto the wreck of the Walter Scott. Huck further encourages the watchman to retrieve Miss Hooker by telling him that her uncle is wealthy so he will rescue her in hopes of retrieving a reward. This fabrication is made by Huck so that the watchman will actually rescue two robbers on the ship; Huck feels that if he tells the truth, these men who are miscreants will not be saved. Huck is proud of his lie that has done the murderers a good turn:

I wished the widow knowed about it. I judged she would be proud of me for helping these rapscallions, because rapscallions and dead-beats is the kind the widow and good people takes the most interest in.

---In several instances, Huck lies to protect Jim from the laws of society. In Chapter XVI, Huck contemplates turning Jim in as a runaway slave, but when he encounters two gruff men with guns on a skiff, he just cannot let Jim be taken by them, so when they stop and ask him if he has seen any Negroes because five have run off; fearing for him and also recalling how Jim has told him that he is the only white person who has ever been thoughtful of him, Huck simply cannot betray his friend. So, he lies to these men, saying that Jim on the raft is white. Then, the men say they will look for themselves, Huck tells another lie about his father being sick with a contagious disease,

“I reckon we'll go and see for ourselves.”
“I wish you would,” says I, “because it's Pap that's there, and maybe you'd help me tow the raft ashore where the light is. He's sick—and so is mam and Mary Ann.”

When the men hear that others have gone away when he has asked for help, they assume that "Pap" has smallpox; therefore, they guiltily give Huck money, and push off. Huck embellishes his tall-tale with yet another lie, 

“Good-bye, sir,” says I; “I won't let no runaway n---s get by me if I can help it.”

---In Chapter XX, when Huck encounters the King and the Duke, two shysters, he realizes that it is to his advantage to lie about his name and about Jim in order to protect himself and Jim from their devious machinations.

My folks was living in Pike County, in Missouri, where I was born, and they all died off but me and pa and my brother Ike.... Pa was pretty poor, and had some debts; so when he'd squared up there warn't nothing left but sixteen dollars and our nigger, Jim....Well, when the river rose pa had a streak of luck one day; he ketched this piece of a raft; so we reckoned we'd go down to Orleans on it. Pa's luck didn't hold out; a steamboat run over the forrard corner of the raft one night, and we all went overboard and dove under the wheel; Jim and me come up all right, but Pa...and Ike...never come up no more.

--In Chapter XXVII, after Huck has taken the inheritance money that the King has taken and hidden in the straw mattress, he lies about this money in order to be able to return it to Mary Jane. When he is asked where this money is, Huck replies,

“In the bank for to be collected. Where would it be?”
“Well, that's all right then, thank goodness.”
Says I, kind of timid-like:
“Is something gone wrong?”

Huck feels that the King and Duke are thieves and not deserving of the truth about stolen money.

References

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Why does Huck Finn in Mark Twain's novel frequently lie, and what impact do these lies have on the reader?

I have a 3-page essay due on this topic.

The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn is the sequel to The Adventures of Tom Sawyer. Huck Finn is a good kid, and you as the reader, can see this. Throughout the book, Huck Finn has a good moral compass. When Huck does lie, he usually lies to help someone or protect someone.

Huck lies to his father, Pap, about the money he has. Huck knows that his father will take his money and buy alcohol, so he lies about the money. After Pap takes Huck to an isolated island and keeps him in a cabin, Huck fakes his own death. This is another lie, but a lie that he does to protect himself. When he wants to find out what is going on in town, he lies that he is actually a girl. He lies to Jim, when they get separated in the fog. Jim is really upset, and Huck feels bad about this lie. He also lies that he is actually, Tom, to help find Jim and set him free.

Huck lies so well. His lies are not done in malice, but are done in a way that almost seem harmless. He lies to his father, because he knows what kind of man he is. His lies to his father are to protect himself. When he lies to Jim, Huck feels real remorse. Jim has become very important to him. He is not always successful in his lies. He is caught when he is trying to pretend to be a girl, but he seems to always get out of the lies. Huck sees his lies as a means to an end. 

Mark Twain chose Huck as a hero, because Huck is real. Kids can relate to him. He has a hard childhood, a great friend, and a moral compass that leads him. We, as readers, see that Huck has a good heart. He is a good and loyal friend. Even though he lies, his lies seem to be in the good of someone else. His lies are not to hurt anyone. He often feels bad when he lies, like he did when Jim got upset with him. You can tell that Huck has a good heart.

Huck Finn is a character that will live in literature. Just the mention of his name, evokes memories of childhood and misadventures. Mark Twain created a lovable, if somewhat, flawed character. If we are honest with ourselves, we can see a little bit of Huck Finn in all of us, and that is what makes Mark Twain choose the character that he did. 

Get Ahead with eNotes

Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Approved by eNotes Editorial