Your opinion on smoking?   The follwing question was posted under Health on September 21, 2012. It is such an important matter that I think it...

Your opinion on smoking?


The follwing question was posted under Health on September 21, 2012. It is such an important matter that I think it should be opened to general discussion. I believe that more testimonials against smoking besides mine might make a stronger impression on young readers.

Can someone give me their detailed opinion (pros vs cons)  on smoking?



College - Freshman

Posted by rickyc973 on September 21, 2012 at 6:01 AM via web and tagged with cigarettes, health, literature, smoking
Share this question:          

1 Answer | add yours


Editor Emeritus, Debater, Expert, Scribe, Poe, Dickens, The Bard

I have personally known many people who died from smoking. My own wife died from smoking. Her father died from smoking. I had several friends who died from lung cancer due to cigarette addiction. The woman who lived in the apartment next door to me was dying of lung cancer, but she wouldn't go into a hospice where she could receive morphine injections because they wouldn't let her continue smoking. A man who lived across the hall was skin and bones from lung disease, and yet he was a chain smoker. He had an inhaler to help him breathe. He would take one puff on a cigarette and one puff from the inhaler. He died, of course--but he kept smoking until the end. I started smoking myself when I was only about twelve years old because I thought it was sophisticated. Fortunately I quit after many years and many attempts, but it was the hardest thing I ever did. I can't think of anything good about smoking. It is getting terribly expensive. Laws are being passed making it harder and harder for people to smoke indoors or outdoors. I truly hate to see young people smoking cigarettes. They don't know what they are letting themselves in for. But I can't say anything to them. Maybe they think that by the time they get lung cancer the doctors will have a way to cure it. Never happen!

Expert Answers
carol-davis eNotes educator| Certified Educator

Smoking is highly addictive.  The drug users of heroin, crack, and other hard core drugs cite smoking as more addictive than any other other drugs. It has been proven statistically that smoking causes death.  It also impacts other kinds of diseases: heart problems, lung problems, kidney problems, etc.

Other than for personal use and enjoyment, there is nothing good to say about smoking.  That is a personal choice and lethal choice.  

Now, the point that the smoke of someone else becomes my problem...that is where I am absolutely against smoking.  I choose not to smoke. I have allergies and asthma and am  prone to having pneumonia. 

If I am sitting at a football game, I should have the right not to have to breathe someone else's smoke.  When the man sitting behind me smoking and his smoke comes billowing down on me, then I believe that he has infringed on my right to breathe and  enjoy a game without smoke.

When confronted about his smoke and my breathing his secondhand smoking, his response was:

Who do you think you are?  I have a right to smoke anywhere I want.  Why don't you get up and move?  It is your problem not mine.

He is wrong.  I have a right to not breathe in his smoke since I choose not to smoke. Second hand smoke is a serious problem. It has more carcinogens than regular smoke. 

Tobacco smoke contains more than 7,000 chemical compounds. More than 250 of these chemicals are known to be harmful, and at least 69 are known to cause cancer.

The problem of second hand smoke should be the issue. If an adult chooses to smoke, that is his prerogative.  However, it becomes a crime when he forces me to smoke along with him.  That is infringing on my rights to breathe without taking chemical compounds from someone else. 

Legally, there have been some laws set in place: restaurants, workplaces, and government offices. These places are protected.  Go to a casino or  an outdoor facility. You might want to ask the smoker what brand he smokes, so you know what you are smoking with him as you breathe his smoke. 

Public places where children go are a special area of concern. By breathing second hand smoke, the child's lungs might be damaged forever.

William Delaney eNotes educator| Certified Educator

I was hoping that more people would contribute specific cases of friends, relatives, neighbors, acquaintances who had died or suffered serious diseases from smoking. My wife died of lung cancer. She was horribly addicted. She smoked filtered cigarettes that were supposed to be low in tar and nicotine. This only caused her to smoke more and more cigarettes to get the amount of nicotine she craved. I gave up smoking many years ago, but, like millions of Americans I suffer from COPD (Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease) as an after-effect of smoking. It is incurable. It can be very unpleasant and can only get worse with age. It costs me a lot of money for inhalers. I can think of at least eight people I knew personally who died lingering deaths because of smoking cigarettes. Some people just cannot quit. One woman who lived in the apartment next to mine was dying of lung cancer but continued smoking to the every end. She wouldn't go into a hospice where she could get morphine injections because they wouldn't allow her to smoke there. American tobacco companies (as you can see on Google) are heavily advertising American brands of cigarettes in China, among other places. It is estimated that in 2025 there will be two million deaths from lung cancer a year in China. I would like to see more horror stories about smoking. They might have a persuasive effect on young people and save some lives.

pacorz eNotes educator| Certified Educator

Regarding #3's post about smokers who feel calmed when they get their cigarette fix, I have heard the same thing many times from my high school students. However, it's important to note that this calming effect is not really coming from the nicotine, it's coming from your body - nicotine is addictive, and when you don't get your fix, you get irritated and jumpy, so of course smoking calms you down - but if you didn't smoke, you wouldn't need to be calmed in the first place! Do you really want to give control over your brain to cigarettes?

The tobacco industry does support farmers, which would be a pro except for the fact that tobacco only grows in excellent rich soil, so those farms could easily be growing a different crop that would help to feed people.

The long and short is that there are no real, rock-solid pros to tobacco use. The people who own and invest in the cigarette companies get rich at the expense of their customers' health.

The cons are easy. Smokers cause everyone to have to pay more for health insurance. Smokers smell bad, face several major health risks because of their habit, live shorter lives on average, and spend a lot of money on cigarettes.

Michael Ugulini eNotes educator| Certified Educator

My opinion is that smoking is unhealthy and should be avoided. Educating children about the damaging effects of smoking is where it all begins. Although any kind of education that gets anyone of any age to quit smoking is great too! However, children are the next major group that will either smoke or not smoke so the education process must begin as early as possible. Post #5 states that the industry creates jobs and this is true - it also helps create more jobs in the health care industry that must deal with the results of smoking, especially cigarette smoking. I only have one question: why is there not a crackdown on the beer, wine, and spirits industry like there is on the tobacco industry? The tobacco industry is vilified, while alcohol is glamorized and given total freedom to advertise on TV, and more? I'm not against having a drink - but alcohol poses dangers as well, especially when abused, but it's viewed as "Hey, let's party and drink, and watch NFL with a host of Bud's at hand." Then after the game we'll hop in the car and drive home!

Smoking Cessation


mizzwillie eNotes educator| Certified Educator

I agree with your post.  My two favorite  brothers-in-law both died of lung cancer, and the death is so awful.  With the second brother-in-law, he smoked when he would drink, so it was doubly difficult.  He had surgery to try to extend his time as he had just retired to the Boston area.  I flew out to help my sister, and watched the agony he went through.  His back was broken, his ability to enjoy anything was gone, and he finally consented to hospice at home.  His last year of life was agony personified.  I keep thinking that if the young people could see the end result of smoking, they would never start. Many of the prisoners I see also wish they had never started smoking because of the expense and the agony of withdrawal which must happen in prison, again because of money.  I wish young people would look at smoking as the expense it is, both in money and health.

William Delaney eNotes educator| Certified Educator

I don't believe that smoking should be abolished or criminalized, but i do believe that people should be warned of its dangers in as many ways as possible. It seems to me that the best way to warn non-smokers against starting is to offer examples of what happens to those who smoke for a number of years. In addition to lung cancer, millions and millions of Americans suffer from COPD, whichs tands for Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease. It is incurable. Many people who gave up smoking decades ago can still get COPD, which can develop into pneumonia and cause death. As a matter of fact, the famous Shirley Temple was a secret smoker most of her life and recently died of COPD. If only smokers could be made to realize how devastating cigarettes can be, they would quit voluntarily, and the government would not need to step in.

clairewait eNotes educator| Certified Educator

Pro's of smoking? That sounds like an oxymoron, except that those who are smokers claim it is easily the quickest way to make them feel instantly calm and in control again. I've heard from several math-minded people that with the onset of a nicotine fix, they experience acute mental clarity and the ability to focus really well. I've definitely heard this from more than one smoker, most of them men, and most of them engineers, ironically. Nicotine also helps with bowel regularity.

As for the cons, as a non-smoker, instead of arguing the obvious health issues smoking causes, I simply speak from the perspective that smokers smell and taste terrible. I made my (now) husband quit smoking when we were dating. I would not kiss him as long as he was a smoker!

shake99 eNotes educator| Certified Educator

As a former smoker, I can only say that I don't know why I started in the first place. As a kid I was very opposed to the idea, but at some point I just started doing it. Probably because people around me in college were smoking.

My advice regarding cigarettes or alcohol or illegal drugs is that the only way to avoid certain addiction and disaster is to never try any of them, ever. I tell my kids and my students that every single person on earth is an addict, and if they are dumb enough to try something for the first time, they'll quickly find out what they are addicted to. Then  they'll find out that addiction is an enemy more powerful than any they've ever known, and one they'll never, ever be able to completely defeat.

Kristen Lentz eNotes educator| Certified Educator

Just from a sheer economic viewpoint, who can afford to smoke these days when you calculate the real cost of the habit in terms of buying cigarettes on a regular basis?  I am consistently amazed at the amount of money spent by some of my relatives throughout the years on cigarettes alone.  The average yearly cost of smoking is between $1,500 and $3,000, depending on what state you live in.  When compounded by say ten years of smoking, the amount of money spent on cigarettes could easily buy a car, not to mention the other expenses associated with the habit. 


pohnpei397 eNotes educator| Certified Educator

I hate smoking too, but I figure that it is not without its good side.  The main one is that it gives a lot of people jobs.  We can say that all of those people should find jobs in other industries, but we know that that isn't all that easy, right?  Of course I realize that it's kind of horrible that their jobs are based on an industry that ends up making people very unhealthy.  But it is still about the only plus for smoking.  And I suppose that there are plenty of other industries that are bad for us (maybe not as bad, though) and which we don't criticize nearly as much.

litteacher8 eNotes educator| Certified Educator

My grandfather died of lung cancer rather suddenly. Although that saddens me, my biggest problem with smoking is secondhand smoke.  I have breathing problems, sometimes severely, and I do not react well to smoke.  When people smoke, especially in enclosed spaces, the smell and irritation can last for hours afterward.  In public places and high-density populated areas like apartment buildings it can be almost impossible to get away from the smoke.  People who face the dangers of secondhand smoke do not have a choice, but smokers do.

thewanderlust878 | Student

For me, I do not find any true pros/advantages of smoking. As a non-smoker who grew up with relatives who smoked, I always found it unpleasant to be around. And after I was old enough to learn about the harmful effects of smoking, I vowed never to even try it. 

The cons, to most people, definitely outweigh the pros. The biggest cons would have to be the health issues that are associated with smoking. For example, lung cancer, liver failure, mouth cancer, gum disease, blackened or yellowed teeth, bad breath, the list goes on and on. Another big con would be the effect on family members, especially young children. Being exposed to second-hand smoke constantly is just as bad as being a smoker yourself, and in some cases, it could even kill the person, without them ever having touched a cigarette themselves.

That's just my opinion on the matter. Hope this helps!

Wiggin42 | Student

My views on Smoking 

Health wise : It is bad to a core and causes so many health problems not only for me but also from the second hand smoking. 

Society wise: society becomes vulnerable and culturally they are behind and aAny society wishes to uplift the wealth and health of the people.

Spiritual exprience  is not possible if you are addicted to smoking and it will give you an excuse to do what ever feels good.

mchandrea | Student

The only positive thing I can tell about smoking is that it is a laxative. At least, that's my brother's excuse every time I tell him to quit. Apparently, it is also a way to relieve stress.

Smoking is bad for our health and it could eventually kill you. It is a terrible thing not only for the smoker, but also to those around him - his family and friends. I have read an article once, that said second hand smoke is even more dangerous and could potentially cause cancer. These non-smokers who inhale the smoke from the cigarette and from the mouth of the smoker becomes involuntary smokers at risk.  

But why is it that this becomes an addiction? Why can't chain smokers stop?

Tobacco contains nicotine. It is a substance as addicting as heroine and cocaine. It gives the smoker a pleasant feeling that makes him want to smoke more. It's ironic how the smoker tries to please himself, the more he is actually killing himself.

People should quit smoking. For their own sake, and most especially for the people around them.

cons of smoking are the health factors, the deterioration of teeth, bad breath, the possibility of putting your loved ones in danger. The Pro's of smoking would be the sense of calmness you get when you smoke, the relaxing feeling.

luiji | Student

How can you even say there's a good side to smoking? In my opinion, your setting yourself up for death and lug cancer. Do I judge people that smoke? Of course not. Do I support it? No. Seeing one of my closest family memebers go though the pain caused by him being addicted to cigarets, gives me some good reasons to disagree with smoking. Once you start it's hard to stop, I've wittnessed it. So why would you even get addicted in the first place? 

It was only a couple decades ago that they discovered that smoking was harmful for you, so all our grandparents and probably most of our parents grew up smoking, sometimes at really young ages. The people who have no excuse is our generation, and, to be honest, our generation doesn't care. That's what I think anyway.

Many people get sucked into smoking the same way they get sucked into drugs: peer pressure. Urged by friends to take up smoking, or just have one, they end up addicted and unable to break their addiction.

And for those that are depressed, no one's going to worry about what harmful things smoking does for you because they're going to kill htemselves anyway... eventually.

But, please everybody, don't get offended by what I just said, because it's just my view on the facts of life.

larrystyles | Student

How can you even say there's a good side to smoking? In my opinion, your setting yourself up for death and lug cancer. Do I judge people that smoke? Of course not. Do I support it? No. Seeing one of my closest family memebers go though the pain caused by him being addicted to cigarets, gives me some good reasons to disagree with smoking. Once you start it's hard to stop, I've wittnessed it. So why would you even get addicted in the first place? 

slimshady1907 | Student

I hate smoking and ı never use it and dont even grab it. Many People started to use smoke to wanna be like their was so bad thing that Many people died because of using smoke ..

ingramh | Student

In my opinion everyone in the world who smokes knows off its negative connotations, yet it us up to them due to the liberal society of which we live in (UK and USA) to decide whether we smoke or not. Smoking bans have been in place due to Rawlsian Harm Principles but smoking should be allowed as it brings in vast revenues to the government and people must have free will as banning people from smoking is a complete and utter rejection of any human right. 

luiji | Student

Just to add an extra slant to this discussion:

Smoking is just the same as breathing in the city air - only a bit worse. If the government is going to make us breathe in all the chemical wastes produced by the factories etc., then they can't ban cigarettes or be horrible to those who use them. Smoking is just one step further than what they force us to do.


chocolatekirby007 | Student

As a student from a society that both shuns and encourages smoking, I have to sa that it is extremel unappleaing to me. In my opinion, there is nothing, justifying smoking as a valuable experience or as a method upon which to lay ones troubles. Smoking is becoming more and more unpopular (in Australia anyway) with the introduction of government campaign against smoking and effective education regimes from an early age.

plshelpme | Student

Smoking, i would say is one of the worst things that man kind has made.

Not only does it affect the smokers health, it also affects the health of those around them. A pregnant woman could harm her baby, an innocent being, by smoking.

A cigarette (and other types of smoking materials) are simply just another money making oppurtunity for greedy businesses, who are looking to profit out of the depression and misery of others.

The addictive nature of smoking, also increases crime around the world and adds to the hurt.

belladona | Student
I think smoking is bad. It doesn't make sense why people do it. It has many health risks, and no benefits. I have always thought that people who started to smoke did so because of stress and peer pressure. That is not a good reason to start.
rahulsk | Student

It should be banned!

luiji | Student

There are no pros of smoking. They are so expensive.

Actually, there is one pro for smoking and that is that smokes are taxed so much that the government makes a pile from people buying cigarettes. The taxes is why they're so expensive.

I've seen people so addicted and broke because of cigarettes. It often happens that they need the smokes, but can't pay for it. They need them so bad, they're shaking, but can't pay for them. They beg me for money, but I can't do anything for them.

I really agree that cigarettes should be banned. If they didn't exist there would be so much less suffering in the world.

suzannah304 | Student

Personally, I hate smoking and even shun those who smoke. The smokers not only put themselves into danger but also the people around them. The smoke from the cigarettes irritates me. Moreover, i just can't stand people smoking in public.

abhisiktakumar | Student

A very serious topic indeed for discussion.I personally feel that,"excessive of anything is good for nothing",so,if people continue smoking as an excessive thing,it would really bother them.I am from India,and when girls smoke here,itz a terrible thing to them.Being frank,even I tried smoking for some months.And here is the result that people around me take it in a wrong way.They call me desperate.But I would simply call it a relaxation item.If a person takes maximum of 2 cigars daily,it would'nt possibly affect them.But yes,again the subject of limit comes here.If anyone goes over his/hers limits,its then going to be a hectic danger for that person.In short,I classify smoking as a timepass subject---IF INHALED WITH LIMITS AND BOUNDARIES,THE PERSON IS GOING TO BE OK.