As a whole, is Gaines' work concerned with the character and society, human nature and values, or the nature of our existence? 

The text as a whole is concerned with all three issues in a way that is complex and convergent. In this way, the text is addressing the complexities of the human condition itself. James, who is an adolescent, must undergo a rite of passage in which he becomes an adult. This rite of passage involves the "becoming" of manhood. The title alone indicates that James will be going through some sort of change from boy to man, and that it will be a challenging and difficult journey for him. Moreover, when we first meet James' family he already seems like an individual who isn't sure who he is or what he wants to do with his life. He isn'

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

I don't think that Gaines' work is forcing a choice between the three options. It seems to me that Gaines' work is concerned with all three realities. The scope and thematic nature of the text is one in which these issues all are relevant to its understanding. 

James is developed...

See
This Answer Now

Start your 48-hour free trial to unlock this answer and thousands more. Enjoy eNotes ad-free and cancel anytime.

Get 48 Hours Free Access

I don't think that Gaines' work is forcing a choice between the three options. It seems to me that Gaines' work is concerned with all three realities. The scope and thematic nature of the text is one in which these issues all are relevant to its understanding. 

James is developed in both the trials he must face as an individual and his relationship to society.  James "becoming a man" and what that entails encompasses both individual and social realms.  The element of what it means to have values and the composition of one's human nature is relevant as James seeks to understand the reality of a segregated South, a world in which Civil Rights for people of color is not evident.  The reaction one has to such a condition is of vital importance to the narrative, and is one in which James' understanding of human nature and the values to which one ascribes are relevant.  In listening to the discussion in the doctor's office, with different points of view being articulated, James seeks to understand and define his own sense of human nature and the values that can be used to define such a nature.  The ending in which his mother affirms to him what it means to "be a man" is not only an answer to the complex and thorny issue of how one defines their human nature and values in a world of segregation, but also helps to define the nature of one's existence.  The question that James does not necessarily articulate, but completely experiences is whether or not the nature of one's existence is an identity in which one takes the form of the world around them or seeks to define themselves in a transcendent manner from it.  James struggles to understand or to grasp the complex implications of such a profound question.  The nature of one's existence lies at the heart of such a discourse.  James' mother realizes this and seeks to assist James in developing the nature of his existence as to transcend what is around him.  The end lesson of "becoming a man" is an idea that suggests that the nature of one's existence is something that can transcend what is around the individual and move them into a realm of what can be and what should be.  In this, the work addresses all three issues in a complex and convergent manner.

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team