There are several reasons for the anthology approach the editors took with Four Hundred Souls:
- Diversity of approach. The essays in the book are more than conventional historical accounts. While there is some standard academic writing in the book, there are also fictionalized accounts of historical events, speculative history, and even poetry. This is because the editors wished to stress that there is no one, single approach to Black history.
- Diversity of voice. Each essay represents the unique voice and point of view of its author. This is important because it shows that no single perspective "owns" or is responsible for Black history. These multiple voices join in the book to form a dialogue, and reading the book is a way of experiencing history as a conversation.
- Participation. Because the book does not follow the standard model of history, e.g., that history is the story of how the past became the present, readers have to engage with Black history in a more active way. That is, readers are required to process each entry and make connections between essays on their own, in effect writing their own "history" using the essays of the book as building blocks. Black history in this case stops being just a topic and becomes something readers are actively helping to construct.
- Activism. The many authorial perspectives in the text underline the complex politics underlying Black history and the value of that history in fighting white supremacist ideology. The reader is encouraged to reflect on their own experience in the context of Black history and the Black struggle for equality. In this way, history becomes a living thing, and a vital tool in political struggle.