If you had to compare a modern song with Wordsworth's Lucy Gray poem for a homework assignment, creating a sort of bridge between two times which song would you choose and why? 

2 Answers | Add Yours

durbanville's profile pic

durbanville | High School Teacher | (Level 2) Educator Emeritus

Posted on

Any song that could be chosen to create a link between Lucy Gray by Wordsworth and the modern era needs to be reflective, somber and even perhaps tinged with regret. However, it does depend on who the song is directed at; whether the parents or the child.

From the child's perspective, What a Wonderful World by Louis Armstrong would be a possible choice. Whilst not modern in the context of 2013, it is modern in the Wordsworth context, Lucy Gray having been written in 1799 and published in Wordsworth's Lyrical Ballads. Louis Armstrong's song is wistful and hopeful and as Lucy Gray's footsteps do not reveal her whereabouts nor her death as "she trips along, And never looks behind," the reader can search for possibilities and consider the beauty and simplicity of nature which fits with Wordsworth's own passion for nature. 

Another more modern possibility is Secret Garden's Song for a Stormy Night. The girl can no longer feel "the cold wind blow You are sleeping so deep..." She is safe from harm but it is also as if Lucy Gray could be "wrapped up" in this song. watching over her parents or they over her. This reveals that, no matter how many hundreds of years pass, the similarities between how families protect each other and yearn for a better time, remain the same. Nature continues to wreak havoc in lives and the connection is further established between how modern song writers use their experiences of nature and their understanding of poetry and literature when writing their songs.

Adele is a popular artist and her song, Chasing Pavements is another possible choice. "Should I give up....even if it leads nowhere"  is a decision she cannot make - such is the chorus of the song. Music allows young readers or listeners to understand text they must otherwise interpret as they put it into the context of their own life and environment. 

Sources:
aszerdi's profile pic

aszerdi | Student, Undergraduate | (Level 1) Valedictorian

Posted on

Wordsworth wrote "Lucy Gray" after a moment of inspiration that occurred when he was surrounded by snow. His sister had also told him of an incident where a young girl died in a snowstorm. In this poem Lucy is sent by her father with a lantern to a nearby town and to guide her mother in the snow. However, Lucy becomes lost in the snowstorm while her parents begin to frantically search for her. Her mother notices her tiny footsteps in the fresh snow. They follow them to where they end. After her death, some are still in denial, believing that she is alive and the lonely child she once was. Some people even think that they can hear her song in the wind.

Consequently, the poem "Lucy Gray" conveys emotions of deep loss, denial, and a longing for an individual who has passed on. Certainly, the parents of Lucy also experienced frantic horror and regret upon realizing that their daughter had wandered off, resulting in her death. The poem ends with the sense that this little girl is still with the people of her village and is lovingly remembered.

Katy Perry's song "The One That Got Away," particularly in combination with her music video, also conveys the same feelings of regret and a deep sense of loss for a certain individual. Her memory of this individual almost causes the audience to feel that he has a physical presence.

The Band Perry's song "If I Die Young" could also be a good comparison to this poem because it discusses the loss of an individual who has passed on long before what one would consider their appropriate of "fair" time, the theme of innocence (Lucy trusted her father, and she was lost in a white landscape), as well as a parent's loss.

Sources:

We’ve answered 318,944 questions. We can answer yours, too.

Ask a question