What were three problems with the Articles of Confederation?

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles
  1. Without a central government it was impossible to have a coherent foreign policy. Matters relating to territorial disputes with other countries, for example, could only be dealt with at the statewide level, and as different states had different interests, this meant that the United States couldn't speak with one voice...

Unlock
This Answer Now

Start your 48-hour free trial to unlock this answer and thousands more. Enjoy eNotes ad-free and cancel anytime.

Start your 48-Hour Free Trial
  1. Without a central government it was impossible to have a coherent foreign policy. Matters relating to territorial disputes with other countries, for example, could only be dealt with at the statewide level, and as different states had different interests, this meant that the United States couldn't speak with one voice on the international stage.
  2. Under the Articles of Confederation, there was no Federal Bank. So there was no effective way for the United States to pay off the enormous debts it had accrued to pay for the Revolutionary War. Congress had been charged with the responsibility of paying off the national debt, but it had to rely on the individual states to give what they owned, and for one reason or another, this didn't always happen.
  3. The Articles couldn't prevent the spread of domestic political disturbances across state boundaries. Matters of law and order were the exclusive responsibility of the states, yet if the states failed in discharging their responsibilities, as they did in the case of Shay's Rebellion, then there was every danger that such disorders would spread to neighboring states, thus potentially undermining the good order and stability of the nation as a whole.
Approved by eNotes Editorial Team
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Our first plan of government was called the Articles of Confederation. It had several weaknesses. One of the weaknesses was that the federal government was designed to be a weak one. We were afraid of having a strong federal government because of our experiences while colonies of Great Britain. We didn’t want a leader or the government to have too much power so various restrictions were put in place. This led to significant issues for our country.

Another problem was financial. Because Congress couldn’t tax, it was difficult for the government to raise money. As a result, we had a hard time paying our debts to other countries. There also was no unified currency. Each state and the federal government printed money. This led to inflation, and people had a hard time trusting any of the paper money that was issued.

A third problem was dealing with foreign affairs. Other countries were pushing us around. Since we couldn’t make people join the military, it was hard to maintain an army to respond to these problems. Also, we didn’t have much money to pay soldiers and get equipment. Thus, we were limited in how we could respond to other countries when they interfered with our trade or encouraged Native Americans to attack us.

Because we couldn’t require people to join the army, it also led to issues at home. When farmers in western Massachusetts revolted in Shays’ rebellion, the federal government didn’t step in to end the rebellion. Because of these problems, a new plan of government was needed. This led to the writing of the Constitution.

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team