Essentially, Hippolyta feels that it is unkind to ask more of the actors than what they can deliver in terms of acting ability. She refers to Philostrate's previous words about the incompetence of the actors and their inability to execute good performances. Philostrate especially stresses the inability of the actors to do justice to a play named Pyramus and Thisbe. He tells Theseus that "in all the play/ there is not one word apt, one player fitted." What he means is that none of the actors can do justice to their roles in the play. In fact, Philostrate maintains that the actor playing Pyramus did such a terrible job that he (Philostrate) cried tears of laughter during the suicide scene. 

 

Unfortunately, Philostrate's words do not deter Theseus at all. In fact, he is adamant that Pyramus and Thisbe is just the sort of play he wants to see. When Hippolyta protests Theseus' decision, Theseus tells her that they should appreciate the intent of the actors rather than merely dwell upon their failures. Theseus invokes the responsibility of those who are superior to practice noblesse oblige (the duty of the privileged to deal benevolently or kindly with those who are less privileged).

The kinder we, to give them thanks for nothing.

Our sport shall be to take what they mistake.

And what poor duty cannot do, noble respect

Takes it in might, not merit.

Where I have seen them shiver and look pale,