Why did Federalists oppose the Louisiana Purchase and what did they plan to do about it?

Expert Answers
pohnpei397 eNotes educator| Certified Educator

Some of the Federalists did not like the idea of the Louisiana Purchase because it was likely to help their political enemies and hurt themselves.  However, we should not overstate the opposition to the purchase.  Major Federalist figures like Alexander Hamilton and John Adams actually did support the purchase because they wanted to strengthen the nation as a whole.  However, there were some Federalists who felt that the purchase was a bad idea because it would strengthen Thomas Jefferson and his political party.

The main reason why the Federalists did not like the Louisiana Purchase was that it would add more land to the South.  The South was not an area with many Federalists.  Because of this, the purchase was likely to add to the political power of the Jeffersonians.  In the short term, it was also likely to get Jefferson reelected.  Finally, the Federalists were worried that the purchase would bring in huge new areas of land that could be settled by the small farmers that were major supporters of Jefferson’s party.

Some Federalists talked of secession over this issue, but the talk really did not get very far.  So, to the extent that Federalists disliked the Louisiana Purchase, it was for political reasons and they did very little to try to prevent the purchase.

 

kmj23 eNotes educator| Certified Educator

To understand why some Federalists were opposed to the Louisiana Purchase, take a look at the following extract from an editorial written by Alexander Hamilton in 1803:

As to the unbounded region west of the Mississippi... a wilderness through which wander numerous tribes of Indians. And when we consider the present extent of the United States, and that not one-sixteenth part of its territory is yet under occupation, the advantage of the acquisition, as it relates to actual settlement, appears too distant and remote to strike the mind of a sober politician with much force.

In other words, the Federalists opposed this purchase because the land was inhabited by Native Americans and, therefore, the chance of being able to settle people here seemed low, if not impossible. (Read the full source in the first reference link provided).

In response to the president's desire to go ahead with the purchase, some Federalists, like those in new England, threatened to secede from the United States. These threats, however, did not hinder the purchase and, in fact, during a vote in the Senate, the motion passed with an overwhelming majority, at 26 votes to 6. (See the second reference link).

Access hundreds of thousands of answers with a free trial.

Start Free Trial
Ask a Question