What were the problems and challenges people faced in ancient Mesopotamia and the Nile River Valley that led to the creation of civilizations?

2 Answers | Add Yours

thanatassa's profile pic

thanatassa | College Teacher | (Level 3) Educator Emeritus

Posted on

The first major issue people faced in these areas was the problem of how to sustain a food supply. The neolithic transition, in which people settled down in one area to farm rather than moving as hunter-gatherers, allowed for more efficient food production than had existed previously, but the increased population density also required the ability to produce a steady food supply within a limited area. In both regions, this required people to cooperate to develop irrigation systems. 

The concentration of population in fixed settlements raises other issues that would not have been problems in small bands of hunter-gatherers. One needs to arrange for clean drinking water and disposal of human waste downstream of sources of drinking water, for example. The use of fire for cooking and metallurgy in a settlement means one needs a cooperative means of dealing with fires. As one no longer has the safety valve of forming a new small band and moving away from conflicts, there needs to be some official conflict resolution mechanism and various forms of laws about property. All these give rise to the need for many of the mechanisms of government that we see developing in ancient Egypt and Mesopotamia, including legal codes, taxation, and some form of government bureaucracy. 

 

Sources:
mkoren's profile pic

mkoren | Middle School Teacher | (Level 3) Senior Educator

Posted on

There were several problems which the people of ancient Mesopotamia and the Nile River Valley faced which helped lead to the establishment of civilizations.  One of the issues was food.  In some places, the land was difficult to farm.  In other places, there were the yearly floods which destroyed everything.  This was tied to the second problem, which was a water supply they weren't able to control.  Every year, the floods came, potentially destroying everything they had.  Developing irrigation systems would help.  It was necessary to formulate a plan to build these irrigation systems.  Once this problem was overcome, the irrigation systems needed to be maintained.  If the silt wasn't cleaned out of the irrigation systems, water wouldn't freely flow.  There weren't enough people to do this job.  Overcoming this was an issue.  Finally, there were attacks by outsiders.  Because these problems were serious and needed solutions, ancient civilizations were created.

Sources:

We’ve answered 318,990 questions. We can answer yours, too.

Ask a question