Critical Evaluation

(Critical Survey of Literature for Students)

Many critics identify Nick Hornby as reflecting contemporary English middle-class issues concerning social relationships in urban settings. About a Boy contains many elements similar to his earlier works, Fever Pitch (1992) and High Fidelity (1995), such as the relationship of one’s identity to one’s pastimes and interests. Hornby’s personal interests in music and football are highly visible in the novel, as are other autobiographical elements, such as a setting in North London (where Hornby grew up in the 1960’s and 1970’s), divorce, and the complexity of relationships. Some critics also contend that Marcus’s character is inspired by Hornby’s son, who has autism. Hornby’s straightforward, conversational writing style includes an element of advising the contemporary individual. These stylistic aspects are considered unique and responsible for his large following.

Hornby is among the group of contemporary authors involved with McSweeney’s, an independent publisher experimenting with new ways of creating and disseminating accessible literature, reaching out to diverse communities online, in print, and through social programs. In About a Boy, Hornby widens his scope, incorporating two protagonists with great superficial age differences to explore and expand traditional conceptions of family and relationships. As a result, About a Boy goes beyond a simple coming-of-age story to represent a contemporary literary view of the potential for newly envisioned interaction between individuals and groups, even as many places become increasingly urbanized and traditional definitions of family and community may appear to be dissolving.

A short bildungsroman with a humorous tone, About a Boy combines the beginning of the customary journey to maturity of a serious young man who at times seems old with the journey to maturity of a thirty-six-year-old man who acts like a teenager. The book alternates chapters between Marcus’s and Will’s points of view, emphasizing their interdependent journey toward understanding their own areas of naïveté. Marcus becomes increasingly self-reliant, self-aware, and savvy regarding contemporary popular culture. Will, whose identity is founded on the connoisseurship of possessions, becomes increasingly aware of others and opens himself to the difficulties and benefits of long-term, well-maintained relationships.

Throughout the novel, media and popular culture...

(The entire section is 1015 words.)