Would The Ultimate Safari have been so successful had it been narrated by someone else (e.g., the grandmother)?

Expert Answers
bmadnick eNotes educator| Certified Educator

Although having the grandmother tell the story would still personalize the events and feelings of the story, it would not be as powerful because the daughter as narrator better reflects the themes of the story. The daughter's innocence about the war and its causes shows the ultimate cruelty of the war. The effect on readers is also more powerful when we see things from a child's point of view. Being able to experience the feelings of this young girl is heart-wrenching because we feel her pain. The difficult trek and their life at the refugee camp represents the daughter's journey from childhood to adulthood. It is her rite of passage. She has to become a mother to her younger brother at a young age, forcing her into adulthood before her time.

I think the story would be successful no matter who the narrator is, but the author realized how much more powerful the message would be when told from a child's point of view. Having to grow up in the midst of such horrendous conditions can be felt by the reader through the little girl's narration.

miley07 | Student

In my opinion if the grandmother had recited the story she would have interpreted the happenings through the view point of an adult and thus the story would not contain the innocence and the perfection which exists now.I mean the grandmother won't praise herself about her bravery and other such good qualities.

Read the study guide:
The Ultimate Safari

Access hundreds of thousands of answers with a free trial.

Start Free Trial
Ask a Question