What views of life and its meaning are in conflict in the story "Sonny's Blues"?

Expert Answers
booboosmoosh eNotes educator| Certified Educator

In James Baldwin's "Sonny's Blues," the most dominant conflicts in the story are those faced by each brother with his personal demons (man vs. self), those that arise between the brothers (man vs. man), and the difficulties both of the brothers face to survive in the world (man vs. society).

The narrator believes that in order to endure (as his parents had before him) in the white, male-dominated society of the 1950s, he must be educated and find a job that is socially acceptable for a black man. He becomes a teacher. Sonny is a different man and cannot take the same path as his brother. He is a musician; unfortunately, life becomes much more difficult when he becomes addicted to heroin. The brothers separate for many years (man vs. man). 

In this regard, society presents each man with a choice: conform and survive, or refuse and suffer.

The narrator and Sonny face the conflict of man vs. society. The narrator views conformity as something that will guide him and allow him to subsist in the America of the day. Because of this choice, the narrator has little freedom. In fact, it is not until the story ends that the narrator recognizes the absence of freedom. The narrator's decision has put him at odds with Sonny, and the narrator does not understand how Sonny has made such different decisions. 

Sonny carries a darkness in him from his childhood. He is unable to conform to society's expectations. Instead, he pursues a life playing jazz and becomes addicted to heroin. Sonny cannot accept the role society offers him; he cannot find meaning in conforming to a society that does not understand him or foster his desire to be different. Playing jazz doesn't offer much success or relief from the pain of his past, growing up in Harlem amidst the invasive darkness of the lives of his parents and their friends. While the narrator represses his pain inside, Sonny is unable to face it or ignore it and resorts to the use of heroin. 

In an era when a black man has no control over any aspect of his life, Sonny starts using heroin because, as he says,

It makes you feel—in control. Sometimes you've got to have that feeling.

Sonny's view of life differs from his brother's; he is unwilling to adjust to a society that makes few provisions for people of color. (This causes the conflict of man vs. man.) Sonny's choice against conformity creates inner turmoil (man vs. self). His drug use allows him to survive emotionally and mentally (though he spends time in jail for dealing drugs). He struggles to find meaning in life through his music—not a view of life fostered by society. Sonny's decisions create conflict because he is unable to make a living from playing jazz, and the drugs take their toll as well.

However, through Sonny's music, his brother (who has never been able to understand Sonny) is awakened to the victories Sonny experiences in his life decisions. Where the narrator feels unable to communicate with his brother and struggles with pain from the past, Sonny finds a place, if only temporarily, that allows him for short periods of time to return to a time in younger life where the world was kept at bay by "the older folks," as they hid the darkness of their lives and their meager existence from the awareness of their children. Jazz takes Sonny on a journey; by the end of the music, it has set him (and his brother) free:

Then he began to make [the melody] his. It was very beautiful...it was no longer a lament. I seemed to hear with what burning he had made it his, with what burning we had yet to make it ours, how we could cease lamenting. Freedom lurked around us and I understood at last, that he could help us to be free if we would listen, that he would never be free until we did...I heard what he had gone through, and would continue to go through until he came to rest in the earth.

The men are presented with a choice: assimilate or make your own way. However, both assimilation and non-conformity come with a price. The narrator's choice creates an inner-conflict as he represses the pain of his past and feels guilt as he struggles with the responsibility of watching over his brother. Sonny chooses to create his own path. He goes to jail (man vs. society); he is estranged from his brother for a number of years (man vs. man); and he struggles with the demons of addiction and his painful past (man vs. self).

Ironically, however, while the narrator might appear to make the better decision, it is actually Sonny who rises above the circumstances thrust upon him by taking the "road less traveled." His choice provides the narrator with a consciousness of the lament that is the thread of music weaving itself through his life, as well as the knowledge that he can now stop grieving. Sonny's music is also responsible for crafting a place of understanding where his brother can truly see him. Finally, it gives Sonny and his brother the ability to experience freedom, even if only for a short time, pushing all the conflicts momentarily away and creating a place where only the music has true meaning in their lives of struggle.

mattbuckley eNotes educator| Certified Educator

In James Baldwin's short story "Sonny's Blues" the two main characters are set up as fantastic character foils. The are brothers but very different in the way they view life and the world. The narrator, Sonny's brother, is very conservative. He does not take many chances in life. He has taken a steady respectable job as a teacher and has a family. He has tried to take care of Sonny as much as he can, as he feels an older brother should; however he has forgotten to support Sonny in what Sonny wants to do. He tries to get Sonny to act responsible and to be safe in life like he has.

Sonny is a free spirit, restless and dreaming, he seems to have wandered through life in search of something he is not sure of. He has battled addiction and isolation. He is the younger brother and desperately wants the narrators approval. Sonny has dreams of being a musician and his brother thinks this ridiculous. When Sonny tells his brother of this dream, the narrator responds saying, "you know people can't always do exactly what they want to do -". Sonny then replies, "No, I don't know that . . . I think people aught to do what they want to do, what else are they alive for?" This quote shows the difference in the way each character views life.

jameadows eNotes educator| Certified Educator

The narrator of the story has a view that life means something, as does the promise of his brother, Sonny. When Sonny was little, the narrator saw a great deal of promise in Sonny. After finding out that his brother has been arrested for selling and using heroin, the narrator is incredulous. As the narrator believes in a constructive view of life and in people's promise, he struggles to make sense of what happened to his brother. The kids around the narrator, however, struggle with a sense of nihilism, or believing in nothing. They sense the "low ceiling of their actual possibilities," as Baldwin writes, and the promise of their lives seems to go out of them. Though Sonny and many of the kids in Harlem succumb to this sense of nihilism, the narrator keeps hoping for something better. His father and mother were the same way; his father died while looking for "something a little bit better." It is the constant fight against nihilism that frames the narrator's life, while Sonny is sucked under in the fight.

Read the study guide:
Sonny's Blues

Access hundreds of thousands of answers with a free trial.

Start Free Trial
Ask a Question