who is importantA teacher or a doctor, who is much important? explain why.

Expert Answers
mstultz72 eNotes educator| Certified Educator

Both are important.  Historically, teachers have been undervalued and doctors have been overvalued.  But, the disparity is lessening of late.

On an basic level, both are taken for granted.  Particularly with doctors, we only notice them when things go wrong.  So, society, in effect, sets them up to fail.  Lately, with malpractice suits and the increasing cost of health care, their hands are becoming more tied, so there will be a trend on their part to be more conservative with their practices.

Teachers' hands too are tied by the "flavor of the month" revolving door of education pedagogy and budget initiatives.  Their impact is more a sum total of quite unnoticeable dividends that rarely gets rewarded.  Until teachers are properly compensated (maybe with a merit pay), then they will continue to go unnoticed and taken for granted.

lfawley eNotes educator| Certified Educator

This is sort of a what came first, the chicken or the egg, post in that doctors needed to exist (well, medical science at least) in order for the information to exist so that one generation could tech it to the next. Today, the knowledge exists, so the teacher can be seen as more important because without him or her how would the next generation gain the knowledge to become doctors? But, and here is the conundrum, if the teacher becomes ill, the doctor then is more important to save the life of the teacher. This is a bit of a trick question, and one for which there is no clear answer!

besure77 eNotes educator| Certified Educator

Everyone is part of a "circle of life" if you will. It doesn't matter if a person works at McDonalds or is nuclear engineer, they are all important in some fashion.

Back to the teacher and doctor discussion I would like that add that they are equally important. Teachers teach the doctors how to be doctors. Doctors treat teachers when they are sick which allows them to continue teaching.

Society is functional in a very intricate way. Everyone has a role to play whether it be the stay at home mom, the teacher, or the doctor.

jmj616 eNotes educator| Certified Educator

The Talmud asks, "Who is worthy of honor?"  The Talmud answers: "He who honors others is worthy of honor."

We can answer your question in a similar way.  If you treat other people with importance (that is, with respect, sensitivity, etc.) then you are important.  If you treat objects with importance (so as not to waste them) then you are important.  If you treat ideas with importance (you think about them carefully and respectfully) then you are important. 

ask996 eNotes educator| Certified Educator

Perhaps we're asking the wrong question here. Lets ask, "Does society value teachers as much as it should?" My answer to this is no. If you ask teachers, most would say that they didn’t go into teaching for the money. Why, however, should we have to feel that way? Why can’t we have as much expectation of financial success as someone in another career--doctors for example?

linalarocca eNotes educator| Certified Educator

I agree with lrwilliams previous post. The doctor would have needed at least one good teacher to inspire him to achieve his career goals! I suppose the function of each profession varies. For instance, a teacher should motivate you to learn and achieve; on the other hand, a doctor should ensure that you maintain your health. Both are equally important, however. 

lrwilliams eNotes educator| Certified Educator

I would agree that it is impossible to rank one profession as more important than others, as someone else said for us to maintain a functional society we need all types of professions. However, being a teacher I would ask this, would the doctor have become a doctor without the passion and inspiration of at least one teacher at some point in his life!!

linalarocca eNotes educator| Certified Educator

I agree with post #1. It is difficult to understand what you are speaking of in terms of who is important. We would need a much more clearer description of what it is you mean. I have understood your question to be an open question.  Therefore, I believe all living things to be of varying degrees of importance.

M.P. Ossa eNotes educator| Certified Educator

Since teachers create all other professions and it is a teacher who inspires you to either love or hate school and education, I go with teacher.

However, the true answer is that either or is important as long as they do their jobs right, with passion, and always striving to succeed at it.

booksnmore eNotes educator| Certified Educator

I see this question as a circle... You can't have a good teacher without a good doctor. You can't have a good doctor without a good teacher. Consider the pioneer days...every town wanted BOTH a doctor and a teacher. Both valuable. Both necessary. Impossible to rank.

bullgatortail eNotes educator| Certified Educator

I agree with linda-allen's previous post. All people and their professions are important, and ranking the importance of a job is demeaning to others. I do believe, however, that a great teacher is more important than a poor doctor and vice versa.

linda-allen eNotes educator| Certified Educator

You are important. I am important. Every single human being on earth is important. It is not a good idea to start ranking the importance of people. It can lead to thinking that some might be expendable.

crystaltu001 | Student

I think that both are important jobs. teachers teach you things that you have to learn. Doctors help you with injuries and check and make sure that you are healthy and okay.

Wiggin42 | Student

It seems silly to rank people based on their profession. Society would suffer if either career group (doctor or teacher) decided to stop working. For that matter think about sanitary workers, janitors, "lunch ladies", etc... The people we overlook and take for granted. If they all stopped working, we would know of it. 

nusratfarah | Student

This is a sor of cyclical order. It is a teacher who paves way for making a doctor since a doctor reaches his goal by taking help from his teachers, in fact s/he learns all the skills from the teacher of the medical college. And, a teacher must take aid of a doctor when s/he is ill. So, both are equally important. No professional can be claimed to be less significant than the other.

frizzyperm | Student

This is a meaningless question. It is, I suspect, a mischievous attempt to put the cat amongst the pigeons in order to enjoy the resulting broo-hah-hah.

To create some sort of empirical answer would need vast amounts of research, theorising and philosophy and would need a huge improvment in our understanding of sociology, psychology, medicine, education etc etc

Which is more important... green or purple?

krishna-agrawala | Student

We need teachers to produce able doctors as well as all the other people who are so useful to the society. Teachers add to the capability of all people in society. In this way they contribute in a significant way to the overall performance and improvement of society.

Without doctors we will have people with poor health but who are capable in their work. But without teachers we will have an entire society of ignorant and incompetent people. In such a society even health of people will suffer in absence of good doctors.

odame2 | Student

its a teacher, without a teacher a can be a doctor, without a doctor i can still me be a life. with de reachers of scincetist herbs can make leave