Why is Tybalt to blame for the deaths of Romeo and Juliet?

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

One could argue that Tybalt is the primary antagonist in the play, and that his brash, aggressive actions indirectly lead to Romeo and Juliet's tragic deaths. In act one, scene five, Romeo and his close friends sneak into Lord Capulet's ball, where he sees Juliet for the first...

This Answer Now

Start your 48-hour free trial to unlock this answer and thousands more. Enjoy eNotes ad-free and cancel anytime.

Start your 48-Hour Free Trial

One could argue that Tybalt is the primary antagonist in the play, and that his brash, aggressive actions indirectly lead to Romeo and Juliet's tragic deaths. In act one, scene five, Romeo and his close friends sneak into Lord Capulet's ball, where he sees Juliet for the first time and expresses his feelings regarding her beauty aloud. Tybalt overhears Romeo and immediately recognizes his voice. As a fierce, hostile individual, Tybalt is offended by Romeo's presence and attempts to fight him. However, Lord Capulet prevents Tybalt from ruining the ball and manages to control him for the time being. Tybalt then vows to get revenge on Romeo and proceeds to challenge him to a duel later in the play.

Romeo then secretly marries Juliet in Friar Laurence's cell, which changes his opinion of the Capulet family. When Tybalt challenges Romeo in act three, scene one, Romeo refuses to participate in the duel and Mercutio defends his honor by accepting Tybalt's challenge. In the middle of Mercutio and Tybalt's duel, Romeo attempts to break up the fight and intervenes. Tybalt uses Romeo's distraction to his advantage by fatally stabbing Mercutio under Romeo's arm. In a fit of rage, Romeo avenges Mercutio's death by killing Tybalt. After killing Tybalt, Romeo is exiled from Verona, and Friar Laurence is forced to come up with a desperate plan for Juliet to fake her death in order to avoid marrying Paris.

Unfortunately, Romeo never receives Friar Laurence's message regarding the sleeping potion and is under the impression that Juliet is actually dead. Once Romeo arrives at Juliet's tomb, he commits suicide and Juliet does the same when she wakes up to discover Romeo's dead body. One could argue that Romeo would have never been exiled from Verona had Tybalt not challenged him to a duel, which tragically led to Mercutio's death and incited his rage. The ensuing miscommunication between Friar Laurence, Juliet, and Romeo would have never happened and the two lovers would have no reason for committing suicide. Therefore, Tybalt's actions in act three, scene one create a serious conflict for the two lovers after Romeo kills him to avenge Mercutio's death and is exiled from Verona.

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Tybalt is the embodiment of the hatred that has long existed between the Capulets and the Montagues. Even Capulet himself has to restrain the hot-blooded Tybalt when the young man recognizes Romeo at the Capulet party (where Romeo and Juliet first meet). This encounter causes Tybalt to bear an insatiable grudge against Romeo, which leads him to the fight that, it could be argued, leads directly to the deaths of the two lovers.

In the first scene of Act III, Tybalt encounters first Mercutio and Benvolio, and then Romeo, in Verona. The Capulet has been looking for Romeo in order to gain satisfaction for the insult he gave him by attending the Capulet festivities in secret. He challenges Romeo to a duel, calling him a "villain." When Romeo, having (unbeknownst to everyone involved) just married Juliet, refuses to fight, Mercutio jumps in, decrying Romeo's "vile submission," and Tybalt kills him, in part because Romeo restrained Benvolio while they were fighting. When Tybalt returns to the scene, Romeo kills him in a duel.

Tybalt's death, which resulted from his challenge to Romeo, sets in motion a chain of events that culminates with the deaths of Romeo and Juliet. The Prince banishes Romeo from the city, and Juliet and the Friar come up with a plan to avoid her scheduled marriage to Paris. The plot does not proceed as planned, though, and the two lovers wind up committing suicide. Because it was the death of Tybalt, caused in no small part by his recklessness, that drove Romeo from Verona, it certainly could be argued that he bears responsibility for the tragic end of the young couple. Certainly Tybalt is as captive to the hatred between the families as any of the other characters, but his hatred is particularly virulent and destructive.

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

In Act I, Scene 1, when Romeo comes on the scene after the street fight which opens the play, he makes the comment that, while the feud between the Montagues and Capulets is based in hatred, it has more to do with a love for fighting:

O me! What fray was here?
Yet tell me not, for I have heard it all.
Here’s much to do with hate, but more with love.
This statement is quite true of Tybalt, Juliet's cousin. He is one of the instigators of the street brawl and seems bent on perpetuating the feud in any way possible. His anger and aggression are one of the major causes which lead Romeo and Juliet to commit suicide at the end of the play.
In Act I, Scene 5, he overhears Romeo speaking at Capulet's party and, when dissuaded by Capulet from fighting Romeo on the spot, vows revenge and sends a letter of challenge to Romeo. In the meantime, Romeo falls madly in love with Juliet and they marry before Romeo ever hears of the challenge. 
In Act III, Scene 1, Tybalt acts on his challenge by seeking out Romeo in the streets. He first comes upon Mercutio and the two trade insults before Romeo enters. When addressed as a "villain" by Tybalt, Romeo immediately backs down because he has just married Juliet. He even suggests that he loves Tybalt. Of course, neither Tybalt nor Mercutio know of Romeo and Juliet's romance and they wind up fighting. Unfortunately, Romeo is unable to stop the sword fight and Mercutio is eventually stabbed by Tybalt who then runs away. Had the scene ended here, Romeo and Juliet may have continued their lives and eventually even announced their marriage and brought the families together just as Friar Laurence had hoped when he performed the marriage.
Despite having already killed one man, "the furious Tybalt" returns to the scene. Obviously, his love of fighting has not been satisfied. Feeling he has been cowardly and "effeminate," Romeo fights Tybalt and promptly kills him. It could certainly be argued that Tybalt's return, and his death at the hands of Romeo, lead directly to the mischief which occurs in the second half of the play. Lord Capulet, believing Juliet to be grieving over her cousin's death, arranges a "day of joy" by promising Juliet to Count Paris. This plan puts Juliet in a problematic situation and ends in her faking her death and the other circumstances which lead to the final suicides of Romeo and Juliet. Tybalt, playing out his role as the main catalyst of feud, is easily blamed for the final tragic events.  
Approved by eNotes Editorial Team