Discussion Topic

Winston Smith's heroism in 1984

Summary:

Winston Smith's heroism in 1984 lies in his rebellion against the oppressive regime of Big Brother. Despite knowing the risks, he seeks truth and individual freedom, engaging in forbidden acts like keeping a diary and pursuing a love affair. His courage to think independently and resist conformity, even in the face of torture and reprogramming, defines his heroic struggle.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What examples from 1984 show Winston Smith as a hero?

Winston is heroic in daring to oppose the state. As Nafasi writes in Reading Lolita in Teheran, in a totalitarian state, the smallest of gestures, such as a woman allowing a few strands of hair to fall out from her veil, becomes an act of rebellion.

Winston's rebellion runs deep. He writes in a diary, although he knows it will lead either to his death or twenty five years at a hard labor camp. He has a forbidden affair with Julia and even rents a room above Mr. Charrington's shop so that the two can, every so often, live like an ordinary couple. He states to O'Brien that he is willing to take great risks to help overthrow the current government.

After his arrest, Winston is heroic in resisting the idea that two plus two equal five, even while being tortured, and he tries to hang on to his love for Julia as long as possible. If he cannot "win," he at least fights a good fight.

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What examples from 1984 show Winston Smith as a hero?

Although he is fairly ordinary at heart, Winston Smith functions as the main hero in George Orwell's dystopian world. This fact might surprise some readers; after all, Winston succumbs to torture at the end of the novel and finishes the narrative as a devout follower of Big Brother. While his end might be tragic, Winston spends the vast majority of the novel exhibiting a quiet and inspiring heroism, so it would be mistaken to judge him solely on his miserable fate in the final pages of 1984. The clearest example of Winston's heroism occurs quite early in the novel: in the first chapter, he steals home to write his thoughts in a diary. This seemingly simple act is perhaps Winston's most heroic moment. Since Big Brother polices the minds of its citizens and punishes those who dare to think for themselves, the decision to record independent ideas in a journal is a rebellious act against the established order. As such, Winston's early decision to rebel by thinking (and writing) for himself is a clear example of his heroism.

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Is Winston Smith from 1984 a hero? Provide three reasons.

Reasons he is a hero:

1.  He stands up for something he believes in.  Though there is incredible pressure to simply go along with Big Brother, and though there appears to be little hope of success and certainly none of material reward, Winston decides that it is worth it to stand up against the Party in whatever way he can, whether that is simply having sex with Julia or trying to bring down Big Brother.

2.  He pursues this quest without much thought to himself, he only wishes for success of the movement or perhaps somehow to awaken the proles so that they can overthrow the party.

I run a bit short after that.  One reason for him not being a hero, he admits to giving in to torture and giving everything away.  Though this is a very human response, it is not one that might be considered heroic.

See eNotes Ad-Free

Start your 48-hour free trial to get access to more than 30,000 additional guides and more than 350,000 Homework Help questions answered by our experts.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Last Updated on