How does George Orwell represent human nature through Winston in 1984?

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

In some sense, all fictional protagonists represent human nature because they are the focus of the novels in which they appear, in which the author is trying to convey something essential and significant about life and about the human experience. Winston in 1984 is an everyman. Orwell makes Winston's mental life—his hopes, his fears, and his sense of dread about the dystopia in which he lives—the central concern of the novel. 1984 is like a transcript of Winston's thoughts, and Winston's plight is a heightened or extreme form of what every human being experiences.

There is something paradoxical, admittedly, about a character such as Winston in an unreal setting who nevertheless represents the essence of actual human nature. Winston goes through trials both inwardly and outwardly that few people can imagine, except for those who have lived in a totalitarian society. In the end he's tortured and brainwashed into a virtual zombie. It is arguably the extremity of this scenario that enables Orwell so strikingly to depict Winston as an emblem of the human condition. We first see him in isolation, unable to share his thoughts and observations with anyone. To an extent everyone is like that, until they begin to connect with others as they mature. Winston finds Julia, and a new dimension of his life arises. He thinks a breakthrough of some kind occurs when he connects with O'Brien, but it turns out to be a massive delusion when he's arrested, tortured, and his life is basically destroyed.

The illusory nature of Winston's belief about O'Brien as a possible ally is a kind of metaphor of the human propensity for self-delusion. Altogether Winston can be seen as a particularized instance of man's hopes, dreams, and even more so his flaws, failures, and desperation, on a massive scale.

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

How does George Orwell use Winston to represent the human experience in 1984?

In 1984, George Orwell uses Winston Smith to represent the human experience through giving him characteristics and placing him in situations with which the reader can identify. These include his changing involvement in his closely intertwined professional, social, and personal worlds. One of Winston’s primary traits is his dissatisfaction with his job: he is not only bored but also doubts that the work is socially useful. Closely connected is his attitude toward authority, which he initially regards with suspicion and resentment. It seems that this resentment is turning into political resistance as he privately denounces Big Brother.

The autocracy in which Winston lives encourages suspicion of his fellow citizens, which contributes to his sense of alienation and loneliness. Although this suspicion initially extends to Julia, Winston’s desire for human connection blossoms through his relationship with her. In the end, Winston is shown to be as weak as anyone else in Oceania. Rather than a noble hero resisting the totalitarian controls, he abandons his personal feelings and betrays Julia. Orwell leaves the reader wondering if they would be stronger than Winston in a similar situation.

See eNotes Ad-Free

Start your 48-hour free trial to get access to more than 30,000 additional guides and more than 350,000 Homework Help questions answered by our experts.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Last Updated on