Impact of Government Policy on Families Research Paper Starter

Impact of Government Policy on Families

(Research Starters)

This article will focus on the impact of government policy on families. It will provide a description and analysis of the US government's public position on the family and the state as well as the government agency that oversees and implements family-related policy, the Administration for Children and Families. This article will introduce the 1996 reforms to the welfare state and discuss the related consequences to families and issues of child mistreatment, childcare problems, child Medicaid enrollment levels, and childhood poverty. Government treatment of families with illegal immigration status will also be addressed.

Keywords Administration for Children and Families; Childhood Poverty; Family; Public Policy; Social Policy; Welfare State



Families, which the United States Census Bureau considers to be "two or more persons related by birth, marriage or adoption who reside in the same household" ("Current population survey," 2010), provide stability for American society. Families, understood to be a type of social institution, transmit cultural and social norms, values, and behaviors. Families are a source of familial and political socialization. The US government and industrialized nations in general depend on families to successfully care for, educate, feed, house, nurture, and socialize children. The US government recognizes the important role of families in stabilizing society and socializing children and, in response, develops and implements policy to help strengthen the family unit. The explicit goal of American family policy is to improve the overall well-being of American children.

In the United States, public policies address the needs and interests of multiple constituents and stakeholders including families as well as ethnic and racial minorities, children, veterans, women, aging Americans, and the disabled. Government policies implicitly and explicitly, intentionally and unintentionally affect American families by a very wide range of public policy concerning education, taxes, monetary support, childcare, emergency relief, and marriage law. Public policy refers to the basic policy or set of policies that serve as the foundation for public laws. Public policy is often characterized as a social goal, enabling objective, or social solution. The policy-making process is a problem-solving activity that solves or resolves a problem or conflict in society. Public policy, requested by society and enacted by government, unites and mediates the relationship between society and government. Public policy is created within specific historical and socio-cultural contexts and political systems. Public policy encompasses and regulates nearly all areas of human and social behavior. One particularly large body of public policy, often referred to as social policy, concerns families and children.

Social policy, like all public policy, is an expression of values held by both citizens and government. Family policy is a type of social policy. Social policy is an expression of moral and economic values and viewpoints. In the United States, social policies that are enacted through social welfare programs serve as a social safety net and regulate and govern human behavior in areas such as general morality and quality of life. Social policy is created, in part, to respond to pressing social needs such as poverty, social exclusion, unemployment, aging, children, mental illness, learning disabilities, and physical disabilities. Social policy is developed, enacted, and implemented to create self-sufficiency, equity, and social cohesion for all members of a society. Examples of significant social policy created in the United States during the twentieth-century that impact families include the social security system, welfare, public housing, hunger and nutrition programs, childcare and child support, health care for people on low incomes, public education, and the social and health services of the Veterans' Administration. All social policies reflect moral, political, and economic choices.

The US government represents itself as pro-family. In contrast, critics of government family-centered policy argue that much of the government policy in the United States negatively affects American families. This article describes both of these positions will serve to contrast the discussion of critical appraisals of the impact that federal welfare reform has had on families. This article will introduce the 1996 reforms to the welfare state and discuss the related consequences to families and issues of child mistreatment, childcare problems, child Medicaid enrollment levels, and childhood poverty.

The US Government's Public Stance on the Family

In 2004, the Administration for Children and Families (ACF) and the US Department of Health and Human Services published "A Celebration of the Family — Observance of the Tenth Anniversary of the International Year of the Family," which was a report to commemorate the ten-year anniversary of the United Nations General Assembly's International Year of the Family in 1994. The report emphasized the foundational role of the family in the United States and recognized the family as a social institution vital to the health and prosperity of the nation. The report had three main goals: to highlight the family as a social institution, to explore the relationship between family and state, and to offer values to guide the government’s family policy.

Themes that appear in the report and in US social policy concern the role marriage plays within a family unit, the relationship of the family and the common social good, and the pressures modern families face. The United States, as described in the report, believes that the relationship between family and state allows the government to offer families three broad categories of support including “respecting the prerogatives of families, proactive support for healthy marriages, and supporting all families that need assistance” (“A celebration...”, 2004, p.7).

The main principles of government family policy, as described in the 2004 Administration for Children and Families' report, include the following (“A celebration...”, 2004, p.9):

  • Principle 1: Government ought to create the conditions that allow families to thrive.
  • Principle 2: Government ought to recognize the unique and irreplaceable contributions of both mothers and fathers to the lives of their children.
  • Principle 3: Government ought to do what it can to strengthen healthy marriages and the two-parent family.
  • Principle 4: Government must support children and families regardless of family structure.

The US government works to put these principles into practice through the development of US family policy. Policies include comprehensive initiatives to help all families succeed, as well as more targeted policies to encourage healthy marriages, responsible fatherhood, and measures to assist children who specifically need help. Significant family policies have included:

  • Taxes and workforce participation: Federal tax cuts, most notably in 2003 by Republican president George W. Bush and extended in 2012 by Democrat president Barack Obama, were designed to lessen the tax burden on families and help reduce the necessity of dual-income families.
  • Education: The No Child Left Behind Act of 2001 was crafted to among other things provide parents with more options in the choice of schools their children can attend and to level the playing field for children taking standardized tests.
  • Health-care: The Medicare Prescription Drug Improvement and Modernization Act of 2003 is intended to offer senior citizens greater choices of prescription drugs as well as establish Health Savings Accounts for the general population. In 2010, the Affordable Care Act (ACA), commonly called Obamacare, sought to reform a number of aspects of the US health insurance industry as well as improve the access to and quality of health care services.
  • Housing and Home Ownership: George W. Bush’s American Dream Downpayment Act of 2003 and the housing initiatives supported by the Obama administration in 2012 were passed to assist families and families of service men and women build long-term financial security through homeownership.
  • Marriage: Marriage: The Healthy Marriage Initiative of 2004 assisted couples in accessing services to help them acquire skills and knowledge needed to build and maintain healthy marriages and reduce the instances of divorce.
  • Fatherhood: Fatherhood: The Fatherhood Initiative of 1995 was created by the Clinton administration and was under the auspices of the Head Start program for disadvantaged children. It coordinated a series of grants, publications, and conferences, to encourage fathers to participate in their children’s healthy early childhood development.
  • Children in Need: Through the Adoption and Safe Families Act of 1997, the Tax Relief Act of 2001 and the Adoption Promotion Act of 2003, the US government has worked to streamline, encourage, and accelerate the adoption process.

An important example of government policy that affects families in all socio-economic levels includes “family-friendly” work policy of the Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA) (Saltzstein & Ting, 2001). The Family and Medical Leave Act, passed in 1993, is a federal law that provides individuals with a maximum of twelve weeks leave from work based on medical necessity for self or immediate family members including children, parents, or a spouse. The Family and Medical Leave Act has significant influence on parents’ leave taking and job satisfaction (Han & Waldfogel, 2003).

Administration for Children

US government family policy, as described in the previous section is, in most cases, overseen and implemented through the Administration for Children and Families (ACF). The Administration for Children and Families (enacted in 1995 through public law 60 FR 40586-94 and 1998 through public law 63 FR 81 — 87) "provides national leadership and direction to plan, manage, and coordinate the nationwide administration of comprehensive and supportive programs for vulnerable children and families" ("About ACF", 2007). The Administration for Children and Families 2013 fiscal year budget for mandatory and discretionary programs...

(The entire section is 4719 words.)