Political Science

Start Free Trial

What would be the ramifications if the United States had a direct election for president instead of the electoral college?

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

If the electoral college were eliminated, then the voices of the populace of the smaller states would be substantially diminished. Candidates for President would be inclined to spend most of their time and resources in the Northeast and West Coast. The Midwest, South, and other parts of the country would be virtually ignored. The framers of the Constitution created the Electoral College not only to preserve the sovereignty of the individual states; but also to see that the smaller states had some voice in the election of the President. Obviously, the vote in the electoral college is heavily weighted toward the larger states, as it should be; but the smaller states are not totally eliminated. Every election year, there are vociferous voices calling for the elimination of the electoral college; and every election those voices fall silent. After over 200 years, the best argument for the Electoral College is that it works quite well.

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team