In O. Henry's short story "The Last Leaf," when does the turning point begin?

Expert Answers

Want to remove ads?

Get ad-free questions with an eNotes 48-hour free trial.

Try It Free No Thanks
mwestwood eNotes educator| Certified Educator

O. Henry's poignant story of two young ladies from disparate parts of the country who live together in artistic harmony finds Johnsy from California having succumbed to pneumonia while her friend Sue endeavors to keep Johnsy from succumbing to the disease.  When Johnsy declares that she will die when all the leaves on the vine outside their window fall off, Sue becomes extremely anxious.  For, there is a strong wind outside.  Desperate to find something to distract Johnsy from her morbid thoughts, Sue goes downstairs in the apartment building.  There she contacts Mr. Behrman who is past sixty and has yet to paint his masterpiece.  Sue convinces Behrman to come upstairs and pose for her. 

Having told Behrman how ill Johnsy is, his eyes fill with tears as he talks with Sue.  Upstairs, they "looked at each other for a moment without speaking." The next morning, Johnsy awakens and asks Sue to raise the shade: "Put it up; I want to see," she orders Johnsy.  This is the turning point, the highest point of emotional intensity in the story.  Fearfully, Johnsy lifts the green shade, revealing one yellowed leaf, the "last leaf."  Nevertheless, Johnsy says that the leaf will fall and she will die when it does.  But, the tenacious leaf remains into the next day.  So, Johnsy declares,

 "I've been a bad girl,,,Something has made that last leaf stay there to show me how wicked I was.  It is a sin to want to die."

She lives.  But, the falling action finds that poor Behrman has succumbed to pneumonia now, himself.  It seems he painted his masterpiece after all.