What's the fallacy in the following argument: Cancer cells can be eliminated by treatment. Aren't criminals cancer cells of society? Eliminate criminals.
Expert Answers
| Certified Educator
calendarEducator since 2005
write1,773 answers
starTop subjects are Literature, History, and Business
A second fallacy lies in the grammar. The answer "eliminate criminals" ignores the prepositional phrase of the statement "by treatment." Elimination is dependent upon the treatment. Really the original statement should be reworded: Treatment can eliminate cancer cells. Then, if the analogy of criminals being the cancer cells of society is accepted (false analogy, though, they don't share enough qualities in commone), then the conclusion would be "Treat criminals", not "Eliminate".
| Certified Educator
calendarEducator since 2007
write2,654 answers
starTop subjects are Literature, History, and Science
Well, in many case more than one fallacy applies, but this one seems pretty clearly to be a weak analogy. Simply put, criminals are not the cancer cells of society, and the parallel is a weak one, leading to, as the final phrase indicates, false conclusions.
Looking a bit outside the statement, consider how cancer (cells) is treated (chemotherapy, radiation therapy, surgical removal of the cancer, etc) and the cost of going through treatment. Cancer treatments not only eliminate the cancer cells, but they also kill other cells (good cells) in your body. So if criminals of society were like cancer cells, treating/eliminating them would mean killing other innocent people of society at the same time. Not to mention, cancer treatments are not always successful (person dies, cancer cells come back, cancer cells aren't 100% eradicated, etc). Like what others have said before, the analogy is weak or can't be made between the two. In my opinion, I think one difference lies in the fact that for cancer patients, if they don't go through treatment - they die, if they do - they might still die, but at least there's chance of living. And thats not necessarily the case for criminals in society, its not a do or die situation.
Unlock This Answer Now
Start your 48-hour free trial to unlock this answer and thousands more. Enjoy eNotes ad-free and cancel anytime.
Ask a Question
Popular Questions
- In 1984, what are the four ministries and their purposes?
-
5 educator answers
- In 1984, what do these 3 slogans mean: War is Peace, Freedom is Slavery, and Ignorance is...
-
2 educator answers
- What does Winston mean by, "Freedom is the freedom to say that two plus two makes four. If that...
-
2 educator answers
- Can somebody explain the quotation from George Orwell's "1984," "we shall meet in a place where...
-
1 educator answer
- In George Orwell's 1984, what are the four government ministries that control the world of Big...
-
1 educator answer
- What is the Two Minutes Hate and what is its purpose in the story?
-
2 educator answers
- Does Winston die at the end of 1984, or is the image of the bullet in his brain at the Ministry...
-
3 educator answers
- In 1984, why does Winston have a diary?
-
2 educator answers
- What is Orwell's message in 1984?
-
3 educator answers
- In Orwell's 1984, what is the purpose of the telescreen?
-
2 educator answers
Student Answers