Why did the Scopes "Monkey" Trial attract such widespread national attention? What issues seemed to be at stake?This is a paper im writing for a history class.. and I need a push in the right...

Why did the Scopes "Monkey" Trial attract such widespread national attention? What issues seemed to be at stake?

This is a paper im writing for a history class.. and I need a push in the right direction.. what some paragraph topics could be!

2 Answers | Add Yours

amarang9's profile pic

amarang9 | College Teacher | (Level 2) Educator Emeritus

Posted on

The issues at stake were huge: knowledge, progress, and thinking vs. a fundamentalist viewpoint that religion was the only guide to moral and ethical behavior. Typically, it is referred to as an evolution-creationism debate; or as it's called these days: an evolution-intelligent design debate. It attracted widespread attention because it was controversial. It was illegal (at least in Tennessee where the trial was held) to teach anything that disagreed with the story of Creation in Genesis in the Bible. Both sides saw this as an opportunity to make their case in a national arena (albeit in a small town). So, each hired high profile lawyers (William Jennings Bryan on the religious conservative side and Clarence Darrow on the Darwin/evolution side). Such notoriety increased the already high profile case.

In the end, this trial was more than just a popularization of an ongoing debate. It was a rift between religious doctrine and scientific study, with scientific study being more open to new ideas, developments and 'evolutionary practices' whereas religious zealots stuck to the Bible and all its literal interpretations. It may have, however, led to some religious progress (some Christians accept evolution as a part of Intelligent Design). The trial also may have contributed to the growing political divide between conservatives and liberals: instead of having an open and honest discussion, evolution/creation has been appropriated as a way for each side to mindlessly oppose his/her political 'opposite.'

pohnpei397's profile pic

pohnpei397 | College Teacher | (Level 3) Distinguished Educator

Posted on

The reason this attracted so much attention is because it was sort of a symbol of a culture war that was going on in the country as a whole at that time.

During the 1920s, the culture of the US was changing.  The cities were becoming much more modern than the country.  The values of people in the city were changing, as shown by the presence of flappers and jazz and movies and things like that.

People in the country, traditional people, saw this as a major negative change in the country's cultural and moral fiber so they fought back through such things as the law that Scopes broke.

So the trial was an example of the traditional people pushing back against the move toward modern values that was occurring during this time.

We’ve answered 318,956 questions. We can answer yours, too.

Ask a question