Politics and Corruption in the Gilded Age

Start Your Free Trial

What was George Plunkitt's (Political Boss, late 1800's) attitude towards reform? This is contrasting or comparing the view that politicians had on reform to the view that industrialists had.  I've...

What was George Plunkitt's (Political Boss, late 1800's) attitude towards reform?

This is contrasting or comparing the view that politicians had on reform to the view that industrialists had.  I've read the piece "I seen my opportunities and I took 'em," and it seems like he liked the status quo. Am I missing something?

Expert Answers info

pohnpei397 eNotes educator | Certified Educator

calendarEducator since 2009

write35,413 answers

starTop subjects are History, Literature, and Social Sciences

I assume that you are talking about an excerpt from Plunkitt's book that is similar to the one presented in the historymatters link below.  If so, you are quite right -- Plunkitt is saying that there is no need to reform the political system so as to get rid of political machines such as Tammany Hall.

In this excerpt, Plunkitt makes a distinction between "dishonest" graft (which he says is bad) and "honest graft" which is good.  He says that he and the rest of Tammany Hall only indulge in "honest graft."  He says that dishonest graft is doing things like extorting money from people or stealing money from the public treasury.  By contrast, what he does is, essentially, insider trading.  He says he simply uses his knowledge of what the city is going to do (build a bridge, etc) to make himself rich.

So you are not missing anything.  Plunkitt really does not think that reform is necessary.

check Approved by eNotes Editorial

Unlock This Answer Now