Do you agree with criticism that Hamlet should take action against Claudius sooner than he does?

Yes, I agree with this criticism. Hamlet is too long in deciding to act. He seems to make up his mind only after he hears of the play that the traveling troupe might put on at Elsinore, and then he still waits another two months before acting. And when he does act, it's a flimsy plan that leads him to kill Polonius by accident: no real revenge against Claudius. Furthermore, Hamlet feels awful about himself—and with good reason!—and this self-criticism makes me question whether he will be able to accomplish what his father has asked of him.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

As a matter of fact, I do agree with this criticism. Hamlet decides to act mad, and then waits for months before taking any other "action." Then, he seems only to make a plan once the traveling troupe of actors happens to show up at Elsinore. It surprises me that he would not be quicker to act, given the awful grief Hamlet feels upon the death of his father, the terrible way in which his father was murdered, and the fact that revenge means so much to to his father that his ghost returns to charge Hamlet with the responsibility of avenging him. 

Also damning, for me, is the way Hamlet feels about himself. If he were making progress and pleased with that progress, I might feel less critical of him. Hamlet thinks he's not acting the way he should, though. Consider his speech after he watches an actor emote during a performance: he asks himself, "Am I a coward?": a seemingly rhetorical question whose answer is, evidently, yes (Act II, Scene 2, line 598). He also calls himself a

dull and muddy-mettled rascal, [who] peak[s]
Like John-a-dreams, unpregnant of my cause,
And can say nothing—no, not for a king
Upon whose property and most dear life
A damned defeat was made (Act II, Scene 2, lines 594-598).

Hamlet criticizes and characterizes himself as someone without courage who is, at best, an absent-minded dreamer who accomplishes nothing, despite the fact that he loved his dear father who was defeated in such a despicable way.

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team