Alien and Sedition Acts of 1798

Start Free Trial

Why did the Federalists believe that the "Sedition Act of 1798" was necessary, and what did Abigail Adams suggest was the nature of the threat? 

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

The Sedition Act of 1798 made it a crime to criticize the government. Combined with the Alien Act which extended the time that it took to become an American citizen from five to fourteen years, these acts served as a test of America's tolerance for eliminating dissent at home in...

This Answer Now

Start your 48-hour free trial to unlock this answer and thousands more. Enjoy eNotes ad-free and cancel anytime.

Start your 48-Hour Free Trial

The Sedition Act of 1798 made it a crime to criticize the government. Combined with the Alien Act which extended the time that it took to become an American citizen from five to fourteen years, these acts served as a test of America's tolerance for eliminating dissent at home in times of international crisis. Then-president John Adams, a Federalist, viewed these acts as important to national security. Britain and France were locked in yet another global conflict and the Federalists, backing Britain, were fighting an undeclared naval war with France with the Quasi-War. Adams worried that French and Irish revolutionaries would want to come to the United States in order to stir turmoil and force a bloody revolution on the new country. In order to look less attractive to these groups, he urged Congress to pass the Alien and Sedition Acts. Abigail Adams supported the passage as she referred to her husband's enemies as "cruel and vile."

The Republicans used this act as campaign material though Adams did not fully follow through on its enforcement. They claimed that the Federalists were only doing this to ensure they kept power for themselves. Adams was an unpopular president in the growing South and West and he was removed in 1800 for the Democratic-Republican Jefferson who removed the act and placed in more favorable policies for France and immigration in general.

While it is easy to dismiss the Alien and Sedition Acts as a Federalist power grab, one should keep in mind that no one knew the future of the American experiment at that time. There were concerns that revolutionaries would overthrow political conservatives in bloody revolutions. The press of that day could be just as cruel as political pundits in the United States today. Adams's primary motivation was to avoid political turmoil at home. His predecessor, George Washington, even endorsed the act from his home in Mount Vernon. The Alien and Sedition Act would serve as one of the United States's first attempts at controlling political dissent and it would be revived in national times of crisis, most notably with America's entry into WWI in 1917.

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

As the 18th Century drew to a close, and with the United States still experiencing growing pains amid political turmoil between the two major political parties, the Federalists and the Republicans, and with fears of a war with France, Congress passed the Alien and Sedition Acts of 1798.  These Acts constituted a major crisis for the new country, and one that tested its democratic values almost before the country could fully consolidate its post-revolution gains.

With France and England still at fighting for supremacy and Revolutionary France encroaching on American prerogatives, particularly with respect to freedom of navigation on the seas, the Federalists and Republicans squared off over alliances and notions of national interest.  With President John Adams preoccupied with the situation with France, the Federalists in Congress succeeded in passing a series of bills designed to restrict immigration by raising the residency requirement from five to 14 years and authorized the arrest and deportation of aliens during time of war.  The Federalists, who fervently supported England’s side in its conflict with France, sought to restrict the ability of immigrants thought to be supportive of France from emigrating to the United States.  These anti-immigrant laws comprised three of the four laws the Federalists passed, and which were signed by President Adams.

It was the fourth of the bills passed, the Sedition Act, that posed the greatest threat to the nascent democracy.  Intended to restrict speech, the law defined as “seditious” and, hence, illegal, the following:

“Section II. Punishes seditious writings.  Definition of offence:

To write, print, utter or publish, or cause it to be done, or assist in it, any false, scandalous, and malicious writing against the government of the United States, or either House of Congress, or the President, with intent to defame, or bring either into contempt or disrepute, or to excite against either the hatred of the people of the United States, or to stir up sedition, or to excie unlawful combinations against the government, or to resist it, or to aid or encourage hostile designs of foreign nations.”

In passing the Sedition Act, the Federalists intended to criminalize Republican opposition to Federalist-supported policies with respect to the “Quasi War” waging at sea with France.  The Republicans, who more liberal on immigration issues and who sympathized with France, whose revolution ostensibly represented the values upon which the United States was founded, were the targets of the Sedition Act, and Republican-supporting newspaper editors were tried and convicted of violating the Act, fortunately, a misdemeanor under the terms of the new law.

President Adams wife, Abigail Adams, was a staunch supporter of the Federalists and that support extended to the Aliens and Sedition Acts.  Abigail Adams was not opposed to war with France, and believed, as did the Federalists, that enemies within were as threatening to her husband, the president, and, by extension, to the country, as were enemies from outside, in effect, France.  The Aliens and Sedition Acts represented the first major test of the resiliency of the new republic.  Their expiration in 1801, coinciding with the end of John Adams presidency, was not challenged by the Federalists, who had succeeded in their goal of roiling the political waters to the disadvantage of the Republicans.

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team