Would you explain the poem of "Song of Powers" by David Mason stanza by stanza?

Expert Answers info

Jamel Goldner eNotes educator | Certified Educator

calendarEducator since 2016

write249 answers

starTop subjects are Literature and History

David Mason's "Song of the Powers" presents a unique take on an old childhood game. The basis for the poem is clearly the age-old struggle of "Paper Rock Scissors," with each "power" contributing a stanza to the poem. The first stanza belongs to what is traditionally called the rock. The stone gloats of its power to "crush." It alone is "stronger than wishes" and is able to destroy the scissors (5). However, stanza two belongs to paper, that which the rock cannot destroy.

In stanza two, the paper claims "mine are the words / that smother the stone" (8-9). While words cannot smother, the paper they are written on can, as long as a "shaper" exists to write and the writing exists. In short, it is near-immortal. With its ability to smother rock and live forever, paper's power seems limitless, until the final power speaks.

In stanza three, the scissors claim "all the knives" that are "gnashing through paper's / ethereal lives" (15-16). Despite the fact that paper's words are preserved in print, scissors can still destroy them all. Further, at the end of the stanza, the scissors move beyond the pride espoused by the stone and paper, suggesting, not only pride, but also a certain level of enjoyment in the destruction, stating "no thing's so proper / as tattering wishes" (17-18).

The final stanza presents a different speaker, one that is not part of the traditional three-way game of destruction. This last entity presents the finality of the game, stating that the three entities "all end alone" (22). The narrator then addresses the reader, suggesting the grim finality that the three combatants face is one that all face:

So heap up...

(The entire section contains 2 answers and 577 words.)

Unlock This Answer Now







check Approved by eNotes Editorial

coachingcorner eNotes educator | Certified Educator

calendarEducator since 2008

write1,346 answers

starTop subjects are Literature, Social Sciences, and History

check Approved by eNotes Editorial


kc4u | Student

Mason's poem divided into four parts is principally about the ironies of power. It teaches a very simple moral lesson--however powerful may one be, the real power is a power of unity. All the powerful entities would have to remain united to exercise their power or make something out of it. On the other hand, if they use their power against each other, they will only end up crushing each other, neutralizing their powers and all of them would have die all alone.

The stone, the first declares his power by saying that he is capable of crushing the scissors. He controls time over others. He is more powerful than the vanity of human wishes.

The paper is the second to announce its power of words which can crush a stone with anything that words are able to create. This is the subjective power as opposed to that of the objective, the stone. The stone may shape time but the paper shapes the mind.

The knife is the third announcer. His is a power of violence cutting across a paper, wounding it with all its energy, like tattering the vanity of human desires.

The final stanza tells the story of their mutual neutralization and thus comes the instruction at the end not to wage a war among them. One has to renounce the excesses of desire and destination, cutting them down not to die all alone.

check Approved by eNotes Editorial

Ask a Question