What ways is the plot of The Scarlet Letter driven (almost mandated) by the motivations of its main character?

2 Answers | Add Yours

timbrady's profile pic

timbrady | College Teacher | (Level 1) Educator

Posted on

Dimmesdale's motivation, to remain a minister and not reveal himself as Pearl's father, drives everything he does.  His inability to deal with the "reality" of what he has done as creates the guilt that leads to us personal destruction.  If he and Hester could have stood on the scaffold the first day, the novel would have ended there.

Chillingworth's desire for revelation and revenge determines everything that he does in the novel.  Almost every action he performs is driven by this need.  Once he suspects Dimmesdale, he does everything he can to prove that he is the father.  Even when Dimmesdale is about to confess, he begs him not to so that he can continue his work of torture and destruction.  When he loses the object of his revenge, he dies shortly afterward because he has lost his reason for existence.

Hester's is motivated by her desire to raise Pearl as a "normal" child, to protect her from the community that seeks to take her away.  Since Pearl is such a strange child, this is not always easy.  She also is motivated by her secret, never mentioned, desire to be with Dimmesdale ---- secret, at least, until Chapter XVII when their unchanging nature of their love is revealed.  Even though it may lead to his destruction, Hester honors Dimmesdale's need to remain "hidden."

All these separate and sometimes conflicting emotions create the memorable story of these 3 conflicted individuals.

mshurn's profile pic

Susan Hurn | College Teacher | (Level 1) Educator Emeritus

Posted on

The novel is indeed driven by Hester's motivations. They account directly for the circumstances of the story and the events as they unfold.

First of all, the story could not have happened at all if, after Pearl's birth, Hester had chosen to leave the Puritan community. She could have taken Pearl (as she did seven years later) and returned to England. Instead, motivated by her deep love for Dimmesdale and her desire to be near him, she chose to remain and bear humiliation and punishment.

By keeping Chillingworth's real identity a secret, Hester enabled his quest for revenge. Once he realized he had found Pearl's father, Chillingworth then dedicated himself to torturing Dimmesdale, psychologically and perhaps even physically. (There is a suggestion Chillingworth was poisoning Dimmesdale.) The old physician's relationship with Dimmesdale and the effects of his revenge upon Dimmesdale comprise most of the story, all brought about by Hester's agreeing to meet Chillingworth's demand. Why did Hester agree to never acknowledge Chillingworth as her husband? She was motivated by guilt for how she had betrayed him; she knew the shame and humiliation her act brought to him. Also, Hester keeps Chillingworth's secret to protect Arthur Dimmesdale. Chillingworth threatened he would surely find and harm the father of her child if she revealed him for who he was.

Hester finally reveals Chillingworth's identity to Arthur because she is motivated to save his life and to convince him to leave the settlement with her and Pearl. Hester has watched Dimmesdale waste away; she is aware of his suffering. Meeting him in the forest, she tells him the truth. As a result, they both profess their love and plan to run away. This throws Arthur into his most severe and final test of moral principles and spiritual beliefs. Instead of leaving, he climbs the scaffold, confesses, feels forgiveness, and dies. Thus the main story ends, its major conflicts resolved.

All that remains is Hester's return to Boston many years later, where she lives out the remainder of her life, dies, and is buried next to Arthur. These events, too, result from her motivation. Hester's reasons for returning remain somewhat unclear, although the narrator suggests what they might have been.

We’ve answered 318,964 questions. We can answer yours, too.

Ask a question