Themes: Knowledge vs. Ignorance
Winston continually struggles to hold onto his own conceptions of truth in the face of the Party’s aggressive efforts to erase and rewrite history. Their concerted efforts to absolve any reliance on knowledge and intelligence allows the Party to coerce the citizens of Oceania to capitulate to Party values and thus believe the Party’s version of the truth. Internally, Winston’s narrative is driven by his hypervigilance in confronting these methods of deception and reclaiming both personal and objective truths. Despite his efforts, Winston is ultimately aware of his powerlessness in this endeavor.
Winston’s frustration with accepting the obsolescence of truth, history, and knowledge is illustrated in the following passage:
The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command… And yet he was in the right! They were wrong and he was right. The obvious, the silly, and the true had got to be defended. Truisms are true, hold on to that! The solid world exists; its laws do not change. Stones are hard, water is wet, objects unsupported fall towards the earth’s centre.
Winston’s growing commitment to defending the truth ultimately leads him to pursue rebellion, which then leads to his imprisonment. During Winston’s detainment, O’Brien aims to make Winston believe that “whatever the Party holds to be the truth, is truth,” and instructs him to “humble [him]self” in “an act of self destruction” in order cure his supposed insanity and absorb the Party’s versions of the truth.
This cycle—in which the Party disguises lies as truth and erases history to justify political and ethical decisions made in the present—is referred to as “reality control.” Winston’s job at the Ministry of Truth ensures that this cycle continues. While engaging in his daily tasks, he communicates that history is “a palimpsest, scraped clean and reinscribed.” This process of reality control thus further provides the ruling members of the Party with ammunition to assert their power over the powerless. Even Winston acknowledges that “the only evidence” of past events exists “inside [his] own mind,” methodically erased for the purpose of representing the Party and Big Brother as eternal and omnipotent forces in history. In order to obstruct the quest for absolute truth, the Party enforces blind faith and “a loyal willingness” to believe in unreliable truths among citizens as a means of control. In this way, Orwell suggests that the Party’s dangerous effectiveness in achieving this power arises out of the crucial conflict between ignorance and knowledge.
Expert Q&A
Understanding Oligarchical Collectivism and its significance in George Orwell's 1984 and its relevance to our world
Oligarchical Collectivism in George Orwell's 1984 represents a society controlled by a small elite group, maintaining power through manipulation and surveillance. This concept highlights the dangers of totalitarianism and the loss of individual freedoms. Its relevance today lies in discussions about government overreach, privacy issues, and the concentration of power in the hands of a few, reflecting ongoing concerns in modern society.
In 1984, why does Winston believe he has "ancestral memory that things had once been different"?
Winston believes he has "ancestral memory" that things were once different because, despite having no personal memory of better times, he feels dissatisfied with his current life. While sitting in the canteen, he is struck by the dismal conditions, such as bad food and a dingy atmosphere, and wonders why he finds them intolerable. He concludes that this dissatisfaction stems from a subconscious knowledge, or ancestral memory, that life was once better.
What is Winston trying to learn from the "old man" in 1984 and what's the outcome?
Winston seeks to learn about the past from an "old man" in hopes of uncovering truths obscured by the Party's control over history. He believes the old man, having lived through the capitalist era, can provide valuable insights. However, their conversation disappoints Winston as the old man's memories are fragmented and lack substance, focusing on trivial details rather than the broader realities of life before the revolution. This leaves Winston accepting the Party's version of history.
What does Winston discover about The Book in 1984?
Winston discovers that the book by Emmanuel Goldstein, "The Theory and Practice of Oligarchical Collectivism," truly exists and is circulated among members of the secretive Brotherhood, a group opposed to the Party. He learns that the book is nearly indestructible, as its contents can be reproduced from memory by Brotherhood members. Additionally, the book describes the oppressive methods of totalitarian regimes and the ideologies of the world's superstates.
Why can't the old man in the tavern tell Winston if the past was better than the present?
The old man in the tavern cannot tell Winston if the past was better than the present because the Party has erased history, leaving individuals without a reference point. Additionally, the old man lacks the ability to think about life from a broader perspective, as he only recalls insignificant details. This inability to recall meaningful aspects of the past prevents him from providing a clear answer to Winston's question about life before the Revolution.
What is the role and importance of history in the book 1984?
What details indicate Winston's curiosity and yearning for the past in "1984"?
Winston's curiosity and yearning for the past in 1984 are evident through several actions. He buys a diary from a pawn shop, risking severe punishment, to record memories and defy the Party's control over history. His fascination with relics, like the pen and creamy paper, reflects his desire to connect with a lost era. Additionally, Winston's attempts to learn about the past from an old man and his repeated visits to the pawn shop highlight his deep longing for historical truth.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.
