The Articles of Confederation

Start Free Trial

Why did the Articles of Confederation fail?

The Articles of Confederation failed because they did not grant the federal government enough power to govern the nation effectively. They did not allow the federal government to draft troops, levy taxes to repay the country's debts, or regulate commerce. The Articles also did not establish federal courts. They were abandoned after Shays' Rebellion.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

The Articles of Confederation and Perpetual Union, often shortened in common usage to the Articles of Confederation, was the first constitution of the fledgling United States of America. It was approved by Congress on November 15, 1777, and after ratification by all thirteen states, it finally came into force on...

See
This Answer Now

Start your 48-hour free trial to unlock this answer and thousands more. Enjoy eNotes ad-free and cancel anytime.

Get 48 Hours Free Access

The Articles of Confederation and Perpetual Union, often shortened in common usage to the Articles of Confederation, was the first constitution of the fledgling United States of America. It was approved by Congress on November 15, 1777, and after ratification by all thirteen states, it finally came into force on March 1, 1781. It established a government and promoted free travel and trade. However, its inherent weaknesses made it necessary to draft and adopt a new and stronger US Constitution, which replaced the Articles of Confederation in early 1789.

There are several reasons why the Articles of Confederation failed. One of the main difficulties under the Articles of Confederation was the inability of the federal government to levy taxes. The United States had incurred substantial debt during the Revolutionary War, but without a system of federal taxation, the country was unable to pay back its creditors. The federal government had to request money from the states, and there was no system of enforcement to compel the states to honor their financial obligations to the government. To make up for the shortfall, Congress printed more money, causing the value of the currency to depreciate. Additionally, Congress did not have the authority to regulate commerce, which caused chaos as each state implemented individual trade policies.

The Articles allowed Congress to maintain a Continental Army in times of need, but it did not provide Congress with the authority to compel the states to supply troops, funds, and supplies. The states each maintained individual armies and navies, but this system made it difficult to unify in the face of a national threat.

The other major failure in the Articles of Confederation was the document's limited vision of what form the federal government would take. Under the Articles, Congress was the only federal institution, so there was no balance of power. The newer, stronger US Constitution provided for three branches of government: the executive branch (the president), the legislative branch (Congress), and the judicial branch (the Supreme Court and other federal courts). These three branches formed a system of checks and balances so that no single branch of government would become too powerful.

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

There were several reasons why the government created by the Articles of Confederation failed. This plan of government was designed to create a weak federal government. This caused many problems.

There were financial problems. Because the federal government did not have the power to tax, it had trouble raising money. As a result, the US had difficulty repaying its debts. When too much paper money was printed, inflation occurred.

The US also had difficulty dealing with the aggressive actions of other countries toward it. Great Britain would not leave the western lands. Additionally, countries such as Spain and Great Britain interfered with trade. Since the government could not force people to join the military, the military was very small. With little money available for supplies, the military was poorly equipped. As a result, the US was in no position to fight against these countries that were causing problems for it.

The government created by the Articles of Confederation had other issues. Because there were no federal courts, the states had no place where they could resolve disputes. Additionally, it took nine of the thirteen states to pass a law and thirteen of the thirteen states to change the Articles of Confederation. Finally, Shays’ Rebellion showed that, at times, the federal government had trouble keeping order.

Eventually, a decision was made to attempt to write a new plan of government. The Constitution was eventually created and adopted.

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

The Articles of Confederation failed because they did not give Congress and the national government enough power. The new United States had just fought a war to end what they considered tyrannical rule by a strong government that overpowered local government, and the leaders of the US feared a powerful central government. Because of this, they did not give the central government the power it needed to rule effectively. The Articles did not give Congress the power to tax, so the government ended up printing money, which caused inflation. The Articles did not give Congress the power to draft troops, so the US military was small, leaving the US weak. Congress did not have the power to control interstate commerce or stop states from printing their own money, causing economic chaos within the US. The Articles did not give Congress the power to place tariffs on foreign goods, hurting American businesses that could not compete with cheaper British goods. The US government had no chief executive, so there was no one to enforce the laws that were passed. The list can go on. With the rebellion led by Daniel Shays in Massachusetts, the leaders of the US realized the Articles were not working, which led to the Constitutional Convention, where the Articles were abandoned and the new US Constitution was written, which addressed many of the problems found with the Articles.

Posted on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

They failed because they did not manage to convince the elites of society that their interests would be protected by the sorts of governments that sprang up under the Articles.

During the time that the US was under the Articles, there were various kinds of economic problems. The state governments' responses to the problems (spurred by the demands of the common people who were being hurt most by the problems) hurt the interests of the elites. They also convinced the elites that the nation would not be able to prosper economically under the sorts of governments that would take those steps.

So, the Articles failed because the elites who took the most interest in government felt that the governments were acting in ways that were bad for a) the interests of the elites and b) the long-term interests of the country as a whole.

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team