In the story, "The Scartlet Ibis" by James Hurst, why does the character Doodle go to such lengths to bury the scarlet ibis?

2 Answers | Add Yours

sciftw's profile pic

sciftw | High School Teacher | (Level 1) Educator Emeritus

Posted on

I think one possible reason for why Doodle is so intent on burying the ibis is because he's a young boy that knows dead things are supposed to be buried.  I'll briefly use some anecdotal evidence to support.  I have three young children.  We have a cat too.  When the cat brings home a dead lizard or mouse, my kids have this need to bury it.  I don't let them, but left to their own devices, my kids would bury the animal because they know dead things are supposed to be buried.  

I think another possible reason that Doodle wants to bury the bird is because he has respect for the bird.  Giving a proper burial to someone or something is a sign of respect.  It's clear that Doodle is in awe of the bird and its beauty.  

Doodle's hands were clasped at his throat, and I had never seen him stand still so long.

Doodle is mesmerized by the bird and its efforts to continue living.  He's so mesmerized that Brother can hardly believe how still Doodle has become.  When the bird dies, everybody just walks away.  They don't see anything of value in the bird anymore.  However, Doodle still sees great beauty in the dead bird.  A proper burial will give tribute to that. 

Even death did not mar its grace, for it lay on the earth like a broken vase of red flowers, and we stood around it, awed by its exotic beauty. 

Finally, I think Doodle sees a bit of himself in the ibis.  Doodle watches the ibis struggle and struggle to live even though it is in a broken state.  The bird struggles to fly and do what birds do, but it just can't.  It's too injured or tired, and it dies.  For all of Doodle's life, he has struggled with his body not allowing him to do what a normal boy should be capable of doing.  His own family expected him to die soon after birth.  Doodle probably sees his own reflection in the bird, and he feels a great deal of compassion for the dead bird.  That would explain why Doodle is so adamant that he properly bury the bird.  

Sources:
missflusk14's profile pic

missflusk14 | High School Teacher | (Level 2) Adjunct Educator

Posted on

In James Hurst's, "The Scarlet Ibis," we must remember that Doodle was a very frail, sickly little boy who, upon his birth, was not expected to live at all. He spent most of his life unable to walk, he could not run, and he had to be handled very delicately.

The scarlet ibis that found it's way into the backyard of Doodle and his family was frail and weak, but still retained its beauty and grace. When the bird attempted to fly out of the tree, it was unable to coordinate it's wings, and- try as it might- fell to the ground, though "even death did not mar its grace."

The bird's brief appearance in the story was important for a number of reasons. The death of the bird foreshadowed that of Doodle, and the narrator even refers to the desceased Doodle as "my fallen scarlet ibis." The beautiful bird's fraility and devastating sudden death made a strikingly resemblance to that of Doodle. From all of this we can infer that Doodle went to such great lengths to bury the bird, and felt the loss so deeply because he saw himself reflected in the condition of that bird. He saw his own weakness in the ibis, and the death greatly disturbed him and struck fear of his own mortality within himself. 

Sources:

We’ve answered 318,908 questions. We can answer yours, too.

Ask a question