What was the significance of the Lucknow Pact?   

The significance of the Lucknow Pact was that it showed that Hindus and Muslims could put aside their religious differences and join together in support of common political goals. Tensions between the two religious communities had existed in India for centuries. And yet, in the Lucknow Pact, Hindus and Muslims were able to overcome them and present a list of common demands to the colonial British authorities.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

The Lucknow Pact of 1916 was a significant event in modern Indian history for several key reasons. First of all, it showed the possibility of Hindu and Muslim cooperation to achieve a common goal. Both the Hindu dominated Indian National Congress and the Muslim League wanted to pressure the British colonial authorities to grant Indians more autonomy in their country. For some time before this agreement, there had been real concerns over growing tensions between the two factions. This agreement showed promise that they could come together in cooperation towards a common goal. Although he would later advocate for partition, Muhammad Ali Jinnah left this conference being hailed as the "ambassador of Hind-Muslim Unity."

The Lucknow Pact also led to more amicable relations within the Indian National Congress itself. Extremists, led by Lala Lajpat Rai, Bipin Chandra Pal, Bal Gangadhar Tilak were able to work with the moderate faction of Gopal Krishna Gokhale to reach a consensus.

It would be over thirty years before India was granted full independence. Before that could happen, British authorities were able to erode much of the Hindu-Muslim unity established with the Lucknow Pact. However, this important agreement was able to lay much of the framework for Indian self-rule. The provisions that it established allowed many to get important administrative experience that would be needed to manage an independent nation.

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

In keeping with their religious differences, the Indian National Congress and the Muslim League had tended to pursue different interests. Whereas the main focus of the Indian National Congress was on Indian nationalism, the Muslim League was more concerned with religious separatism, advocating the establishment of a separate religious homeland within the boundaries of British India for the country’s minority Muslim population.

It was somewhat remarkable, then, that the two groups were able to put aside their differences in signing the Lucknow Pact, an agreement that allowed the representation of religious minorities in the provincial legislatures. To the surprise of many, Hindus and Muslims had joined forces to support common political goals. This held out the prospect of a peaceful transition to an independent India in which all religious communities would have a place.

By adopting a common stance, the Indian National Congress and the Muslim League were more effective in presenting their demands to the British colonial authorities. To a large extent, continued British rule in India depended on divisions between Hindus and Muslims, whose relations had traditionally been tense, to say the least. But once the Indian National Congress and Muslim League had signed the Lucknow Pact, it became more difficult for the British to rely on divide-and-rule tactics in administering India.

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

The Lucknow Pact played an important role in:

  • Improving cooperation between the British and the society in India
  • Improving relations between the Muslim League and the Indian National Congress
  • Reducing conflict between the extremist faction of Congress and the moderate faction of Congress

The Lucknow Pact was a resolution reached between the Indian National Congress and the Muslim League to create a more liberal approach to the governance of the country. The pact also addressed issues related to Hindu-Muslim relations in the country. Additionally, the resolutions were shared with the British as part of the society's proposal.

Among some of the changes made included:

  • Half the executive council members were to be elected by the councils
  • The Legislative Council was also to have most members elected
  • One-third positions were allocated to Muslims in the Councils despite population proportions
  • Changes made to the law that affected sections of the society had to get majority support from those affected by the changes

The agreement also helped India in organizing unified movements towards the achievement of the country's independence.

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

The Indian National Congress and the Muslim League met in a joint conference for the first time in 1916 at Lucknow. The greatest significance of the Lucknow Pact is that it brought together these two groups: the Indian National Congress that claimed to represent all of India, and the Muslim League that was formed to counter the Congress's overarching claim. 

At that joint conference, the Hindu and Muslim leaders were able to resolve their own differences and agreed to jointly pressure the British government to allow India more home rule. At the time, the two groups fully expected the constitutional reforms they jointly presented to their British colonial rulers to be enacted after World War I ended. 

The pact was an important move toward Indian independence during the nationalist movement in Indian, but the unity between Hindus and Muslims was short-lived. Most of the Congress leaders who voted for the Lucknow Pact rescinded their support not long after it was passed. In 1918, the INC joined the Indian Franchise Committee (also know as the Southborough Committee), one of three committees led by British representatives, that worked out the details of post-World War I constitutional reforms for India.

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team