In "The Crucible" what's ironic about Proctor's calling the trials a black mischief?  And about Cheever arresting Elizabeth?

3 Answers | Add Yours

dbello's profile pic

dbello | High School Teacher | (Level 1) Educator

Posted on

The irony behind Proctor's condescending label of 'black mischief' with regard to the trials was to suggest that they were not fair trials, but a mockery of a trial. These 'trials' had nothing to do with 'the truth', instead they were orchestrated to promote hysteria within the community by suggesting certain people in the community were acting upon satan's instruction, and as such had to be exposed and punished because their actions or beliefs differed from that of the status-quo. The idea of promoting an unfounded fear within a society in order to side-track them from the reality of their true circumstances can work well if delievered in what looks like a just and noble cause. Remember, Arthur Miller wrote this novel in order to highlight the actions of what Senator Joseph McCarthy and his Committee of Un-American activities was doing in 1957. His novel was set in the past, however his intent was clearly meant as a wake-up call for the 1950's American society. Miller uses Cheever to epitomize hypocrisy, however worse than that in the 1950's Miller suggests people might not be everything they seem...

mrs-campbell's profile pic

mrs-campbell | High School Teacher | (Level 1) Educator Emeritus

Posted on

Ironic typically means that something occurs that is the opposite of what you might have expected.  So, witchcraft itself is usually referred to as a black art; in fact, Danforth even asks Proctor if he keeps his "black allegiance" to the devil.  So the fact that John calls the trials a black mischief is taking the descriptors that are usually reserved for witches, and placing it on the people that are condemning others for witchcraft.  You would expect that the trials would be a beacon of truth and sanity; ironically and unfortunately, they aren't in this historic situation.

As for Cheever arresting Elizabeth, that is ironic because it is hinted that Cheever is good friends with the Proctors.  In fact, Elizabeth herself tells John, "Let you go to Ezekiel Cheever-he knows you well", wanting John to tell him what Abby said.  Elizabeth feels that Cheever will be able to help John to vindicate the honor of those women accused.  Ironically, it is Cheever himself that comes, not to help, but to arrest Elizabeth.  This must have been a hard blow for the Proctors, to see a friend so taken by the courts.

graftona's profile pic

graftona | High School Teacher | eNotes Newbie

Posted on

It's ironic because John engaged in some of his own "black mischief" (his affair with Abigail) before this even started.  Had he not done that this situation would not even have occured.

We’ve answered 318,912 questions. We can answer yours, too.

Ask a question