Is Rakesh really a devoted son?

2 Answers | Add Yours

akannan's profile pic

Ashley Kannan | Middle School Teacher | (Level 3) Distinguished Educator

Posted on

The original question had to be edited down.  Though the ending of the story might not present it to be such, I think that Rakesh is a devoted son.  He is devoted to his parents.  He does everything that is asked of him.  He does well in school, achieves and succeeds in a profession that brings his parents pride and joy, marries a woman of their choosing, comes back to India when they ask, and tends to his father when he is a weakened state.  He is devoted in that he is able to put his aside his own wishes for their betterment and their word.  The bond that he carries as their son does not dissipate as he gets older.  In other words, he remains their son, even taking priority over as husband or father.  

In this light, Rakesh would have to be seen as a devoted son.  There is little more he can do.  The ending of the story where he denies his father his wants is only done because of health concerns.  Rakesh is simply using his own knowledge, gained at the wishes of his parents, to help his father's own health.  He is a devoted son because the question remains as to what else he needs to do to make them happy.

Sources:
ltelford's profile pic

ltelford | (Level 1) eNoter

Posted on

Yes I believe he is, at first he shows his devotion by doing everything that his parents ask of him.  He does not just do it, he does it well to show his appreciation to his parents for giving him the opportunity.  He could have married anyone but to show his devotion and respect he married the choice of his parents.  When his parents were aging he showed his devotion by putting up with all the emotional isolation from his father, the abusive behaviour he showed toward him.  He still continued to look after him in a way which was gentle but firm so he understood that what he was doing was in his father's best interest.  So yes I believe that he did does show incredible devotion. 

We’ve answered 318,990 questions. We can answer yours, too.

Ask a question